{
  "papers": [
    {
      "paper_id": "76638",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "BraiNCA: brain-inspired neural cellular automata and applications to morphogenesis and motor control",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Tolerance of defective parts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "brain-inspired neural cellular automaton (BraiNCA)",
          "claim": "Attention-gated NCAs with long-range edges show more damage-tolerant self-organization than purely local vanilla NCAs.",
          "quote": "can yield more sample-efficient and damage-tolerant self-organization than purely local, grid-based update rules",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range communication accelerating learning",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "brain-inspired neural cellular automaton (BraiNCA), morphogenesis task",
          "claim": "Long-range connections and larger neighbourhood integration independently speed convergence to a target morphology.",
          "quote": "both architectural modifications-long-range connections and larger grid sizes-contribute independently and synergistically to improved learning efficiency",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Division of labour and specialization",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "neural cellular automaton controlling Lunar Lander",
          "claim": "Somatotopic regional partitioning of the NCA grid into functional zones improves robustness and learning speed in motor control.",
          "quote": "This spatial specialization appears to yield more robust task performance and faster speed of learning relative to standard Vanilla",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective motor control",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "neural cellular automaton controlling Lunar Lander",
          "claim": "A decentralized NCA learns to control a simulated lander via spatially aggregated cell votes on actions.",
          "quote": "We benchmark the BraiNCA architecture on two tasks, morphogenesis and motor control experiments.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76639",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "The Artificial Experimentalist: Discovery and Control of Self-Organizing Phenomena with Autotelic Reinforcement Learning",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Lenia continuous cellular automaton steered by RL agent (CARL)",
          "claim": "Brief sparse perturbations redirect a soliton which then continues along the new heading unassisted.",
          "quote": "the agent learns to apply a brief perturbation that redirects it, then withdraws, allowing the soliton to continue along the new heading unassisted",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Lenia solitons controlled by goal-conditioned RL agent",
          "claim": "Self-organizing Lenia patterns can be created and steered via minimal, local perturbations by a learned controller.",
          "quote": "learns a goal-conditioned policy to intervene in a complex system through minimal, local perturbations",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Zero-shot environment transfer",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "RL agent controlling Lenia",
          "claim": "Policies trained across diverse goals and rules generalize zero-shot to out-of-distribution update rules and solitons.",
          "quote": "the agents acquire policies that generalize zero-shot to various out-of-distribution conditions",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical goals and subgoals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human-in-the-loop RL agent steering Lenia solitons through mazes",
          "claim": "High-level directional commands from a human are translated by the agent into low-level interventions, suggesting hierarchical control.",
          "quote": "Such integration suggests a path toward hierarchical control, where higher-level agents or processes set subgoals for lower-level controllers.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Autonomous discovery of self-maintaining patterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Lenia with autotelic RL agent",
          "claim": "The agent discovers self-sustaining solitons across many update rules at higher rates than heuristic baselines.",
          "quote": "CARL discovers stable solitons across a wide range of Lenia update rules at a higher rate than heuristic baselines",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76640",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Agnosiophobia in a virtual agent: behavior and dynamical architecture in Lenia",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Avoidance of missing sensory information",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Lenia creatures (virtual patterns)",
          "claim": "Lenia creatures reorient away from occluded regions lacking information, without any mechanism designed for this.",
          "quote": "despite having no mechanism designed for the task, we observed a pattern we call agnosiophobia - reorientation away from these regions",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Lenia creatures",
          "claim": "Creatures recover the same morphology after perturbation (partial equifinality) while heading varies, enabling navigation.",
          "quote": "Our creatures are equifinal with respect to morphology, but the heading they recover to depends on the perturbation, and is hence non-equifinal.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Recovery through morphological change",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Lenia creature K4s",
          "claim": "Some creatures transiently transform into a different oscillating shape and re-emit in the opposite direction when facing occlusion.",
          "quote": "K4s transforms into a distinct shape, an oscillating structure, and re-emits in the opposite direction",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-preservation of morphology as goal",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Lenia creatures",
          "claim": "Changes of heading serve the more fundamental goal of preserving the creature's own morphology.",
          "quote": "Lenia creatures taking advantage of their freedom to change heading in order to achieve what appears to be a more fundamental goal: the preservation of their morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Basin geometry mapping by targeted perturbation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "Lenia creatures",
          "claim": "Targeted occlusions at each body pixel map recovery time, distortion and heading change, revealing the creature's cognitive basin.",
          "quote": "The targeted occlusions of the previous section map the geometry of each creature's cognitive basin.",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76643",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Defining Life: A Conversation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Kinematic self-replication",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots (frog-cell constructs)",
          "claim": "A participant notes in passing that xenobots supplied with dissociated cells assemble further xenobots.",
          "quote": "Xenobots given a feedstock of cells make more xenobots.",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ],
      "note": "Definitional email conversation on life; only one concrete capability claim (a participant's passing report of xenobot replication); definitional statements not coded."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76644",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "What Lives? A Meta-Analysis of Diverse Opinions on the Definition of Life",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "LLM-based clustering of expert definitions of life; methodological meta-analysis, definitions are not claims that a system achieves a capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76645",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Diverse Intelligences—The Space of Possible Minds: Commentary",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Goal-directed perception-action loops",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "all active agents (biological, cyborg, AI)",
          "claim": "All agents, whatever their substrate, share goal-directed loops of action and perception and finite perspectives.",
          "quote": "share crucial, never-changing functions like goal-directed loops of action and perception, vulnerabilities to external damage",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Creative reassembly in understanding",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "humans and AI systems",
          "claim": "Understanding relies on creative reassembly of concepts rather than certain grounding in direct experience.",
          "quote": "Creative reassembling, not certainty, is a key part of intelligence.",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ],
      "note": "Commentary essay on diverse intelligence and AI ethics; competency content is conceptual."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76647",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Cognitive glues are shared models of relative scarcities: the economics of collective intelligence",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Resource allocation from local scarcity signals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "economy/price system as model of cellular collectives",
          "claim": "The price system acts as cognitive glue, coordinating mutually compatible plans by signalling relative scarcities.",
          "quote": "We identify the price system as the cognitive glue of the economy by acting as a coordinating affordance that enables members to form plans that are mutually compatible.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stress sharing and influence radius",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "economy and multicellular bodies",
          "claim": "Prices propagate one agent's stress to others, motivating them to adjust in ways that solve the original agent's problem.",
          "quote": "prices have shared the stress from the original person to all other buyers in the market",
          "page": 23,
          "page_end": 23
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective credit assignment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular organisms and economies",
          "claim": "Collective intelligences must solve credit assignment, which stress and reward sharing achieve.",
          "quote": "Any collective intelligence must solve the problem of credit assignment [92].",
          "page": 22,
          "page_end": 23
        },
        {
          "name": "Cooperation supported by competition",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells in bodies and agents in economies",
          "claim": "Competition among similar members keeps prices/signals honest and enables cooperative collective outcomes.",
          "quote": "competition has been shown to be vital to achieving cooperative outcomes [144,145]",
          "page": 27,
          "page_end": 27
        },
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "collectives of cells or humans",
          "claim": "When members' plans are mutually compatible the collective becomes internally coherent and can be modelled as an agent.",
          "quote": "the collective system may fruitfully be modelled as an agent in itself, justifying the term 'collective intelligence'",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Memory optimised for salience over fidelity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "diverse biological intelligences",
          "claim": "Biological memory reinterprets engrams creatively, optimizing salience rather than exact fidelity.",
          "quote": "it optimizes for salience, not fidelity, of information on the evolutionary, developmental and behavioural scales",
          "page": 23,
          "page_end": 24
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76648",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Brains and where else? Mapping theories of consciousness to unconventional embodiments",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Aneural learning and memory",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "immune cells, cardiomyocytes",
          "claim": "Non-neural cells show sensitization, learned responses and long-term memory analogous to neural memory.",
          "quote": "Immune cells can be sensitized, display learned responses, and encode long-term memories reflective of a history of exposure to specific pathogens",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Anticipation of future events",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "plants",
          "claim": "Plants show anticipatory responses and game-theoretic decisions weighing resources and kin status.",
          "quote": "plants display anticipatory responses and even gametheoretic decision-making capabilities that weigh the availability of resources with kin status of neighboring organisms",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Consciousness in unconventional embodiments",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells, tissues, organoids, synthetic systems",
          "claim": "Functional principles of most theories of consciousness are not brain-specific and could apply to aneural collectives.",
          "quote": "the focus on brains is more driven by convention and limitations of imagination than by any specific content of existing ToCs",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric scaling of cognitive light cones",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular bodies",
          "claim": "Bioelectric networks align cells toward larger cognitive light cones in abstract problem spaces.",
          "quote": "working together by means of a bioelectric network which aligns them toward larger cognitive light cones in abstract problem spaces",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 16
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76649",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Topological constraints on self-organization in locally interacting systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Coordination range and topology constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Potts model, autoregressive models and hierarchical networks on graphs",
          "claim": "Graph topology of local interactions determines whether a system can maintain long-range ordered target states.",
          "quote": "we discuss necessary conditions on the topology of the graph for an ordered phase to exist",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Multiscale hierarchical self-organisation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "hierarchical networks vs autoregressive language models",
          "claim": "Hierarchical multiscale systems can organise into complex patterns whereas autoregressive language models fail to keep long-range order.",
          "quote": "multiscale systems like those prevalent in biology are capable of organising into complex patterns, whereas rudimentary language models are challenged by long sequences of outputs",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-modifying the problem environment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biological collectives (stigmergy)",
          "claim": "Interaction with an environment (stigmergy, external cues) is hypothesised to help collectives maintain coherence.",
          "quote": "We hypothesise this explains why stigmergy and other forms of extracellular signalling arise in biological systems",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76650",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Bioelectrical Interfaces Beyond Excitable Cells: Cancer, Aging, and Gene Expression Modulation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of pattern and homeostasis",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "non-excitable cells and tissues",
          "claim": "Bioelectric states of non-excitable cells regulate developmental patterning, tissue homeostasis, regeneration and disease.",
          "quote": "bioelectricity in non-excitable cells governs key phenomena, including developmental patterning, tissue homeostasis, and disease progression",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric signatures of cancer and senescence",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "tumour microenvironments, senescent cells",
          "claim": "Spatial Vmem variation correlates with metastatic potential and is proposed as a readout/target for cancer and aging interventions.",
          "quote": "spatial variations in membrane potential within tumor microenvironments were found to correlate with metastatic potential",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ],
      "note": "Perspective on bioelectronic interface technologies for non-excitable cells; competency content limited."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76652",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Heuristically Adaptive Diffusion-Model Evolutionary Strategy",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Improving search through experience",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "diffusion-model-based evolutionary algorithm (HADES)",
          "claim": "A continually retrained diffusion model gives evolution a memory of past elites, enabling faster adaptation in changing environments.",
          "quote": "allows the generative process to utilize previously experienced information, thus enabling faster adaptation in changing environments",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Allostasis and changing targets",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "diffusion-model evolutionary strategy on dynamic numerical optimization",
          "claim": "The method shows improved adaptability to changing fitness environments while still converging to targets.",
          "quote": "report significant improvements in adaptability to changing environments while maintaining reliable convergence to target solutions",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Conditional steering of evolutionary search",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "conditional diffusion-model evolutionary strategy (CHARLES-D)",
          "claim": "Classifier-free guidance biases search toward desired fitness, phenotypic traits or diversity without reward shaping.",
          "quote": "we can utilize conditional sampling in DMs to directly bias the evolutionary search dynamics, steering it towards regions in the parameter space that exhibit desired target traits",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Maintaining exploratory diversity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "diffusion-model evolutionary strategy",
          "claim": "Novelty-conditioning and memory buffers preserve population diversity while converging to high fitness.",
          "quote": "achieving efficient convergence toward highfitness solutions while preserving explorative diversity",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76653",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Engineered Living Systems With Self-Organizing Neural Networks: From Anatomy to Behavior and Gene Expression",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus neurobots (ectodermal explants with implanted neural precursors)",
          "claim": "Implanted neural precursors differentiate and self-organize into neural networks within an evolutionarily novel motile body.",
          "quote": "neural precursor cells implanted in explanted Xenopus ectodermal tissue develop into mature neurons, extending processes both toward the surface and among each other",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Shape-function coupling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus neurobots",
          "claim": "Neural growth alters bot shape (elongation) and multiciliated cell distribution, and neurobots move with more complex trajectories.",
          "quote": "the more elongated the bot, the more neural expression, suggesting that the elongation could be a result of neural processes growing within the neurobot",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Behavioural complexity in synthetic organisms",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus neurobots vs biobots",
          "claim": "Neurobots show more complex movement trajectories than non-neural biobots, quantified via a spectral complexity index.",
          "quote": "we found that neurobots showed a significantly higher degree of trajectory complexity compared to biobots",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus neurobots vs biobots exposed to PTZ",
          "claim": "A seizure-inducing drug reduces movement complexity in biobots but tends to increase it in neurobots.",
          "quote": "we found a significant difference between neurobots and biobots, with neurobots showing significantly higher values for relative complexity",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Atavistic gene expression shift",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus neurobots transcriptomics",
          "claim": "Neurobots show increased transcript variability and a shift toward expression of evolutionarily ancient genes.",
          "quote": "Transcriptomics reveals increased transcript variability, expression of genes related to nervous system development, a shift toward ancient genes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76654",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Mind Everywhere: A Framework for Conceptualizing Goal-Directedness in Biology and Other Domains-Part Two",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Setpoint maintenance without learning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "agents generally (perceptual control loop)",
          "claim": "A minimal agent measures, compares to a setpoint, and acts to minimise error.",
          "quote": "takes measurements, makes comparisons to a setpoint, and tries to minimize error with respect to its setpoint and prior expectations",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells connected by bioelectric networks; animals; humans",
          "claim": "Agents lie on a spectrum of persuadability; bioelectric cell networks can be persuaded by modifying stored information.",
          "quote": "cells connected by bioelectric networks can be persuaded by modifying their stored information",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Kinematic self-replication",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots use a novel means (kinematic replication) to reproduce when normal frog reproduction is unavailable, an example of novelty.",
          "quote": "Xenobots perform kinematic self-replication when the normal frog mode of reproduction is not available to them",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian bioelectric pattern memory",
          "claim": "Planarian tissue stores a bioelectric pattern memory of what to build after injury, which can be rewritten.",
          "quote": "a planarian tissue that stores a bioelectrical pattern memory of what it should build if it gets injured in the future",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Unseen stressor workarounds",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria exposed to barium",
          "claim": "Planaria regenerate a barium-adapted head by changing expression of a few genes to solve a novel stressor.",
          "quote": "quickly regenerate a new, barium-adapted head by finding just a handful of genes among their genome whose upregulation enables them to solve this completely novel physiological stressor",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Cognitive light cone",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "agents at any scale",
          "claim": "Agents are demarcated by the spatiotemporal size of the goals they can pursue.",
          "quote": "Agents are demarcated by a cognitive light cone determined by the spatiotemporal size of the goals they can pursue",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76656",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Top-down perspectives on cell membrane potential and protein transcription",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of gene expression states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectrical model of non-excitable cells with voltage-gated transcription",
          "claim": "Membrane potential shifts drive transitions between gene expression states; polarized cells control expression more effectively.",
          "quote": "shifts in membrane potential allow transitions between gene expression states",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Sensing collective state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "multicellular bioelectric model (central cell plus neighbours)",
          "claim": "A central cell can infer the number and bioelectric state of its neighbours from induced membrane potential changes.",
          "quote": "A central cell is able to measure the number of neighboring cells and learn their bioelectrical state from the downward-induced membrane potential changes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Top-down control of cellular states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric multicellular aggregate model",
          "claim": "With strong gap-junction coupling, the collective bioelectric state reshapes the central cell's transcription (community effect).",
          "quote": "significant top-down effects, demonstrated by the bioelectrical and transcriptional changes, are feasible for strong intercellular connectivity",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric/transcription model",
          "claim": "A two-state bioelectric memory (polarized/depolarized) corresponds to a two-state biochemical memory of protein concentrations.",
          "quote": "the close correspondence of the two-state bioelectrical memory",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric top-down control in regeneration",
          "claim": "Top-down bioelectric triggers could induce modular, self-limiting downstream cascades without micromanagement.",
          "quote": "The ability to induce modular, context-sensitive, and self-limiting cascades without micromanaging the outcomes 46 should be of potential importance to biomedical applications 47 .",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76657",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Neural cellular automata: Applications to biology and beyond classical AI",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "neural cellular automata (growing NCA, voxel robots, Minecraft structures)",
          "claim": "NCAs trained with perturbations learn to persist and regrow target patterns after damage.",
          "quote": "these NCAs learn to persist and selfrepair complex patterns like lizard or emoji shapes, mimicking biological regeneration where local rules enable recovery from unseen injuries",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Recovery through morphological change",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "NCA-controlled soft voxel robots",
          "claim": "Damaged simulated robots regenerate their morphology via local cell interactions, partially recovering locomotion.",
          "quote": "damaged morphologies (e.g., bipeds or tripods) achieved up to 99% structural similarity to originals, with varying locomotion recovery",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Noise and asynchronous update tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "neural cellular automata for morphogenesis",
          "claim": "NCA morphogenesis models show robustness to adversarial noise and changing parameters.",
          "quote": "these systems demonstrate enhanced robustness against adversarial noise, generalizing well to changing system parameters",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Transfer between problem families",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "neural cellular automata",
          "claim": "NCAs show enhanced transferability to modified target patterning objectives.",
          "quote": "exhibit enhanced transferability towards modified target patterning objectives [7, 22]",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Competency buffering genetic selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "evolutionary NCA simulations",
          "claim": "Evolution of NCA-based organisms is strongly shaped by cellular competency at multiple scales.",
          "quote": "found that the evolutionary process is greatly influenced by the cellular competency at several scales [7]",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Aging as loss of maintenance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "evolutionary NCA simulations of aging",
          "claim": "Aging emerges as loss of goal-directedness in morphospace even without genetic damage or noise.",
          "quote": "aging results from loss of goal directedness in morphospace at tissue level, leading to breakdown of collective anatomical homeostasis",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Rejuvenation by local reset",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "NCA aging model",
          "claim": "Aged tissues retain dormant regenerative potential that targeted interventions can reactivate.",
          "quote": "there is dormant regenerative potential in aged tissues, which can be reactivated through targeted interventions",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "NCA model of tadpole craniofacial remodelling",
          "claim": "NCAs model scrambled tadpole craniofacial structures that reorganize to correct anatomy guided by a bioelectric pattern.",
          "quote": "NCAs were used to model disrupted craniofacial structures in tadpoles that subsequently reorganize and achieve correct anatomical configurations",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Combining memories across groups",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "EngramNCA",
          "claim": "Private intracellular memory channels enable decentralized memory storage and transfer and coexisting morphologies.",
          "quote": "enabling decentralized memory storage and transfer while facilitating the emergence of hierarchical and coexisting morphologies [8]",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Abstract reasoning in NCAs",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "neural cellular automata on ARC-AGI-1",
          "claim": "NCAs display generalizing goal-directed dynamics even on abstract reasoning benchmarks.",
          "quote": "NCAs display robust and generalizing goal-directed dynamics without centralized control",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76659",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Bidirectional Communication Between Xenobot Cultures? Toward Collective Intelligence Across Diverse Biological Systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Response to acoustic stimuli",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "basal Xenobots",
          "claim": "Aneural Xenobots sense mechanical/acoustic vibration and alter their movement paths.",
          "quote": "aneural biobots derived from Xenopus embryonic cells (basal Xenobots) are also sensitive to external mechanical cues and alter their movement paths when exposed to acoustic vibration stimuli",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Inter-agent communication via biohybrid translator",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "pairs of Xenobot cultures linked by sonification and a latent translator",
          "claim": "Proof-of-principle bidirectional communication between two Xenobot cultures mediated by sound generated from their trajectories.",
          "quote": "provide proof-of-principle experimental results that demonstrate the viability of bidirectional communication between two Xenobots",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Synchronization and entrainment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "Xenobot pairs",
          "claim": "Mutual information between the Xenobots' heading sequences rises during the communication phase.",
          "quote": "MI is higher during the \"Talking Period\" in all four experiments.",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Acoustic signalling offers a control modality for Xenobot locomotion without genetic editing or sculpting.",
          "quote": "novel control modalities for guiding the cilia-driven Xenobot locomotion in biomedical applications without direct genomic editing, morphological design, or manual sculpting",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76660",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Evolution by natural induction II: further interactions with natural selection",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Natural induction without population selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "networks under stress (GRNs, metabolic networks, ecosystems)",
          "claim": "Networks whose connections give way under stress plus perturbations adapt without population-level selection.",
          "quote": "Natural induction is a different adaptive mechanism from natural selection.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Ecosystem-level adaptation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "single ecosystem modelled as generalised Lotka-Volterra network",
          "claim": "Natural induction can produce ecosystem-level adaptive organisation even with a population of one ecosystem.",
          "quote": "adaptive organisation at the ecosystem level could be provided by natural induction even when there is a 'population of one'",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Evolution of evolvability",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "evolving gene regulatory networks",
          "claim": "Interaction of selection and induction produces evolvability at timescales where selection does not directly apply.",
          "quote": "natural selection does not apply at the relevant timescale for the evolution of evolvability observed",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Pattern completion",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "evolved gene regulatory network",
          "claim": "A single evolved GRN stores several past phenotypes, repairs corrupted ones and generalises to new feature combinations.",
          "quote": "A single evolved GRN can hold a memory of several phenotypes selected in the past, recognise and repair corrupted phenotypes, and generalise to create new combinations of features",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Generalizing to previously unseen solutions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "networks undergoing natural induction",
          "claim": "Natural induction raises the likelihood of visiting new configurations sharing regularities with past ones, i.e. generalisation.",
          "quote": "it also increases the likelihood of visiting other specific configurations - those with similar underlying regularities (generalisation)",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76661",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Evolution by natural induction",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Natural induction without population selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "dynamical networks with stress-yielding connections (GRNs, metabolic networks, ecosystems)",
          "claim": "Stress-induced differential adjustment of connections reorganises a system like associative learning, without natural selection.",
          "quote": "This differential adjustment of connections causes reorganisation of the system's internal structure in a manner equivalent to associative learning familiar in neural networks.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Event counting and multiple memories",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "natural induction networks",
          "claim": "Natural induction suffices for storage and recall of multiple patterns.",
          "quote": "This is sufficient for storage and recall of multiple patterns, learning with generalisation and solving difficult constraint problems",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Escaping local optima",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "natural induction vs natural selection",
          "claim": "Natural induction can find trait combinations resolving constraints better than selection's local adaptive peaks.",
          "quote": "since natural selection naturally finds local adaptive peaks (at best) and natural induction can find combinations of traits that better resolve constraints between component parts",
          "page": 17,
          "page_end": 18
        },
        {
          "name": "Phenotype-first evolution with selection as memory",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "evolving populations with plastic phenotypes",
          "claim": "Natural selection may act as a memory of adaptations first discovered by natural induction.",
          "quote": "natural selection may act not as a source of adaptations but as a memory of adaptations discovered by natural induction",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76662",
      "year": 2026,
      "title": "Atavistic Genetic Expression Dissociation (AGED) During Aging: Meta-Phylostratigraphic Evidence of Cellular and Tissue-Level Phylogenetic Dissociation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Aging as loss of maintenance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "human tissues (aging transcriptomes)",
          "claim": "Aging is framed as breakdown of coordinated morphogenetic control with tissues regressing toward ancestral cellular states.",
          "quote": "aging may result from the breakdown of coordinated morphogenetic control, leading organs and tissues toward less integrated, ancient unicellular states",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Atavistic gene expression shift",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "meta-phylostratigraphic analysis of aging RNA-seq across tissues",
          "claim": "Aging tissues show over-representation of differential expression in the most ancient genes, heterogeneously by tissue.",
          "quote": "An atavistic over-representation of differential expression in the most ancient genes and under-representation in the evolutionary youngest genes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rejuvenation by local reset",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "aging tissues",
          "claim": "Restoring multicellular coherence in evolutionarily youthful gene expression is proposed as a rejuvenation strategy.",
          "quote": "opens new avenues for rejuvenation, focusing on restoring multicellular coherence in evolutionarily youthful gene expression",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76664",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Cognition all the way down 2.0: neuroscience beyond neurons in the diverse intelligence era",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Search efficiency relative to blind search",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "problem-space formalism applied to amoeboid chemotaxis and planarian regeneration",
          "claim": "Intelligence is operationalised as log10 ratio of random-walk cost to agent cost in a problem space.",
          "quote": "this metric is the decimal logarithm of the ratio between the cost of a random walk and that of a biological agent",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Chemotactic navigation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Dictyostelium discoideum (modelled from empirical data)",
          "claim": "Amoeboid chemotaxis reaches targets roughly 150-200 times faster than an unbiased random walk.",
          "quote": "meaning approximately 150-200 times more efficient (corresponding to 7.2-7.6 bits of path-information gain)",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Unseen stressor workarounds",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian Dugesia japonica head regeneration in barium",
          "claim": "Barium-adapted head regeneration finds a viable transcriptional solution ~10^21 times faster than random search.",
          "quote": "yields a search efficiency K = log10(6×10 27 s/3.2×10 6 s) ≈ 21",
          "page": 20,
          "page_end": 20
        },
        {
          "name": "Cognitive glue binding parts into wholes",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells and tissues",
          "claim": "Neuroscience's insights concern policies that act as cognitive glue binding parts into collective intelligences regardless of substrate.",
          "quote": "the deep insights of neuroscience are not about neurons per se, but about the policies and patterns of physics and mathematics that function as a kind of \"cognitive glue\"",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76666",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Identification of brain-like complex information architectures in embryonic tissue of Xenopus laevis organoids",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "basal Xenobots (aneural Xenopus epithelial constructs) calcium imaging",
          "claim": "Basal Xenobots show functional connectivity, higher-order information and dynamic integration comparable to brains.",
          "quote": "display a common set of organizational features and dynamics, including sophisticated functional connectivity networks, higher-order information of multiple types, and dynamic integration of information",
          "page": 23,
          "page_end": 23
        },
        {
          "name": "Integrated information over time",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "basal Xenobots",
          "claim": "Whole-minus-sum integrated information in Xenobot calcium dynamics is significantly greater than null models.",
          "quote": "both the basal Xenobots and the brain had significantly greater dynamic integrated information compared to their respective nulls",
          "page": 20,
          "page_end": 21
        },
        {
          "name": "Brain-like information architecture in aneural tissue",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "basal Xenobots vs human fMRI",
          "claim": "Brain-like patterns of coordinated activity occur in non-neural epithelial tissue.",
          "quote": "these same patterns of coordinated activity are also present in the aneural tissues of evolutionarily distant biological systems",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76667",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Field-mediated bioelectric basis of morphogenetic prepatterning",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Field-mediated collective patterning",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "computational model of non-neural bioelectric network with electrostatic field",
          "claim": "The intrinsic electric field acts as a slow control parameter that enhances complexity of Vmem patterns via negative feedback.",
          "quote": "the electrostatic field contributes to this process, via a synergetics (a` la Haken)-based mechanism, by enhancing the complexity of Vmem patterns",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric tissue model with boundary organizer",
          "claim": "Transient, optimized boundary field stimuli steer the bulk tissue to develop a target face pattern.",
          "quote": "We leveraged these results to prime the system to develop specific target patterns simply by transiently stimulating the field surrounding the boundary of the tissue.",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric tissue models with differing field sensitivity",
          "claim": "Models with weak vs strong field sensitivity reach the same face pattern via mosaic vs stigmergic strategies.",
          "quote": "they developed the face patterns using very different strategies (namely, a mosaic- and stigmergybased mechanism) depending on whether the field sensitivity strength was weak or strong",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-modifying the problem environment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "stigmergic bioelectric patterning model",
          "claim": "In the stigmergic model, cells pattern via the shared field they modify, recapitulating frog craniofacial prepattern development.",
          "quote": "the stigmergic model recapitulates the qualitative developmental sequence of the bioelectric craniofacial prepattern observed in frog embryos",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76668",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Aging as a Loss of Goal-Directedness: An Evolutionary Simulation and Analysis Unifying Regeneration with Anatomical Rejuvenation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Aging as loss of maintenance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "neural cellular automata evolved for homeostatic morphogenesis",
          "claim": "Aging emerges after developmental goals are completed, even without noise or programmed degeneration.",
          "quote": "Aging emerges after developmental goals are completed, even without noise or programmed degeneration",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Latent or counterfactual memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCA aging model",
          "claim": "Spatial information about lost organs persists in tissue, implementing a memory of lost structures.",
          "quote": "Despite organ loss, spatial information persists in tissue, implementing a memory of lost structures, which can be reactivated for organ restoration",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rejuvenation by local reset",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCA aging model",
          "claim": "Resetting only wrongly expressed organ and boundary cells efficiently restores morphology with few interventions.",
          "quote": "an average number of as few as 5 - 6 interventions (in some cases even 1 or 2) suffice to stabilize the morphology",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 17,
          "map_to": "Local repair without global rework"
        },
        {
          "name": "Local repair without global rework",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCA aging model",
          "claim": "Injecting regenerative information only into incorrectly-positioned cells (and their boundary) is more efficient than replacing whole organs.",
          "quote": "rejuvenation is found to be most efficient when regenerative information includes differential patterns of affected cells and their neighboring tissue",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "NCA aging model",
          "claim": "Active information storage and transfer entropy rise with aging, while spatial entropy distinguishes structural loss from noise accumulation.",
          "quote": "Aging correlates with increased active information storage and transfer entropy, while spatial entropy distinguishes two dynamics",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76669",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Temporal depth in a coherent self and in depersonalization: theoretical model",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Temporal depth of the self",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "human self modelled under TAME and free energy principle",
          "claim": "The self's temporal depth (size of its cognitive light cone in time) measures its integration; its collapse underlies dissociation.",
          "quote": "The size of the Self 's cognitive light cone is one of the measures of its complexity - its temporal depth.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Merging and splitting collective identities",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "human self as nested collective intelligence",
          "claim": "Overwhelming lasting stress can disintegrate the self into components with smaller cognitive light cones.",
          "quote": "Such experience is bound to cause the Self 's disintegration - its breakdown into a collection of components, each with a smaller cognitive light cone.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76670",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Sustained Serotonergic Stimulation Platform for Peripheral Axonal Regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Pharmacologically enhanced regeneration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "rat sciatic nerve transection with zolmitriptan (serotonin agonist)",
          "claim": "Sustained serotonergic stimulation increased the fraction of axons regenerating to the distal end after nerve repair.",
          "quote": "80% of the axons successfully extended to the distal end in the Zolmitriptan group, compared with 57% in the control group",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Preclinical regenerative-medicine study; competency content limited to drug-enhanced axonal regeneration."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76671",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Bioelectric characterization of senescing human keratinocytes",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Aging as loss of maintenance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "senescing human keratinocytes",
          "claim": "Senescence is accompanied by depolarization and loss of spatial Vmem organization, supporting morphostatic information loss.",
          "quote": "aging results from breakdown of bioelectrically encoded cues that preserve tissue structure",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric resilience",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "senescent human keratinocytes",
          "claim": "Senescent cells show reduced responsiveness to hyperpolarizing drug and impaired bioelectric resilience.",
          "quote": "Senescent cells showed reduced responsiveness to hyperpolarizing drug pinacidil and impaired bioelectric resilience.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric domain formation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human keratinocyte cultures",
          "claim": "Late-stage senescent cultures lose the ability to form distinct spatial Vmem domains.",
          "quote": "Senescence was marked by depolarization, increased inter-culture heterogeneity, reduced intra-culture variability, and loss of spatial Vmem organization.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human keratinocytes",
          "claim": "Bioelectric modulation shifts senescence phenotypes: hyperpolarization attenuates and depolarization exacerbates them.",
          "quote": "Hyperpolarization attenuated, and depolarization exacerbated, senescenceassociated phenotypes.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76673",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Giving Simulated Cells a Voice: Evolving Prompt-to-Intervention Models for Cellular Control",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Language-directed control of cell collectives",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated 2D cellular collective steered by LLM plus evolved Prompt-to-Intervention network",
          "claim": "Natural-language prompts are translated into spatial vector fields that steer simulated cells to cluster or scatter.",
          "quote": "evolved P2I networks can successfully align cellular dynamics with user-defined goals expressed in plain language",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Interference between conflicting learned behaviours",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Prompt-to-Intervention controller",
          "claim": "Training a single controller on conflicting goals can lead to one behaviour degrading another.",
          "quote": "Training a single P2I model on multiple behaviors-especially those with conflicting goals-can lead to interference, where learning one behavior degrades another.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76674",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Exploring the role of large language models in the scientific method: from hypothesis to discovery",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Review of LLMs in the scientific method; no biological or artificial-system capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76675",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Associative conditioning in gene regulatory network models increases integrative causal emergence",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "biological gene regulatory network models (29 experimentally derived)",
          "claim": "GRN models are trained to associate distinct stimuli, i.e. associative memory without neurons.",
          "quote": "We analyzed gene regulatory networks, which learn to associate distinct stimuli, using causal emergence",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Learning-induced causal emergence",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "biological GRN models vs random networks",
          "claim": "Associative training increases integrative causal emergence in most biological networks, more than in random controls.",
          "quote": "causal emergence was strengthened in 17 out of 19 networks. The change amounted, on average, to a 128.32±81.31% increase from before to after training.",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "gene regulatory network models",
          "claim": "Causal emergence (integrated information decomposition) quantifies how much a system is more than the sum of its parts.",
          "quote": "causal emergence, which captures the degree to which an integrated system is more than the sum of its parts",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective credit assignment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular organisms (rat lever-press example) and GRNs",
          "claim": "An emergent agent binds experiences of different parts into one associative memory no part has alone.",
          "quote": "The \"rat\" is the owner of the associative memory that none of its parts can have.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Discrete classes of training response",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "biological GRN models",
          "claim": "Networks fall into five discrete 'species' of emergence trajectories under training, correlated with biological categories.",
          "quote": "We found five optimal \"species\" of behavior and nicknamed them homing, inflating, deflating, spiky, and steppy",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76676",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "The Bioelectrics of Immortality and Mortality in Cold-Sensitive Hydra oligactis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric signatures of aging",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Hydra oligactis (immortal vs aging mortal)",
          "claim": "Immortal and old mortal hydra have distinct whole-body Vmem patterns, consistent with a bioelectric component of aging.",
          "quote": "the different bioelectric patterns of immortal versus old mortal hydra are consistent with a bioelectric component to the aging process",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric prepattern of body regions",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Hydra oligactis whole-body Vmem imaging",
          "claim": "Immortal hydra show a consistently depolarized foot forming a bioelectrically distinct region.",
          "quote": "The consensus whole-body bioelectric atlas of immortal hydra shows a consistently depolarized foot and occasionally depolarized tentacles.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76677",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Universal multilayer network embedding reveals a causal link between GABA neurotransmitter and cancer",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Network-embedding method for drug/disease link prediction; the Xenopus GABA-cancer check is method validation, not a capability claim."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76679",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Harnessing the analog computing power of regulatory networks with the Regulatory Network Machine",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "gene regulatory network models analysed as Regulatory Network Machines (ESC network)",
          "claim": "Multistable GRNs retain long-lasting output changes after a transient input, so future behaviour depends on past experience.",
          "quote": "multistable RNMs can have future behavior depend on their past experience to maintain a long-lasting, or even permanent, change to their outputs",
          "page": 17,
          "page_end": 18
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "GRN models (RNM framework)",
          "claim": "Identical-looking systems in different held input contexts respond to the same intervention with categorically different final states.",
          "quote": "lead to categorically different responses to the same perturbing event/intervention",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 18
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "MAPK cancer cell fate Boolean network",
          "claim": "Network finite state machines identify sequences of transient inputs that drive cells from cancer-like states to normal states (renormalization).",
          "quote": "providing easy identification of specific applied interventions necessary to achieve desired, stable biological outcomes",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Intelligence potential of regulatory networks",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "gene regulatory networks",
          "claim": "Intelligence potential sums multistate and context ratios, indicating capacity for memory and context-dependent behaviour.",
          "quote": "We define the IP of a network as the sum of two parameters: i) the Multistate Ratio, (MR) and ii) the Context Ratio (CR).",
          "page": 30,
          "page_end": 30
        },
        {
          "name": "Analog computation in regulatory networks",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "gene regulatory networks",
          "claim": "GRNs behave as analog computers whose equilibrium transitions encode sequential logic.",
          "quote": "demonstrating how GRNs behave as analog computers capable of sophisticated information processing",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76680",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "What does evolution make? Learning in living lineages and machines",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Multiscale competency architecture",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biological organisms at all scales",
          "claim": "Components at each scale competently navigate their own problem domains and shape each other's behaviour toward homeodynamic goals.",
          "quote": "components competently navigate problem domains (e.g., metabolic, physiological, transcriptional, and anatomical)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Genome as generative model",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "developmental genetics viewed through ML",
          "claim": "The genome acts as a generative model rather than a blueprint, with physiology adding plasticity and robustness.",
          "quote": "The genome acts as a generative model, not a hardwired algor ithm nor a blueprint, for species-speci fic form and function.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian flatworms",
          "claim": "Brief bioelectric drug exposure rewrites planarian pattern memory to a permanent two-headed target morphology without genetic change.",
          "quote": "When rewritten using brief exposure to bioelectric-modifying drugs, the pattern memory can be changed into a two-headed form",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole",
          "claim": "A potassium-channel-induced bioelectric state induces ectopic eyes even outside the Pax6 competency zone.",
          "quote": "the ectopic eye on the gut of a tadpole (C, red arrowhead) induced by injection of a potassium channel",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "NCA-grown robotic morphologies",
          "claim": "NCAs grow functional robot bodies from sensory, messenger and motor cells that solve behavioural problems via decentralized coordination.",
          "quote": "NCAs can grow functional robotic morphologies (by self-assembling synthetic sensory, messenger, and motor cells) that display behavioral problemsolving capabilities",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76681",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "AI-enabled drug prediction and gene network analysis reveal therapeutic use of vorinostat for Rett Syndrome in preclinical models",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Network-level phenotype normalization",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus and MeCP2-null mouse Rett syndrome models treated with vorinostat",
          "claim": "A single repurposed drug restores multiple CNS and non-CNS abnormalities even when dosed after symptom onset.",
          "quote": "vorinostat, which broadly improves both CNS and non-CNS (e.g., gastrointestinal, respiratory, inflammatory) abnormalities in X. laevis and MeCP2-null mice",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "AI-assisted drug repurposing study; competency content limited to systemic phenotype rescue."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76682",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "The Morphological, Behavioral, and Transcriptomic Life Cycle of Anthrobots",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots (adult human airway epithelial cells)",
          "claim": "Wild-type adult human cells self-assemble into motile constructs with their own morphogenesis and life history.",
          "quote": "wild-type adult human cells self-assemble into an active living construct with its own distinct transcriptome, morphogenesis, and life history",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots",
          "claim": "After needle damage most Anthrobots flex and return to their original spheroid shape within minutes.",
          "quote": "Out of the 23 Anthrobots that were time-lapsed immediately after being damaged, 16 showed recovery to their original spheroid shape",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots",
          "claim": "Anthrobots self-construct through distinct developmental routes (dormant, merger expander, monoclonal expander).",
          "quote": "which we named as dormant, merger expander, and monoclonal expander",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Rejuvenation by local reset",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots",
          "claim": "Morphogenesis into Anthrobots reduces the cells' epigenetic (methylation clock) age.",
          "quote": "the process of development into bots reduced their epigenetic age by 25%",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Atavistic gene expression shift",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots transcriptomics",
          "claim": "Assembly drives massive gene-expression remodelling including embryonic patterning genes and more ancient genes.",
          "quote": "a shift toward more evolutionarily ancient gene expression",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Sustained motility until death",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots",
          "claim": "Anthrobots keep moving at steady frequency as they age, stopping only at death, with no immobile elderly phase.",
          "quote": "we found no evidence of an increasing elderly, fully immobile phase of life",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76684",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Neuroevolution of decentralized decision-making in $${\\boldsymbol{N}}$$-bead swimmers leads to scalable and robust collective locomotion",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Collective locomotion from identical local rules",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "N-bead microswimmer with bead-level ANN controllers (neuroevolution)",
          "claim": "Efficient swimming gaits emerge from decentralized, bead-specific decisions with only local information.",
          "quote": "efficient locomotion emerges from coordinated yet simple and decentralized decision-making of the body parts",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "N-bead microswimmers",
          "claim": "Policies evolved for one bead count transfer without retraining to swimmers with very different numbers of beads.",
          "quote": "policies optimized for an NT-bead microswimmer are in most cases also highly effective for (N ̸= NT)-bead morphologies, even if N ≫ NT or vice versa",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Tolerance of defective parts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "N-bead microswimmers",
          "claim": "Decentralized policies remain effective when arms are locked by passive cargo beads, enabling cargo transport out of the box.",
          "quote": "While the presence of cargo beads significantly restrain the neighboring beads from adapting the adjacent arm-length, essentially locking the corresponding arm, the remaining functional beads self-propel the entire microswimmer effectively.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Unselected damage tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "N-bead microswimmers",
          "claim": "Robustness to morphological change emerged without being explicitly optimized for.",
          "quote": "Notably, we did not explicitly optimize for this property at all, but it is an emergent phenomenon of the inherent decentralized decision-making of the system.",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76685",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Life, its origin, and its distribution: a perspective from the Conway-Kochen Theorem and the Free Energy Principle",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Persistence as minimal Bayesian agency",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "all time-persistent dynamical systems (Conway-Kochen theorem, Free Energy Principle)",
          "claim": "All complex systems that persist through time can be characterized as Bayesian agents, erasing a bright line between physical and cognitive.",
          "quote": "contemporary physics characterizes all complex dynamical systems that persist through time as Bayesian agents",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Error correction, learning and memory in molecular systems",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "macromolecules, biochemical pathways, cells",
          "claim": "Complex multicomponent systems like pathways and cells exhibit error correction, learning and memory.",
          "quote": "biochemical pathways, or cells are significantly cognitive, exhibiting features such as error correction, learning, and memory [22]",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ],
      "note": "Theoretical perspective on origin of life and cognition."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76686",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Artificial Intelligences: A Bridge Toward Diverse Intelligence and Humanity's Future",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Continuum from physics to mind",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryogenesis and evolution",
          "claim": "Development and evolution show a gradual continuum from chemistry to cognition with no sharp line.",
          "quote": "the journey from physics to psychology is ubiquitous and gradual, dissolving sharp philosophical categories and revealing a continuum between matter and mind",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Homeostatic healing capacity exploited by medicine",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells and tissues",
          "claim": "Medicine often relies on prompting tissues and leaving their homeostatic problem-solving capacities to heal.",
          "quote": "a process that relies on the homeostatic and problem-solving capacities of cells and tissues",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Merging and splitting collective identities",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "humans as composite systems",
          "claim": "Humans are composite systems of cooperating and competing sub-modules, as shown by split-brain and dissociative conditions.",
          "quote": "we are not monolithic, indivisible intelligences but rather systems of interacting, cooperating, and competing sub-modules on many levels of organization",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ],
      "note": "Essay on AI and diverse intelligence; conceptual competency content."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76688",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Basal Xenobot transcriptomics reveals changes and novel control modality in cells freed from organismal influence",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Transcriptional exploration under novel stress",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "basal Xenobots vs age-matched Xenopus embryos",
          "claim": "Xenobots show larger inter-individual gene expression variability, suggesting exploration of transcriptional space in a novel embodiment.",
          "quote": "Basal Xenobots show significantly larger inter-individual gene variability than age-matched embryos, suggesting increased exploration of the transcriptional space.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Atavistic gene expression shift",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "basal Xenobots",
          "claim": "Most transcriptomic shifts in Xenobots are toward evolutionarily ancient transcripts.",
          "quote": "Phylostratigraphy shows a majority of transcriptomic shifts in the basal Xenobots towards evolutionarily ancient transcripts.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Response to acoustic stimuli",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "basal Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots change their motion behaviour in response to acoustic vibration, consistent with upregulated mechanosensory genes.",
          "quote": "We experimentally confirm that basal Xenobots respond to acoustic stimuli via changes in behavior.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Unseen stressor workarounds",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cells facing novel stressors",
          "claim": "Cells facing novel stressors explore gene expression configurations until finding ones that resolve the stress, with different cells finding different solutions.",
          "quote": "cells experiencing novel stressors can randomly change their gene expression profiles until they find configurations that resolve the stress",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76689",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Revealing non-trivial information structures in aneural biological tissues via functional connectivity",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "Xenopus epidermal organoids expressing GCaMP6s",
          "claim": "Mutual-information functional connectivity networks from calcium dynamics reveal non-random structure in aneural tissue.",
          "quote": "We find organoid networks exhibit potential evidence for more connectivity than null models, with our models displaying high degree hubs and mesoscale community structure with spatial clustering.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Injury-induced integration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenopus epidermal organoids after puncture",
          "claim": "After puncture the tissue retains network features and shows increased integration, suggesting coordinated response to injury.",
          "quote": "our results suggest evidence for an increase in integration among cells shortly post- puncture",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 13
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76690",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Uncertainty minimization and pattern recognition in Volvox carteri and V. aureus",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Two-option discrimination",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Volvox aureus and V. carteri",
          "claim": "Volvox preferentially move toward regular rather than randomized light pulse patterns of equal total light.",
          "quote": "a significantly larger proportion of V. aureus were detected in the section adjacent to the fixed interval stimulation than in the section adjacent to the random stimulation",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Frequency-selective response",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Volvox aureus",
          "claim": "V. aureus show a preferential adaptive response to 2 Hz light pulses over other frequencies.",
          "quote": "There was a clear preferential adaptive response to light pulse frequencies of 2 Hz when opposed to smaller and larger pulse frequencies",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Volvox aureus",
          "claim": "Phototactic alignment toward a past light direction persists after the stimulus ends.",
          "quote": "bias towards the previously illuminated side of the well, indicating the persistence of phototactic alignment",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Habituation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Volvox carteri populations exposed for 2 years",
          "claim": "Long-term exposure to patterned or random light abolishes the 1 Hz phototactic bias, a pattern-specific habituation.",
          "quote": "which is evidence of pattern-specific habituation in V. carteri, which is a form of non-associative learning",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Uncertainty minimization in aneural organisms",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Volvox",
          "claim": "Randomized stimuli and unpredictable shocks interfere with photoadaptation, consistent with active-inference uncertainty minimization.",
          "quote": "The detection of functional uncertainty minimization in an aneural organism expands concepts like uncertainty minimization beyond neurons",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76694",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "Bioelectricity is a universal multifaced signaling cue in living organisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian regeneration",
          "claim": "A brief bioelectric alteration permanently rewrites planarian target morphology to two-headed, a memory separate from genetics.",
          "quote": "a temporary (as brief as 3 h) alteration of the bioelectric state gave rise to planaria, which have a permanently altered target morphology",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "amphibian tail and limb regeneration",
          "claim": "A brief bioelectric trigger (sodium ionophore) kickstarts complete regeneration in non-regenerative conditions.",
          "quote": "acting as a brief trigger that kickstarts a complex program of changes in gene expression in anatomy",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cancer models (melanoma, oncogene-induced tumours)",
          "claim": "Cancer reflects failure of bioelectric binding of cells to a common purpose; bioelectric signals can induce or normalize tumours.",
          "quote": "impairments of bioelectrical signaling as defects in the mechanisms that normally bind individual cells to a common purpose in normal tissue and organ morphostasis",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of pattern and homeostasis",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "diverse organisms",
          "claim": "Bioelectricity is an instructive cue for cellular physiology, development, regeneration and disease.",
          "quote": "emerging evidence supports a view of bioelectricity as an instructional signaling cue for fundamental cellular physiology, embryonic development, regeneration, and human diseases",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76696",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Open problems in synthetic multicellularity",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Aneural learning and memory",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "gene regulatory networks, pathways, bacterial biofilms",
          "claim": "Learning occurs without neurons; GRNs and pathways learn without genetic change; biofilms use electrical memory.",
          "quote": "It has been shown that learning in living systems can occur without a neural substrate 93 and that GRNs and pathways can learn with no genetic changes needed 101,102 .",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Division of labour and specialization",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "multicellular organisms",
          "claim": "Multicellular organisms comprise cell types with division of labour and cooperation, unlike autonomous unicells.",
          "quote": "MC organisms consist of various cell types with division of labor and cooperation 1,2 .",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "synthetic multicellular collectives, insect societies",
          "claim": "Collective intelligence yields group solutions not explicable by individuals, potentially engineerable in synthetic constructs.",
          "quote": "the enhanced capacity that emerges from the collective interactions among agents in a group, resulting in solutions that cannot be explained in terms of single individual actions",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Synthetic life cycles",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "snowflake yeast, Anthrobots",
          "claim": "Synthetic multicellular assemblies could develop from single cells and complete reproductive life cycles.",
          "quote": "A minimal synthetic design should include the growth of a whole assembly from a single cell and the potential for some cells in the assembly to leave it",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ],
      "note": "Perspective listing open problems in synthetic multicellularity."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76698",
      "year": 2025,
      "title": "The Multiscale Wisdom of the Body: Collective Intelligence as a Tractable Interface for Next-Generation Biomedicine",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with scrambled craniofacial organs",
          "claim": "Scrambled tadpole faces remodel during metamorphosis into normal frog faces.",
          "quote": "\"scrambled\" tadpole faces remodel during metamorphosis to form a normal frog face",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Switching mechanisms after failure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "polyploid newts with enlarged cells",
          "claim": "Newt kidney tubules use fewer cells, or even a single giant cell wrapping around itself, to build the same structure.",
          "quote": "when the cells are made to be truly gigantic, a single cell may create the tubule, wrapping around and leaving the needed lumen in the middle",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Proportional error correction",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "morphogenetic cell collectives",
          "claim": "Anatomical homeostasis uses feedback loops that measure distance from a target state and act to reduce error.",
          "quote": "large-scale feedback loops exist that measure distance from a given target state and execute diverse molecular steps to implement those goals (reduce error)",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Group-to-group assistance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos in large groups (hyperembryo)",
          "claim": "Embryos in large groups form a hyperembryo that resists teratogens better than individuals.",
          "quote": "an ability to solve teratogenic challenges far better than individual embryos (or small groups) exhibit [197]",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "tadpole and frog regeneration",
          "claim": "The same systemic electroceutical triggers tails at tail wounds and legs at leg wounds; specificity lies in the responding collective.",
          "quote": "the exact same electroceutical-monensin-triggers tails in tail wounds and legs at leg wounds",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cell collectives (planarian example)",
          "claim": "Rewriting setpoints rather than forcing states gains the system's buy-in and avoids compensatory resistance.",
          "quote": "one powerful way to achieve complex goals is to rewrite the setpoints, as described above for planarian regeneration",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "State-dependent valence",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "homeostatic loops in development",
          "claim": "Homeostatic loops implement valence and preferences, making birth defects failures to reach a target.",
          "quote": "A remarkable fact about homeostatic loops is that they implement valence (desirable outcomes) and preferences [98, 99].",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76699",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Multicellular adaptation to electrophysiological perturbations analyzed by deterministic and stochastic bioelectrical models",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Unseen stressor workarounds",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "deterministic and stochastic bioelectrical models of multicellular aggregates",
          "claim": "Cells compensate a blocked cation channel by upregulating a rescue channel that restores polarization, adapting to a novel stressor.",
          "quote": "short-term bioelectrical perturbations can trigger long-term biochemical adaptations to novel stressors in multicellular aggregates",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectrical cell model",
          "claim": "Using membrane potential as a master regulator, cells correct errors with a small subset of channels rather than tuning every channel.",
          "quote": "it can make use of the cell potential 5,16 in an error-correcting mechanism that involves a small subset of the total number of cell channels",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Generalizing to previously unseen solutions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planaria exposed to barium; bioelectric models",
          "claim": "A novel stressor can elicit responses evolved for its general class (depolarizing agents).",
          "quote": "responses to a general class of stressors (cell depolarizing agents here) can be elicited by a novel particular member of that class",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Whole-group context sensitivity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "multicellular bioelectric aggregate",
          "claim": "Adaptation can involve a population-level community effect of polarized cells beyond single-cell responses.",
          "quote": "At the multicellular level, it is suggested here that the adaptation can also involve a population-level process where the community effect of the polarized cells",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76702",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Natural Induction: Spontaneous Adaptive Organisation without Natural Selection",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Natural induction without population selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "network of viscoelastic connections under occasional disturbances (simulation)",
          "claim": "Recurrent physical optimisation and physical learning produce spontaneous adaptive organisation without selection.",
          "quote": "here we show that the recurrent interaction of physical optimisation and physical learning together results in significant spontaneous adaptive organisation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Improving search through experience",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "viscoelastic spring networks",
          "claim": "The system learns to preferentially visit increasingly low-energy solutions, improving problem-solving with experience.",
          "quote": "it spontaneously learns to preferentially visit solutions of increasingly greater quality (exceptionally low energy)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Escaping local optima",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "viscoelastic spring networks",
          "claim": "Natural induction provides optimisation superior to local relaxation alone.",
          "quote": "it provides optimisation ability that is superior to local optimisation and improves with experience",
          "page": 26,
          "page_end": 26
        },
        {
          "name": "Generalizing to previously unseen solutions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "viscoelastic spring networks",
          "claim": "Connection changes learn a generalised associative model of visited local optima, storing, recalling and generalising configurations.",
          "quote": "the changes to the connections in the network learn a generalised associative model of the local solutions visited",
          "page": 26,
          "page_end": 26
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76703",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Disgust as a primary emotional system and its clinical relevance",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Merging and splitting collective identities",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "amniote blastoderm",
          "claim": "Scratching a blastoderm yields multiple self-organizing embryos; the number of selves emerging is not genetically fixed.",
          "quote": "a single blastoderm is a pool of somatic and cognitive potentiality, from which may emerge 0, 1, or some number of individual Selves",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Self/world boundary determination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryos and organisms (autopoiesis)",
          "claim": "An emergent system must actively determine where it ends and the outside world begins.",
          "quote": "the emergent system must autonomously determine where it ends and the \"outside world\" begins",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Pathogen avoidance as behavioural immunity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "humans (DISGUST emotional system)",
          "claim": "Disgust is the affective component of a behavioural immune system protecting against pathogens.",
          "quote": "DISGUST is the affective part of the so-called \"behavioral immune system",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ],
      "note": "Affective neuroscience / clinical paper; competency content mostly conceptual."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76704",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Classical sorting algorithms as a model of morphogenesis: Self-sorting arrays reveal unexpected competencies in a minimal model of basal intelligence",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "1D sorting algorithm array (cell-view sorting)",
          "claim": "Arrays of autonomous elements sort themselves from random permutations to fully sorted states via bottom-up local policies.",
          "quote": "cellview sorts successfully completed the sorting process, navigating from a random state to the 100% fully sorted state",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Tolerance of defective parts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "1D sorting algorithm array with frozen cells",
          "claim": "Self-sorting arrays sort more reliably than traditional top-down implementations when some elements are broken.",
          "quote": "arrays of autonomous elements sort themselves more reliably and robustly than traditional implementations in the presence of errors",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Delayed benefit requiring short-term sacrifice",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "1D sorting algorithm array",
          "claim": "Arrays temporarily reduce sortedness to navigate around defects, more so when more frozen cells are present.",
          "quote": "we find the ability to temporarily reduce progress in order to navigate around a defect",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Type clustering without visible tags",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "chimeric sorting arrays mixing two algotypes",
          "claim": "Cells running the same algorithm cluster together although no algorithm accesses algotype information.",
          "quote": "none of the algorithms access the Algotype information of their own or neighboring cells-there are no explicit steps implementing clustering",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Mixed-policy collectives completing shared goals",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "chimeric sorting arrays",
          "claim": "Mixed-algotype arrays still complete sorting, with efficiency roughly the average of their components (linear, not superadditive).",
          "quote": "components with different policies but the same goal can be mixed in the same collective without abrogating the ability to complete the system-level task",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Delayed benefit requiring short-term sacrifice",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "sorting algorithm arrays",
          "claim": "Delayed gratification is quantified as temporary movement away from the goal followed by later gains, tested in context of barriers.",
          "quote": "Delayed Gratification (DG) is the ability to temporarily go further away from a goal to achieve gains later in the process",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76706",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "The energetics of cellular life transitions",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Energetic checkpoint on cell fate transitions",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "mouse lung epithelial cells; cells generally (integrated stress response)",
          "claim": "The ISR acts as an energetic checkpoint preventing OxPhos-deficient cells from costly identity transitions and recruiting systemic resources.",
          "quote": "We propose that the ISR is an energetic checkpoint evolved to (i) prevent OxPhos-deficient cells from engaging in excessively costly transitions",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Resource allocation from local scarcity signals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells signalling via GDF15 to the brain",
          "claim": "Stressed cells recruit systemic energetic resources by signalling energetic distress to the brain.",
          "quote": "allow ISR-positive cells to recruit systemic energetic resources by signaling via GDF15 and the brain",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Perspective on bioenergetics of cell-fate transitions."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76707",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Toward a nomenclature consensus for diverse intelligent systems: Call for collaboration",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Nomenclature call for diverse intelligent systems; no capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76708",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Stress sharing as cognitive glue for collective intelligences: A computational model of stress as a coordinator for morphogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stress sharing and influence radius",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "agent-based evolutionary model of morphogenesis",
          "claim": "Stress sharing makes populations reach anatomical targets faster and enlarges cells' radius of influence.",
          "quote": "stress sharing improves the morphogenetic efficiency of multicellular collectives; populations with stress sharing reached anatomical targets faster",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-distance cell movement",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "agent-based morphogenesis model",
          "claim": "Stress sharing enhances cell movement over longer distances to reach target positions.",
          "quote": "stress sharing influenced the future fate of distant cells in the multi-cellular collective, enhancing cells' movement and their radius of influence",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Privacy of goal states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "agent-based morphogenesis model",
          "claim": "An external observer cannot infer the anatomical goal from the embryo's stress maps during development.",
          "quote": "During development, anatomical goal states could not be inferred from observation of stress states",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Coordination range and topology constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "agent-based morphogenesis model",
          "claim": "The maximum radius over which a cell dislodges another quantifies cognitive light cone size.",
          "quote": "To quantify the range over which a given cell alters the fate of another cell, we plot the maximum radius over which a cell dislodges another cell",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76710",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Evolutionary Implications of Self-Assembling Cybernetic Materials with Collective Problem-Solving Intelligence at Multiple Scales",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Competency buffering genetic selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "neural cellular automata evolved for Czech-flag morphogenesis",
          "claim": "Evolution proceeds much faster when evolving the functional parameters of competent agents than when evolving the target pattern directly.",
          "quote": "We demonstrate that an evolutionary process proceeds much more rapidly when evolving the functional parameters of an MCA compared to evolving the target pattern directly.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Generalizing to previously unseen solutions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "evolved NCAs",
          "claim": "Evolved multiscale competency architectures generalize to noise levels and competency conditions never experienced during evolution.",
          "quote": "the evolved MCAs generalize well toward system parameter changes and even modified objective functions of the evolutionary process",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Transfer between problem families",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "pre-evolved NCAs re-evolved for new flag patterns",
          "claim": "Pre-evolved NCAs adapt in few generations to new target patterns or higher noise.",
          "quote": "only a single or, at most, a handful of generations are necessary for solving the task even at intermediate and high noise levels",
          "page": 20,
          "page_end": 20
        },
        {
          "name": "Noise and asynchronous update tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCAs with stochastic cell decisions",
          "claim": "Varying the reliability of cell decisions scales competency from direct encoding to MCA, with robustness to developmental noise.",
          "quote": "we systematically vary the accuracy with which the uni-cellular agents of an NCA can regulate their cell states (simulating stochastic processes and noise during development)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76712",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Self-Improvising Memory: A Perspective on Memories as Agential, Dynamically Reinterpreting Cognitive Glue",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Memory reinterpretation after remapping",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells to societies (memory as salience-preserving)",
          "claim": "Agents must dynamically reinterpret and modify memories to suit changing selves and environments, preserving salience not fidelity.",
          "quote": "a perspective on memory as preserving salience, not fidelity, is applicable to many phenomena on scales from cells to societies",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Memory through damage or remodelling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "metamorphosing insects; regenerating planaria",
          "claim": "Insects and planaria maintain memories across brain remodelling or regeneration, re-imprinting them onto new brains.",
          "quote": "Metamorphosing insects and planaria that maintain memories and re-imprint them from tail fragments onto a newly regenerating brain",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Transfer memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Aplysia (brain-extract memory transfer)",
          "claim": "Memories transferred via brain extracts are decoded by the recipient regardless of precise placement.",
          "quote": "no matter where precisely the molecules go, the new brain will extract their meaning and instruct the behavior of the recipient Aplysia",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Remapping molecular cues into behaviour",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "frog embryos injected with odorant",
          "claim": "An odorant injected into a frog egg yields an animal that seeks that odor, remapping a molecular cue across scales into behaviour.",
          "quote": "one can inject an odorant molecule into a frog egg, and the resulting animal will seek out that odor in its search for food [122]",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Memories as agential patterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cognitive systems (substrate-independent)",
          "claim": "Memories as patterns in an excitable medium could be seen as active agents in sense-making.",
          "quote": "memories, as patterns in the excitable medium of cognitive systems, could be seen as active agents in the sense-making process",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76713",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "A pro-reparative bioelectronic device for controlled delivery of ions and biomolecules",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Bioelectronic ion-pump device engineering; in vivo readout is a macrophage ratio, not an organism-level repair outcome."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76714",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Collective intelligence: A unifying concept for integrating biology across scales and substrates",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Merging and splitting collective identities",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "amniote blastoderm; induced eye fields",
          "claim": "Breaks in the blastoderm yield twins or triplets and large eye-fields can fragment into multiple eyes; individuality depends on interaction geometry.",
          "quote": "temporary introduction of breaks in the blastoderm (leading to informational isolation of islands of cell masses) results in twins, triplets, etc 103",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Recruiting an appropriate number of helpers",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus ectopic eye induction",
          "claim": "A few voltage-modified cells recruit wild-type neighbours to build normal-sized lenses.",
          "quote": "normal-sized lenses can be produced because the voltage-modified cells recruit their wild-type neighbors to participate in the organogenesis",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Competing goals: dominance, compromise or remodelling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus ectopic eye induction vs cancer-suppression signals",
          "claim": "Inducing cells and surrounding cells exert opposing influences; once a collective decision is made, all cells fall in line.",
          "quote": "collective decisions competing to determine the path through morphospace that will be taken and once a choice is made, all of the cells fall into line",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick Hensen's node left-right identity",
          "claim": "Even when left-right identity is stochastically perturbed, all cells on one side of the node agree on their identity.",
          "quote": "in all these cases, all of the cells on one side of the node agree on their identity",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Delayed benefit requiring short-term sacrifice",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "neural crest cells after arch ablation",
          "claim": "Neural crest cells migrate along paths contrary to their individual optimum to fill a missing arch, serving the collective target.",
          "quote": "achieving the correct target morphology of the collective behavior through movement patterns contrary to the individual cell's normal optimal path",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "vertebrate segmentation clock in explants",
          "claim": "The segmentation clock reaches correct segmentation via different morphospace paths even under radical geometric changes.",
          "quote": "the ability to take different paths through morphospace to correctly partition tissue into uniform, correctly sized segments",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "bacterial biofilms",
          "claim": "Optogenetically triggered bioelectric signals evoke long-lasting changes in biofilm behaviour, a collective memory.",
          "quote": "can be optogenetically controlled to evoke long-lasting changes on bacterial behavior - a collective memory",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective-over-individual fitness trade-off",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "bacterial biofilms",
          "claim": "Biofilm cells show bioelectrically coordinated oscillatory growth favouring the collective at the expense of individual fitness.",
          "quote": "exhibit bioelectrically-coordinated oscillatory growth patterns that favor the health of the collective at the expense of their own individual fitness",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76719",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Programmable Delivery of Fluoxetine via Wearable Bioelectronics for Wound Healing In Vivo",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Pharmacologically enhanced regeneration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "mouse wounds with wearable bioelectronic fluoxetine delivery",
          "claim": "Programmed fluoxetine delivery shortened inflammation and increased re-epithelialization in wounds.",
          "quote": "resulted in a 27.2% decrease in the macrophage ratio (M1/M2) and a 39.9% increase in reepithelialization",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ],
      "note": "Bioelectronic drug-delivery device paper; limited competency content."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76720",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Charging Ahead: Examining the Future Therapeutic Potential of Electroceuticals",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Electrotaxis toward wounds",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "wounded epithelia",
          "claim": "Endogenous wound electric fields guide directed cell migration and can override other directional cues.",
          "quote": "The importance of this bioelectric cue is highlighted by its ability to override other directional cues for cell migration in wound healing.",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Field-directed migration (electrotaxis)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cell collectives",
          "claim": "Electric fields can induce directed, large-scale collective cell migration.",
          "quote": "induce directed and large-scale collective cell migration",
          "page": 10,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ],
      "note": "Industry-perspective review of electroceutical ontology; limited competency content."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76722",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "AI-driven automated discovery tools reveal diverse behavioral competencies of biological networks",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Versatility of reachable outcomes",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "biological gene regulatory network models (curiosity-driven exploration)",
          "claim": "Real GRN models can reach a surprisingly wide spectrum of steady states without structural changes.",
          "quote": "models inferred from real biological data can reach a surprisingly wide spectrum of steady states",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigating around dynamic barriers",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "GRN models with energy-barrier 'walls'",
          "claim": "Some GRNs follow detouring trajectories that still reach the same endpoint despite walls placed in transcriptional space.",
          "quote": "with non-linear trajectories exhibiting many \"detours\" and \"loops\" but yet consistently reaching the same endpoint despite several pushes (Figure 5-e ) or walls",
          "page": 17,
          "page_end": 17
        },
        {
          "name": "Persistence under repeated disturbance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "GRN models subjected to pushes and noise",
          "claim": "Robust GRNs return to their original trajectory despite many pushes.",
          "quote": "is an example of an extremely robust system which, despite many push configurations (in magnitude and number), consistently returns to its original trajectory",
          "page": 17,
          "page_end": 17
        },
        {
          "name": "Search efficiency relative to blind search",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "curiosity search vs random search on GRNs",
          "claim": "Curiosity-driven exploration discovers more diverse reachable goal states than random search.",
          "quote": "Plot shows the reachable points discovered by curiosity search (a) and by random search (b) in the behavior space Z",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Versatility-robustness measure",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "GRNs across organism classes",
          "claim": "Versatility (area of reachable goal states) and robustness are quantified and compared; biological networks far exceed random networks.",
          "quote": "random network versatility is much lower (<0.026) than the versatility observed in biological networks",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 20
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76723",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Embryos assist morphogenesis of others through calcium and ATP signaling mechanisms in collective teratogen resistance",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Group-to-group assistance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryo cohorts exposed to teratogens",
          "claim": "Embryos in large groups resist teratogens better than isolated or small groups at constant per-embryo exposure (cross-embryo morphogenetic assistance).",
          "quote": "Xenopus laevis embryos are much more sensitive to a diverse set of chemical and molecular-biological perturbations when allowed to develop alone or in small groups, than in large groups",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo cohorts",
          "claim": "Increasing cohort size increases survival and decreases defect incidence.",
          "quote": "increasing the number of exposed embryos in a cohort increases the rate of survival while incidence of defects decreases",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stress sharing and influence radius",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos sharing media",
          "claim": "Mechanical injury to one embryo induces calcium waves in distant uninjured conspecifics, via ATP/P2 signalling.",
          "quote": "Mechanical damage in Xenopus induces calcium waves in distant, uninjured conspecifics.",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "mixed Xenopus cohorts",
          "claim": "Only similarly perturbed embryos help one another; naive or differently-insulted embryos do not, suggesting insult-specific signals.",
          "quote": "unperturbed individuals do not help stabilize teratogen-exposed individuals and we conclude that only perturbed individuals have a role in CEMA",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76724",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Machine Learning for Hypothesis Generation in Biology and Medicine: Exploring the latent space of neuroscience and developmental bioelectricity",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Shared molecular basis of morphogenesis and behaviour",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "gene ontology analysis across Drosophila, zebrafish, mouse, human (hypothesis from LLM domain translation)",
          "claim": "Genes annotated for behaviour and for development overlap increasingly across phylogeny, supporting conservation between cognition and morphogenesis.",
          "quote": "the molecular mechanisms behind developmental bioelectricity and that of cognitive/behavioral phenomena should be conserved",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ],
      "note": "Mainly an ML method (FieldSHIFT) for hypothesis generation by translating neuroscience to developmental bioelectricity."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76727",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Nested Selves: Self-Organization and Shared Markov Blankets in Prenatal Development in Humans",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Nested self-organization with shared Markov blankets",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "human pregnancy (maternal and fetal immune systems)",
          "claim": "Two self-organizing systems in pregnancy negotiate exchange of resources and information via shared Markov blankets under active inference.",
          "quote": "two immune systems need to negotiate the exchange of resources and information in order to maintain viable self-regulation of nested systems",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Merging and splitting collective identities",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "embryonic blastoderm",
          "claim": "The number of individuals in a single blastoderm is dynamically determined by cell interactions.",
          "quote": "the number of individuals in a single blastoderm is dynamically determined by cell- interactions",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ],
      "note": "Theoretical paper on self-organization in pregnancy via active inference."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76728",
      "year": 2024,
      "title": "Motile Living Biobots Self-Construct from Adult Human Somatic Progenitor Seed Cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots (adult human bronchial epithelial cells)",
          "claim": "Single adult human lung cells self-construct into motile multicellular biobots without genetic editing or sculpting.",
          "quote": "Each Anthrobot begins as a single cell, derived from the adult human lung, and self-constructs into a multicellular motile biobot",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Shape-function coupling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots",
          "claim": "Anthrobots' distinct movement types are significantly correlated with their morphological types.",
          "quote": "this behavioral diversity is significantly correlated with their morphological diversity",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stable individual movement styles",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots",
          "claim": "Anthrobots self-organize into discrete movement types ranging from tight loops to straight lines.",
          "quote": "Anthrobots exhibit diverse behaviors with motility patterns ranging from tight loops to straight lines",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Bridging damage or transporting debris",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobot 'superbots' on scratched human neural monolayers",
          "claim": "Superbots bridging a scratch induce local regrowth and gap closure of neural tissue beneath them.",
          "quote": "resulting in the formation of a stitch right underneath the \"superbot bridge,\" connecting the two sides of the scratch",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Opportunistic unselected behaviour",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Anthrobots",
          "claim": "Novel structures with unexpected, biomedically relevant behaviours arise from wild-type cells via bulk microenvironmental cues.",
          "quote": "novel structures, with new and unexpected behavior and biomedically-relevant capabilities, can be discovered in morphogenetic processes without direct genetic editing or manual sculpting",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76729",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Information integration during bioelectric regulation of morphogenesis of the embryonic frog brain",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Pattern recognition of multicellular voltage patterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "minimal GRN-bioelectric model of Xenopus neural plate; Xenopus embryos",
          "claim": "Cells collectively discriminate large-scale voltage patterns, with gene expression determined by distributions across the sheet rather than local voltage.",
          "quote": "A minimal model shows how cells can sense largescale patterns of cell voltage",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric pattern-discrimination model",
          "claim": "The model solved the pattern discrimination task in tissues up to ~400 cells though trained on 24, without selection for scaling.",
          "quote": "our model successfully solved the pattern discrimination problem even in a larger tissue containing 180 cells (compared with the original 24 cells), even though it was not specifically trained",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "bioelectric-transcription model",
          "claim": "Causal integration analysis reveals higher-order spatiotemporal integration of voltage pattern information into gene activity.",
          "quote": "Causal integration analysis revealed a higher-order mechanism by which information about the voltage pattern was spatiotemporally integrated into gene activity",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Division of labour and specialization",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric-transcription model",
          "claim": "Different genes are attuned to different spatial scales of the voltage pattern.",
          "quote": "some genes (2 and 5) are more attuned to the pattern at the tissue level, some (genes 3 and 4) to the single-cell level",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Tolerance of defective parts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos with half-altered voltage pattern",
          "claim": "As predicted by the model, disrupting the voltage pattern on one side still yields normal brain development by leveraging correct information on the other side.",
          "quote": "leveraging correct information on one side to accommodate informational defects on the other side",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 19
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76730",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "The Multiple Realizability of Sentience in Living Systems and Beyond",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Single-cell cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "individual cells",
          "claim": "Single cells display stimulus discrimination, problem-solving, decision-making, risk assessment, learning and adaptive rule-encoding.",
          "quote": "individual cells display response patterns consistent with stimulus discrimination, problem-solving, decision-making, risk assessment, learning, and adaptive rule-encoding",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Embodied goal-directed learning in hybrots",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "hybrid robots and closed-loop neural cultures",
          "claim": "Cells and tissues given sensory feedback and motor outputs show goal-directed, anticipatory responses and learning in vitro.",
          "quote": "when cells and tissues receive sensory feedback and are able to interact with an external world (e.g., motor outputs), they display response patterns that are goaldirected and anticipatory",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Consciousness in unconventional embodiments",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "living and engineered systems",
          "claim": "Sentience is argued to be multiply realizable and substrate independent, requiring inclusive frameworks.",
          "quote": "it may be scientifically valuable to assume that there are many possible systems that it is like to be",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ],
      "note": "Perspective on multiple realizability of sentience."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76734",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Collective Intelligence of Morphogenesis as a Teleonomic Process",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "regenerating salamander/planarian organs",
          "claim": "Regenerative growth stops precisely when the correct organ shape is achieved.",
          "quote": "The rapid growth and remodeling of regeneration (which can be as fast as any tumor) stops precisely when a correct organ shape has been achieved.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus 'Picasso' tadpoles",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with scrambled craniofacial organs still form largely normal frog faces via novel paths.",
          "quote": "largely normal frogs result because all of these organs move through novel, unnatural paths, until a proper frog face results",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Switching mechanisms after failure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "newt kidney tubules with enlarged cells",
          "claim": "When cells are very large, a single cell bends around itself to make the same tubule structure normally made by many cells.",
          "quote": "if the cells are made to be very large, just one cell will bend around itself to create the same structure",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Proportional error correction",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular morphogenesis (anatomical homeostasis)",
          "claim": "Feedback loops progressively reduce error between current state and a coarse-grained anatomical setpoint.",
          "quote": "feedback loops that trigger cell movement, gene expression changes, and the like in order to progressively reduce the error between a current state and a coarse-grained anatomical setpoint",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian flatworms",
          "claim": "Planaria regenerate every part from small fragments, rescaling remaining tissue to correct proportion.",
          "quote": "planarian flatworms (which regenerate every part of the body from even small fragments, while scaling the remaining tissue down so that perfect proportion results)",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "mammalian and amphibian embryos",
          "claim": "Embryos cut in half form twins and embryos with very different cell numbers still produce properly scaled bodies.",
          "quote": "embryos created with radically different numbers of cells still produce properly scaled bodies",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76735",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Endless forms most beautiful 2.0: teleonomy and the bioengineering of chimaeric and synthetic organisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots (dissociated frog embryonic skin cells)",
          "claim": "Dissociated frog skin cells reassemble into a novel motile proto-organism with its own developmental sequence.",
          "quote": "what they did was to reassemble and form a novel proto-organism known as a Xenobot",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Kinematic self-replication",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Deprived of normal reproduction, Xenobots herd loose cells to form the next generation.",
          "quote": "the emergent processes of Xenobots discover kinematic self-replication",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots repair after damage and show spontaneous behavioural changes without genetic modification.",
          "quote": "they repair after damage, interact with their environment and show spontaneous changes in behaviour",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Opportunistic unselected behaviour",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots repurpose native hardware (cilia for mucus) for novel locomotion, without transgenes.",
          "quote": "Xenobots repurpose their native hardware (e.g. cilia, which are normally used to redistribute mucus) to new functionality",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Competency buffering genetic selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multi-scale competency architecture in evolution",
          "claim": "A multi-scale competency architecture lets evolution and engineers rely on competent components rather than micromanaging, facilitating evolution of robust problem-solving.",
          "quote": "We suggest that a multi-scale competency architecture facilitates evolution of robust problem-solving, living machines.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76736",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Closing the Loop on Morphogenesis: A Mathematical Model of Morphogenesis by Closed-Loop Reaction-Diffusion",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Proportional error correction",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "closed-loop reaction-diffusion model with wave-based peak counting",
          "claim": "A negative-feedback controller counts RD peaks with a wave and iteratively adjusts parameters until the target number is reached.",
          "quote": "The top-level controller then directs seven iterations of counting, noting that there are too many peaks, and increasing λRD by 10% on each iteration, eventually giving the desired two peaks.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Measuring own body shape",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "cells communicating via waves in a morphogenetic field model",
          "claim": "Cells communicating in a wave-like pattern can analyze properties of the current body shape to create an error signal.",
          "quote": "We show how cells communicating in a wave-like pattern could analyze properties of the current body shape.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "closed-loop RD model",
          "claim": "The goal number of pattern repeats N can be altered over a wide range and the system rebuilds to the new target.",
          "quote": "letting us use a negative-feedback controller to create a pattern with N repetitions, where N can be altered over a wide range",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76738",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Searching in the Dark: Evolving Biobot Swarm Compositions to Efficiently Explore Obstructed Environments",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Edge following and spatial exploration",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated biobot swarms with behaviour types drawn from a pool",
          "claim": "Evolved swarm compositions explore obstructed environments significantly better than random swarms.",
          "quote": "the fitness of the best evolved swarm at the last time step was significantly higher than the fitnesses of randomly generated swarms (p < 0.01)",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Composition-dependent swarm behaviour",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated biobot swarms",
          "claim": "Carefully selected mixtures of individually uncontrollable biobots yield desired collective exploration behaviour.",
          "quote": "while we cannot control the behavior of individual biobots, carefully selected swarm compositions can lead to desired behavior outcomes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated biobot swarms",
          "claim": "Evolved swarm solutions scale to some extent to larger environments and swarm sizes.",
          "quote": "these solutions scale to some extent to larger environments and swarm sizes",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76739",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Future Medicine: from molecular pathways to the collective intelligence of the body",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "mammalian liver (hepatostat)",
          "claim": "The liver regenerates to keep the liver-to-body weight ratio constant, a homeostatic setpoint of organ size and function.",
          "quote": "The liver is the only solid organ to use its regenerative mechanism to ensure that the liver-to-body weight ratio remains constant.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Environment-dependent form from local goals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "hepatocytes transplanted into lymph nodes of tyrosinemic mice",
          "claim": "Ectopic hepatocytes build auxiliary liver tissue only when there is functional need, growing until normal liver mass is restored.",
          "quote": "in the absence of substantial liver disease, hepatocytes transplanted into lymph nodes do not generate liver tissue [48], supporting the need of function concept",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "ectopic liver in lymph nodes",
          "claim": "After partial hepatectomy, lymph-node hepatocytes proliferate again until the auxiliary liver achieves normal mass and function.",
          "quote": "the hepatocytes in the lymph node begin to proliferate again until the auxiliary liver achieves normal liver mass and function",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Unseen stressor workarounds",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "hepatocytes under chronic injury; planaria with barium",
          "claim": "Hepatocytes mount cell-death resistance under chronic injury, an adaptive response to novel stress.",
          "quote": "hepatocytes have also been shown to mount profound cell death resistance during chronic liver injury",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "epithelial cells freed from bodies (Xenobots, Anthrobots)",
          "claim": "Isolated epithelial cells reboot multicellularity into new proto-organisms with new structures and behaviours.",
          "quote": "Epithelial cells isolated from bodies reboot their multicellularity and create new proto-organisms with unmodified frog or human genomes but entirely different body structures, behaviors, and capabilities",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cellular collectives (anatomical compiler)",
          "claim": "An anatomical compiler would respecify target morphology information in cellular collectives rather than micromanage cells.",
          "quote": "converts the anatomical goals of the user into a respecification of the target morphology information in cellular collectives",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76740",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Multiple ways to implement and infer sentience: Commentary on Segundo-Ortiz & Calvo on Plant Sentience",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Anticipation of future events",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "plants",
          "claim": "Plants anticipate, assess risk, cooperate, mimic and pursue goals, as reviewed by Segundo-Ortin & Calvo.",
          "quote": "plants anticipate, assess risk, cooperate, mimic, and pursue goals, as do their animal counterparts",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Consciousness in unconventional embodiments",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "plants and diverse substrates",
          "claim": "Cognitive functions including sentience can be realized by very different systems and substrates.",
          "quote": "cognitive functions, including sentience, can potentially be achieved by very different systems and their disparate substrates",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Kin / self-type discrimination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "plants",
          "claim": "Plants integrate multiple signal types to discriminate kin from non-kin and compete or cooperate accordingly.",
          "quote": "plants can integrate chemical, electrical, optical, and mechanical signals to discriminate kin from non-kin",
          "page": 3,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ],
      "note": "Short commentary on plant sentience."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76744",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "The brain is not mental! coupling neuronal and immune cellular processing in human organisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Aneural learning and memory",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "immune cell networks",
          "claim": "The immune network shows characteristics aligned with perception, attention, decision-making, problem-solving, learning and memory.",
          "quote": "The described characteristics of the immune network are aligned with cognitive processes such as perception, attention, decision-making, communication, problem-solving, learning, and memory.",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric memory in bacterial biofilms",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "bacterial biofilms",
          "claim": "Electrical signalling in biofilms parallels neurons, encoding memory via changes in membrane potential.",
          "quote": "a \"parallel between neurons and bacteria\" related to encoding memory by changes in the membrane potential",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Distributed whole-body cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "human organism (neuronal and immune cells)",
          "claim": "Cognition is a multiscale web of information processing distributed across cellular systems throughout the body, not just the brain.",
          "quote": "cognition can be seen as a multiscale web of dynamic information processing distributed across a vast array of complex cellular (e.g., neuronal, immune, and others) and network systems",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Theoretical paper on brain-immune coupling in cognition."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76746",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "The collective intelligence of evolution and development",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Collective credit assignment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular organisms (rat lever example) and collectives",
          "claim": "Collectives must solve distributed credit assignment so local self-interested parts produce long-term collective interest.",
          "quote": "Problems of distributed credit assignment are a key aspect of intelligence, even in conventional organisms.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Natural induction without population selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "ecological communities as connectionist networks",
          "claim": "Hebbian-like learning behaviours can be exhibited by ecological communities without community-level selection.",
          "quote": "the same learning behaviours can be exhibited by an ecological community without selection at the community level",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Delayed benefit requiring short-term sacrifice",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "learning systems that generalise",
          "claim": "Systems that generalise can act consistently with long-term rewards even against short-term interests.",
          "quote": "a system that can generalise can act in a manner that is consistent with long-term rewards, even when this appears to oppose immediate or short-term interests",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "connectionist models of collectives (Hebbian learning)",
          "claim": "Hebbian learning in self-modelling dynamical systems strengthens co-occurring correlations, implementing associative memory in collectives.",
          "quote": "the more things co-occur, the more the connection between them changes to make them more likely to co-occur in future",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ],
      "note": "Theoretical review connecting connectionism to collective intelligence in evolution and development."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76747",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Bioelectric networks: the cognitive glue enabling evolutionary scaling from physiology to mind",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian flatworms",
          "claim": "Planarian head number is set by a bioelectric circuit with default 1 that can be transiently rewritten to 2, and the change is remembered.",
          "quote": "Transient modification of the bioelectric state is remembered by the circuit, which can be experimentally re-set to read \"2\"",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Alternative stable morphologies",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian fragments treated with gap-junction blocker",
          "claim": "Temporary gap-junction blockade makes planaria build heads of other species, later remodelling back to normal.",
          "quote": "temporary exposure to a blocker of electrical synapses (i.e., an anesthetic) causes planarian fragments to create the heads of other species, with no genetic change required",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Switching mechanisms after failure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "newt kidney tubules",
          "claim": "With enlarged cells, fewer cells or even a single cell build normal-diameter tubules.",
          "quote": "if the cells are made to be enormous, a single cell will bend around itself, producing the normal size tubule diameter",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "early mammalian embryos",
          "claim": "Embryos cut in half recognize the damage and each half forms a complete twin.",
          "quote": "each side recognizes the damage, makes up for it exactly, and creates one of a pair of monozygotic twins",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric scaling of cognitive light cones",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric networks from cells to brains",
          "claim": "Bioelectric signalling predated neurons and was repurposed from morphospace navigation to behavioural navigation, scaling goals.",
          "quote": "Evolution was using bioelectric signaling long before neurons and muscles appeared, to solve the problem of creating and repairing complex bodies.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76748",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Control Flow in Active Inference Systems—Part II: Tensor Networks as General Models of Control Flow",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Context-specific deployment of perception-action resources",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "active inference systems at all scales (tensor network control flow)",
          "claim": "Survival under limited free energy requires control systems that deploy perception and action resources context-specifically, representable as tensor networks.",
          "quote": "Survival under these conditions requires a control system that can activate, or deploy, available perception and action resources in a context specific way.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-modifying the problem environment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "eukaryotic cells and multicellular systems",
          "claim": "Most eukaryotes write and read stigmergic memories in their environment, crucial for cognition.",
          "quote": "crucially for cognition - the writing and reading of stigmergic memories",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ],
      "note": "Formal/theoretical physics framework (FEP, tensor networks); limited empirical competency content."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76749",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Control Flow in Active Inference Systems—Part I: Classical and Quantum Formulations of Active Inference",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Context-specific deployment of perception-action resources",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "active inference systems (classical and quantum FEP)",
          "claim": "Living systems need control flow that deploys perception and action resources depending on context.",
          "quote": "Survival under these conditions requires a control system that can activate, or deploy, available perception and action resources in a context specific way.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Formal/theoretical review of classical and quantum active inference; minimal competency content."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76750",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Darwin's agential materials: evolutionary implications of multiscale competency in developmental biology",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Competency ratchet",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "evolving lineages (planaria, salamanders, mammals)",
          "claim": "Competency hides structural genome quality from selection, driving further optimization of competency mechanisms in a feedback loop.",
          "quote": "a ratchet for multiscale intelligence that can readily be seen in computational models of the process [240]",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 18
        },
        {
          "name": "Competency buffering genetic selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "organisms with multiscale competency architecture",
          "claim": "When parts can adjust, fitness carries less information about the structural genome, so selection cannot easily see genomes.",
          "quote": "Because cells can navigate morphological and physiological spaces, fitness carries less information about the structural genome.",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 18
        },
        {
          "name": "Cryptic variation and smoother fitness landscapes",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multiscale competency architecture in evolution",
          "claim": "Multiscale competency smooths the fitness landscape, improving evolvability and helping search overcome local maxima.",
          "quote": "By smoothing the fitness landscape, MCA makes the search process much more efficient, improving evolvability by enabling the search to overcome local maxima.",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 19
        },
        {
          "name": "Latent or counterfactual memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cryptic planaria",
          "claim": "One-headed planaria with a two-headed bioelectric target morphology build two heads when cut, a counterfactual memory.",
          "quote": "The bioelectric representation of the target morphology guiding the cellular collective can work as a counterfactual memory",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells, tissues and organs",
          "claim": "Biological structures show regulative plasticity, adjusting to injury or internal modifications to accomplish adaptive tasks across problem spaces.",
          "quote": "the ability to adjust to perturbations such as external injury or internal modifications and still accomplish specific adaptive tasks across metabolic, transcriptional, physiological, and anatomical problem spaces",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76752",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Cellular Signaling Pathways as Plastic, Proto-cognitive Systems: Implications for Biomedicine",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Habituation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cancer cells under targeted therapy (drug resistance)",
          "claim": "Acquired drug resistance without genetic change suggests physiological habituation of signalling pathways.",
          "quote": "no genetic amplifications were observed in people with acquired resistance, 81 suggesting dynamic physiological habituation mechanisms",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Sensitization",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "drug responses in physiology",
          "claim": "Reverse tolerance (sensitization) increases reaction to repeated stimuli, a basic proto-cognitive memory.",
          "quote": "Tolerance and reverse tolerance (sensitization) are, in their most general forms, a decrease or increase, respectively, in the magnitude of reaction to a repeated stimulus.",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "drug tolerance in animals and humans",
          "claim": "Drug tolerance can be context-specific, akin to Pavlovian conditioning to environmental cues.",
          "quote": "This conditioned tolerance is similar to Pavlovian conditioning",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Trainable signalling pathways",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "protein pathways and gene regulatory networks",
          "claim": "Pathways show trainability (memory) and context-sensitive information processing that could be exploited via stimulus history.",
          "quote": "protein pathways and transcriptional networks exhibit interesting and unexpected capabilities such as trainability (memory) and information processing in a context-sensitive manner",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76753",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Biological Robots: Perspectives on an Emerging Interdisciplinary Field",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Kinematic self-replication",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Kinematic self-replication in Xenobots was generated by manipulating stereotyped cilia-driven behaviours, a fragile process requiring careful tuning.",
          "quote": "It is precisely through manipulation of these known and stereotyped behaviors that we were able to generate kinematic self-replication, 9 a fragile process requiring careful titration",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective locomotion from identical local rules",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots (cilia- and muscle-actuated biobots)",
          "claim": "Ciliated or muscle tissues drive locomotion in predictable, stereotyped ways usable for modelling individual and group behaviour.",
          "quote": "the cilia and muscle actuators behave like windup toys in a predictable and stereotyped manner",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Shape-function coupling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biological robots and developmental systems",
          "claim": "Consilience of developmental biology and robotics illuminates multiscale control, self-assembly and form-function relationships.",
          "quote": "the consilience of these fields can help to shed light on issues of multiscale control, self-assembly, and relationships between form and function",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Multi-author perspective on biorobots; includes a deflationary view of Xenobot behaviour from one commentator."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76754",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "The scaling of goals from cellular to anatomical homeostasis: an evolutionary simulation, experiment and analysis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical goals and subgoals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "2D neural cellular automata evolved from cell-level metabolic homeostasis",
          "claim": "Evolution scales single-cell metabolic setpoints into tissue-level setpoints that solve the French flag problem.",
          "quote": "Our system showed the evolution of the much more complex setpoints of cell collectives (tissues) that solve a problem in morphospace",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCA French-flag tissue",
          "claim": "After perturbation beyond evolved timescales, the tissue corrects its pattern within a few steps.",
          "quote": "after the perturbation at 110 steps, the tissue corrected the red stripe in 10 steps",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Unselected damage tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCA French-flag tissue",
          "claim": "Robustness to perturbation and long-term stability emerged though neither was directly selected for.",
          "quote": "as well as the ability to recover from perturbation (robustness) and long-term stability (even though neither of these was directly selected for)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stress sharing and influence radius",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCA French-flag tissue",
          "claim": "Evolution exploits stress propagation dynamics as an instructive signal to reach the target morphology.",
          "quote": "including the use of stress propagation dynamics to achieve the target morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Allostasis and changing targets",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "NCA French-flag tissue",
          "claim": "The tissue maintains morphology over a long adult phase, spontaneously deviating and correcting via stress-driven remodelling.",
          "quote": "the intrinsic dynamics of the tissue created deviations from the target morphology that increased the level of stress, after which the tissue corrected the new anatomical trajectory",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Late spontaneous remodelling",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planaria regenerating after ERK inhibition (U0126)",
          "claim": "Headless planaria thought to be terminal suddenly repattern weeks later, some regaining a normal head, as predicted by the model.",
          "quote": "22% showed some form of sudden repatterning even though regeneration had completed and morphogenesis had ceased weeks prior",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 16
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76755",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "The nonlinearity of regulation in biological networks",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regulatory nonlinearity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "137 published Boolean network models of biological regulation",
          "claim": "Taylor decomposition of probabilistic Boolean logic quantifies regulatory nonlinearity; biological networks are less nonlinear than random ones, cancer networks more variable.",
          "quote": "biological regulation tends to be less nonlinear than expected, meaning that higher-order interactions among the regulatory inputs tend to be less pronounced",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "biological regulatory networks",
          "claim": "Biological networks need few inputs to reprogram and are relatively easy to control, possibly related to their linearity.",
          "quote": "biological networks need few inputs to reprogram 31 and are relatively easier to control 4",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ],
      "note": "Methodological network-analysis paper; competency content limited to controllability metrics."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76757",
      "year": 2023,
      "title": "Synthetic morphology with agential materials",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Kinematic self-replication",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots can make the next generation because cells are an agential material inherently able to assemble into a new organism.",
          "quote": "xenobots can replicate because cells are an agential material with the inherent capability to assemble into a coherent new organism",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots (frog skin cells)",
          "claim": "Freed from neighbours' instructive signals, skin cells' baseline preference is to form an active xenobot rather than a 2D skin layer.",
          "quote": "the xenobot example demonstrates that their baseline preference (in the normal, default environment) is to make an active xenobot",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Recruiting an appropriate number of helpers",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos with ion-channel-induced ectopic eyes",
          "claim": "Bioelectrically modified cells recruit enough wild-type neighbours to build a normal lens.",
          "quote": "the bioelectrically-modified cells automatically recruit their wild-type neighbours at numbers sufficient to make a normal lens",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "frog embryos (bioelectric eye induction, appendage regeneration)",
          "claim": "A simple bioelectric trigger state can induce whole organs such as eyes at ectopic locations.",
          "quote": "A simple bioelectric trigger state can be induced by misexpression of an ion channel to reproduce the spatial pattern of electric potential that normally specifies the location of the eyes",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Opportunistic unselected behaviour",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Many xenobot capabilities such as kinematic self-replication were not predicted and were never selected for in the frog life cycle.",
          "quote": "Many of the capabilities of xenobots, such as kinematic self-replication, were not predicted in advance.",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76762",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Exploring the Behavior of Bioelectric Circuits Using Evolution Heuristic Search",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated bioelectric tissues (BETSE) found by heuristic search",
          "claim": "Discovered bioelectric patterns keep their main features across different tissue shapes and cell counts.",
          "quote": "the main features of the tissue activity are maintained regardless of the tissue shape and cell count",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 20
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated bioelectric planarian-shaped tissue",
          "claim": "A circuit was found whose stable Vmem pattern returns to its resting state after stimulation (self-healing).",
          "quote": "The genetic algorithm found a configuration that created a cell tissue that self-healed",
          "page": 20,
          "page_end": 22
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated bioelectric planarian-shaped tissue",
          "claim": "A circuit was found that holds a new Vmem state after transient stimulation ends, a rewritable memory.",
          "quote": "When the stimulation period was over, all the cells in the tissue maintained their membrane voltage for the rest of the simulation",
          "page": 23,
          "page_end": 23
        },
        {
          "name": "Event counting and multiple memories",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated bioelectric tissue",
          "claim": "A circuit responds differently to a second stimulation than to the first, a simple temporal memory.",
          "quote": "When the second stimulation began, the voltage of all the cells reacted to the second stimulation differently.",
          "page": 23,
          "page_end": 23
        },
        {
          "name": "Versatility of reachable outcomes",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric circuit parameter space",
          "claim": "Bioelectric parameter space, though hard to search, contains circuits with rich patterning behaviours.",
          "quote": "while bioelectrical space is not easy to search, it does contain parameter sets that encode rich and interesting patterning behaviors",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76763",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "On-chip on-demand delivery of K+ for in vitro bioelectronics",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Device engineering (on-chip K+ delivery for in vitro Vmem control); no capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76764",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Active inference, morphogenesis, and computational psychiatry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Morphogenesis as active inference",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "active inference simulations of cell collectives",
          "claim": "Cells minimizing free energy collectively migrate and differentiate to a target morphology; aberrant precision produces developmental defects.",
          "quote": "the same forms of aberrant active inference (e.g., deficits of sensory attenuation and low sensory precision) that have been used to explain psychopathological conditions",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "active inference morphogenesis simulation",
          "claim": "Reducing signalling and sensitivity of two over-precise cells rescues the collective's developmental defect.",
          "quote": "After the simulated biomedical intervention, as we can observe in Figure 8, the developmental defect is cured and all cells reach their location with the appropriate differentiation.",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Drug-induced morphogenetic disorders of inference",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos treated with thioridazine",
          "claim": "As predicted, a dopamine antagonist thought to reduce sensory precision induced anatomical defects in frog embryos.",
          "quote": "thioridazine (a dopamine antagonist that may reduce sensory precision in biological systems) induced developmental (anatomical) defects as predicted",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76765",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "The free energy principle induces neuromorphic development",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Neuromorphic morphology from free-energy minimization",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "any system with morphological degrees of freedom and limited free energy (cells, neurons)",
          "claim": "Under the FEP such systems evolve toward neuromorphic morphologies supporting hierarchical coarse-graining computations.",
          "quote": "any system with morphological degrees of freedom and locally limited free energy will, under the constraints of the free energy principle, evolve toward a neuromorphic morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Shape-function coupling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "neurons and cells with morphological degrees of freedom",
          "claim": "A cell can vary its morphology to selectively deploy its quantum reference frames to specific sectors of its boundary.",
          "quote": "a neuron can take advantage of by varying its morphology to selectively deploy its QRFs to specific sectors of B",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        }
      ],
      "note": "Formal theoretical paper (FEP, quantum reference frames)."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76767",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Adversarial Takeover of Neural Cellular Automata",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Minimal adversarial interventions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "neural cellular automaton (multi-rule NCA)",
          "claim": "Injecting a few cells running a different NCA rule can gradually take over an organism and change its global properties/task.",
          "quote": "We demonstrated that it is possible to change global properties of a Neural Cellular Automata, by injecting very few adversaries that gradually take over the entire organism.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Minority takeover threshold",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "neural cellular automaton",
          "claim": "When time matters (e.g., before a mortal organism dies) a larger adversary injection is needed for takeover to succeed.",
          "quote": "For some tasks, where the time is a major factor, a larger injection of adversaries will be needed",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Aging prevention by injected cells",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "neural cellular automaton",
          "claim": "A mortal (aging) NCA can be made to persist indefinitely by injecting adversarial cells following a different rule.",
          "quote": "Next we demonstrate that it is possible to stop aging in an existing NCA by injecting adversaries that follow a different rule.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Inter-rule distance metric",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "neural cellular automaton",
          "claim": "The authors define a distance between NCA rules and find adversaries close in parameter space to the original cells.",
          "quote": "Finally, we quantify a distance between NCAs and develop a procedure that allows us to find adversaries close to the original cells.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "neural cellular automaton",
          "claim": "Prior NCA work showed cells can be trained to converge to (and grow) arbitrary target morphologies.",
          "quote": "researchers managed to create NCA that are able to converge to any morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76770",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Generalizing frameworks for sentience beyond natural species",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Sentience criteria for unconventional agents",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "synthetic/bioengineered beings, AI, cyborgs",
          "claim": "Sentience frameworks must be generalized beyond phylogeny and brain homology to evaluate novel engineered and hybrid agents.",
          "quote": "We must develop principled approaches to evaluating the sentience of (and thus, our responsibility to) beings of unfamiliar provenance and composition.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "gene regulatory networks",
          "claim": "Associative learning, one of the sentience criteria, has been shown to occur in gene regulatory networks.",
          "quote": "Their criterion #7 (associative learning) can occur even in gene regulatory networks",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Competence in non-behavioural problem spaces",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells, tissues, bioengineered forms",
          "claim": "Minimal cognition reveals intelligence in physiological, metabolic, transcriptional and anatomical spaces that humans fail to recognize.",
          "quote": "the field of minimal cognition is revealing competences and intelligence in other problem spaces (such as physiological, metabolic, transcriptional, and anatomical)",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76771",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Enhancers of Host Immune Tolerance to Bacterial Infection Discovered Using Linked Computational and Experimental Approaches",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Infection tolerance (survival despite pathogen load)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "Xenopus embryos survive several bacterial infections while pathogen burden stays high, i.e. tolerance rather than clearance.",
          "quote": "although embryos survived exposure to infection, their pathogen burden remained elevated confirming the induction of a tolerant state rather than an increase in pathogen killing or clearance",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Pharmacologically induced infection tolerance",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "A metal chelator or HIF-1a agonist increased survival of embryos infected with a lethal pathogen despite high pathogen load.",
          "quote": "administration of a metal chelator (deferoxamine) or a HIF-1𝜶 agonist (1,4-DPCA) in embryos infected with lethal A. hydrophila increased survival despite high pathogen load",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Host-pathogen response index (HPRI)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "A single score combining host survival and pathogen load delineates susceptible, tolerant and resistant hosts.",
          "quote": "we developed the HPRI score, which simultaneously accounts for host survival and pathogen levels in a single score and delineates susceptible, tolerant, and resistant host organisms",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76775",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Neurons as hierarchies of quantum reference frames",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical active inference",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "neurons, synapses, dendrites (quantum reference frame model)",
          "claim": "Hierarchies of quantum reference frames in neurons are modelled as hierarchical active-inference systems.",
          "quote": "In this representation, hierarchies of quantum reference frames act as hierarchical active-inference systems.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Reward-guided dendritic remodelling",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "neuronal dendritic trees",
          "claim": "The model predicts dendritic trees remodel toward maximal informativeness, with trophic reward as the selection criterion.",
          "quote": "we are able to predict generically that dendritic trees will remodel in the direction of maximal informativeness, with trophic reward as the selection criterion",
          "page": 28,
          "page_end": 29
        },
        {
          "name": "Scale-free cognition (non-neural generalization)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "non-neural cells and tissues",
          "claim": "The same QRF/active-inference representation is proposed to generalize to non-neural cells in development and regeneration.",
          "quote": "We summarize how the model may be generalized to nonneural cells and tissues in developmental and regenerative contexts.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76776",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "A free energy principle for generic quantum systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical active inference",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "generic quantum systems",
          "claim": "Generic quantum systems, given free choice, are agents that minimize variational free energy (Bayesian prediction error).",
          "quote": "We show how such agents minimize Bayesian prediction error in environments characterized by uncertainty, insufficient learning, and quantum contextuality.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Observer semantics in generic physical systems",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "generic quantum systems",
          "claim": "Any quantum system can be formally treated as an observer/agent assigning semantics to observational outcomes.",
          "quote": "We show how generic quantum systems can be regarded as observers, which with the standard freedom of choice assumption become agents capable of assigning semantics to observational outcomes.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Context switching to reduce prediction error",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "generic quantum systems",
          "claim": "Quantum context switching is both a source of prediction error and a strategy for reducing it.",
          "quote": "quantum context-switching as both a source of prediction errors and a strategy for reducing prediction errors",
          "page": 40,
          "page_end": 40
        },
        {
          "name": "Quantum coherence as computational resource",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biological systems",
          "claim": "Biological systems are suggested to use quantum coherence as a computational and communication resource.",
          "quote": "we suggest that biological systems employ quantum coherence as a computational resource and - implicitly - as a communication resource",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76778",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Design for an Individual: Connectionist Approaches to the Evolutionary Transitions in Individuality",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Distributed unsupervised learning of collective organisation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "connectionist / evolutionary connectionism models",
          "claim": "Connectionist models show networks of organised relationships sufficient for information integration and collective action can arise by distributed unsupervised learning without central control.",
          "quote": "can be produced via fully-distributed and unsupervised learning principles, i.e., without centralised control or an external teacher",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Evolutionary transitions in individuality as learning",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellularity / evolutionary units",
          "claim": "Conditions for evolving a new level of individuality are hypothesised to match the conditions for learning non-decomposable functions in neural networks.",
          "quote": "we hypothesise that the conditions necessary to evolve a new level of individuality are described by the conditions necessary to learn nondecomposable functions of this type",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "organismic individuals",
          "claim": "Organismic individuality is framed as development/behaviour of the whole being a non-decomposable function of its parts.",
          "quote": "organismic individuality (where the development and behaviour of the whole is a non-decomposable function of the behaviour of component parts)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76779",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere: An Experimentally-Grounded Framework for Understanding Diverse Bodies and Minds",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamander limb, frog leg regeneration",
          "claim": "Cells cooperate toward an invariant target morphology from diverse starting conditions, meeting James' 'fixed ends with varying means' test.",
          "quote": "the cells cooperate toward a specific, invariant endstate (the target morphology), from diverse starting conditions, and cease their activity when the correct pattern has been achieved",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamander limb regeneration",
          "claim": "Regenerating limbs rebuild from any amputation level and stop when the structure is complete.",
          "quote": "cells will also re-build complex structures such as limbs, no matter where along the limb axis they are amputated, and stop when it is complete",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole craniofacial organs",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with scrambled craniofacial organs remodel via novel movements into normal frog faces.",
          "quote": "the tissues will move from their abnormal starting positions in novel ways until a correct frog face is achieved",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "deer antlers; planaria",
          "claim": "Trophic memory in antlers and bioelectric pattern memory in planaria show re-writable anatomical setpoints in standard hardware.",
          "quote": "This is an example of experience-dependent, re-writable pattern memory, in which the target morphology (the setpoint for anatomical homeostasis) is re-written within standard hardware.",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Switching mechanisms after failure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "newt kidney tubules (polyploid cells)",
          "claim": "When cells are made very large, a single cell uses cytoskeletal bending instead of cell-cell interactions to form the correct lumen.",
          "quote": "Instead of the typical cell-cell interactions that coordinate tubule formation, cytoskeletal deformations within one cell can be deployed to achieve the same end result.",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "newt kidney tubules",
          "claim": "Tubules made from enlarged cells use fewer cells to keep correct lumen size.",
          "quote": "When the cell size is experimentally enlarged, the same tubules are made of a smaller number of the bigger cells.",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric scaling of cell goals into anatomical homeostasis",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "developmental bioelectric networks (ion channels, gap junctions)",
          "claim": "Developmental bioelectricity joins cells into larger agents, scaling cell-level feedback loops into anatomical homeostasis.",
          "quote": "developmental bioelectricity, implemented by pre-neural use of ion channels and gap junctions to scale up cell-level feedback loops into anatomical homeostasis",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Competency buffering genetic selection",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multi-scale biological systems",
          "claim": "Multi-scale competency of biological parts is proposed to greatly potentiate evolvability.",
          "quote": "This architecture of multi-scale competency of biological systems has important implications for plasticity of bodies and minds, greatly potentiating evolvability.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Morphogenesis as basal cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "developing/regenerating systems",
          "claim": "TAME treats morphogenesis as collective-intelligence problem-solving in anatomical space, i.e. basal cognition.",
          "quote": "When applied to regenerating/developmental systems, TAME suggests a perspective on morphogenesis as an example of basal cognition.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76780",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Biological underpinnings for lifelong learning machines",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Catastrophic forgetting resistance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "lifelong learning machines / biological organisms",
          "claim": "Lifelong learners must acquire new tasks without degrading old ones (stability-plasticity dilemma).",
          "quote": "The challenge of acquiring new skills without forgetting old ones is known as the stability-plasticity dilemma",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Forward and backward transfer",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "lifelong learning machines",
          "claim": "Exploiting task similarity enables forward transfer to new tasks and backward transfer improving old ones.",
          "quote": "backward transfer to the case when learning a new task improves performance on a previously learned task",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Task-agnostic adaptation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "lifelong learning machines",
          "claim": "L2 systems cannot rely on an oracle to signal task switches and must infer which skills apply.",
          "quote": "L2 models deployed in the real world cannot rely on an oracle to tell them when training switches from one task to another",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Efficient learning with bounded resources",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "lifelong learning machines",
          "claim": "Lifelong learners should improve with experience while making modest demands on energy and compute.",
          "quote": "they never stop learning, their performance improves with experience, and - importantly - they make modest demands on energy and compute/memory resources",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Sensor and effector remapping",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with ectopic eyes",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with an eye on the tail still learn visually, showing the brain adapts to a novel architecture.",
          "quote": "tadpoles created with an eye on their tail (instead of their primary eyes) can still exhibit efficient visual learning",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Transient bioelectric modification yields 2-headed planaria that keep regenerating as 2-headed despite wild-type genome.",
          "quote": "transient modifications of their bioelectric circuits result in 2-headed forms that continue to give rise to 2-headed forms in perpetuity, despite their wild-type genome",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Learning in non-neural bioelectric networks",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "bioelectric network model",
          "claim": "A simple non-neural bioelectric model can be trained to perform logic and pattern recognition.",
          "quote": "A simple non-neural bioelectric model 143 that can be trained to perform cognitive tasks like logic and pattern recognition serves as a proof of principle",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole craniofacial organs",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with misplaced craniofacial organs progressively reduce error from the target morphology.",
          "quote": "showing the ability to progressively reduce the error (difference from the correct target morphology) and forge new paths to the correct region of morphospace",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76781",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Studying Protista WBR and Repair Using Physarum polycephalum",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Local repair without global rework",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "An injured Physarum vein (1 cm gap) is rapidly repaired within hours.",
          "quote": "An injury to the vein that leaves the underlying agar intact can be (e) rapidly repaired within 5 h",
          "page": 72,
          "page_end": 72
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Physarum regenerates a whole plasmodial network from a small seed point, consistently regenerating hierarchical branching patterns.",
          "quote": "Physarum has a strong generative capacity with consistent regeneration of hierarchical branching patterns",
          "page": 67,
          "page_end": 68
        },
        {
          "name": "Synchronization and entrainment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Shuttle streaming acts as an intrinsic oscillator that synchronizes the cell and supports collective behaviour.",
          "quote": "acts as an intrinsic cellular oscillator that drives synchronization across the cell and allows for collective behavior of the organism",
          "page": 66,
          "page_end": 67
        },
        {
          "name": "Aneural decision-making and problem solving",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Coordinated activity across distances gives rise to mechanosensing, problem-solving and decision-making that optimize foraging and danger avoidance.",
          "quote": "gives rise to more complex mechanosensing, problem solving, and decision-making capabilities that optimize the slime mould's ability to find food and avoid danger",
          "page": 66,
          "page_end": 67
        },
        {
          "name": "Dormancy and revival under stress",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Under adverse conditions Physarum becomes dormant sclerotia and revives rapidly when humidity and food return.",
          "quote": "Sclerotia rapidly transforms to a vegetative plasmodial state in the presence of humidity and food sources",
          "page": 67,
          "page_end": 68
        },
        {
          "name": "Merging and splitting collective identities",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Separate plasmodial networks can fuse together.",
          "quote": "fuse with separate plasmodial networks",
          "page": 67,
          "page_end": 68
        },
        {
          "name": "Autotomy: sacrificing a part to protect the whole",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "crustaceans, annelids, holothurians",
          "claim": "Animals shed body parts to escape predators or isolate infected or malfunctioning parts.",
          "quote": "shed body parts as a defense mechanism, in order to escape predators or to isolate infected or malfunctioning body parts",
          "page": 35,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 36
        }
      ],
      "note": "Methods volume (Whole-Body Regeneration: Methods and Protocols); competencies taken from the Physarum chapter (Sperry, Murugan & Levin)."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76786",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Impact of Membrane Voltage on Formation and Stability of Human Renal Proximal Tubules in Vitro",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human renal proximal tubule cells (RPTEC) in vitro",
          "claim": "Vm depolarization correlates with tubule self-organization, and KATP channel modulation changes tubular network topology.",
          "quote": "Chronic manipulation of KATP channels induced changes in the tubular network topology without affecting lumen formation.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76787",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "When left does not seem right: epigenetic and bioelectric differences between left- and right-sided breast cancer",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Left-right bioelectric asymmetry in tumours",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human breast cancer (patient data, xenografts, MDA-MB-231 cells)",
          "claim": "Left- and right-sided breast tumours differ in ion-channel gene methylation, membrane potential and proliferation.",
          "quote": "L-sided cells presented increased methylation of hyperpolarizing ion channel genes and increased ­Ca 2+ concentration and depolarized membrane potential, compared to R-ones.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1,
          "exclude": true
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "tumours",
          "claim": "Restoring bioelectric communication among tumour cells is proposed to suppress carcinogenesis.",
          "quote": "the interference with (or restoration of) bioelectric communication among tumor cells should be able to suppress carcinogenesis",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "breast tumour cells and microenvironment",
          "claim": "Tumour cells sense and use the epigenetic/bioelectric microenvironment to shape a survival strategy.",
          "quote": "We propose here a connection between epigenetics, environment, and bioelectric changes that the tumor cell senses, uses, and copes-with to shape a survival strategy.",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76788",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Acute multidrug delivery via a wearable bioreactor facilitates long-term limb regeneration and functional recovery in adult Xenopus laevis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "adult Xenopus laevis hindlimb amputation",
          "claim": "A 24-hour exposure to a five-drug cocktail in a wearable bioreactor triggered a regenerative response lasting over a year.",
          "quote": "We found that a brief (24-hour) exposure to this MDT delivered by wearable bioreactor resulted in a remarkable limb regenerative response lasting over 1 year.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "adult Xenopus laevis hindlimb",
          "claim": "Treated adult frogs showed long-term, self-sustaining growth and tissue repatterning of the limb.",
          "quote": "We also observed long-term growth and significant tissue repatterning that was self-sustaining.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "adult Xenopus laevis hindlimb",
          "claim": "Regenerated limbs were reinnervated and regained sensorimotor function.",
          "quote": "de novo tissue formation including reinnervation that successfully reestablished sensorimotor function",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "limb regeneration",
          "claim": "Triggering native, self-limiting organogenesis modules is proposed as more efficient than micromanaging the process.",
          "quote": "the fastest path toward this goal may lie in triggering native, self-limiting modules of organogenesis, not continuous micromanagement of the lengthy process at the cell and molecular levels",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76790",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Potassium channel-driven bioelectric signalling regulates metastasis in triple-negative breast cancer",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric regulation of cancer invasion",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "triple-negative breast cancer cells and mouse model",
          "claim": "Altering resting potential via K+ channels changes invasion, tumour growth and metastasis; a K+ channel blocker reduced metastasis.",
          "quote": "Our results demonstrate that bioelectricity regulates cancer cell invasion and metastasis which could lead to a new class of therapeutics for patients with metastatic disease.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76791",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Evolution and emergence: higher order information structure in protein interactomes across the tree of life",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Causal emergence (informative macroscales)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "protein interactomes of >1800 species",
          "claim": "Effective information reveals higher-order macroscales with lower noise and degeneracy, more pronounced in eukaryotes.",
          "quote": "We show the emergence of higher order 'macroscales' in these interactomes and that these biological macroscales are associated with lower noise and degeneracy and therefore lower uncertainty.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Resilience of macroscale components",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "protein interactomes",
          "claim": "Nodes participating in the macroscale are more resilient than nodes outside it.",
          "quote": "the nodes in the interactomes that make up the macroscale are more resilient compared with nodes that do not participate in the macroscale",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Macroscales easing control and evolvability",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biological networks",
          "claim": "Informative macroscales may make outcomes easier to control and easier for evolution to construct since they are multiply realizable.",
          "quote": "possessing informative macroscales might make for easier control of particular outcomes or processes, such as cell differentiation",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76793",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Kinematic self-replication in reconfigurable organisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Kinematic self-replication",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus reconfigurable organisms (xenobots)",
          "claim": "Synthetic multicellular assemblies replicate by moving and compressing dissociated cells into functional self-copies.",
          "quote": "We find that synthetic multicellular assemblies can also replicate kinematically by moving and compressing dissociated cells in their environment into functional self-copies.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Opportunistic unselected behaviour",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus reconfigurable organisms",
          "claim": "Kinematic replication arises spontaneously in days without selection or genetic engineering.",
          "quote": "Furthermore, replication does not evolve in response to selection pressures, but arises spontaneously over 5 d given appropriate initial and environmental conditions.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Shape-function coupling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "AI-designed reconfigurable organisms",
          "claim": "AI-designed body shapes postpone loss of replicative ability and do useful work as a side effect.",
          "quote": "We also show how artificial intelligence methods can design assemblies that postpone loss of replicative ability and perform useful work as a side effect of replication.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective locomotion from identical local rules",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "groups of reconfigurable organisms",
          "claim": "The combined movement of groups of organisms aggregates dissociated cells into piles that become offspring.",
          "quote": "their combined movement reaggregates some of the dissociated cells into piles",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76794",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Behaviorist approaches to investigating memory and learning: A primer for synthetic biology and bioengineering",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Habituation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "novel synthetic organisms / biobots",
          "claim": "Habituation assays (with or without context) are proposed for probing learning in novel organisms.",
          "quote": "If the organism in question can process contextual information, habituation will be demonstrated in one context and re-learned in another.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "novel synthetic organisms / biobots",
          "claim": "Classical, instrumental and operant conditioning paradigms are offered as substrate-independent learning assays.",
          "quote": "The three types of associative learning that have received the most attention are classical, instrumental, and operant conditioning.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Learning in unconventional substrates",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cells, molecular pathways, gene regulatory networks",
          "claim": "Learning capacity has been suggested in cells and subcellular components such as pathways and GRNs.",
          "quote": "Learning capacity, in the sense of specific changes of future responses in light of past experiences [91], has been suggested in many unconventional substrates",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells and tissues in regenerative medicine; synthetic living machines",
          "claim": "Training via stimuli could exploit cells' learning capacities to reach morphogenetic endpoints too complex to micromanage.",
          "quote": "using stimuli, not hardware rewiring, to achieve desired endpoints such as specific morphogenetic outcomes",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Anticipation of future events",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biobots / novel living constructs",
          "claim": "Novel constructs should be characterized for decisions, memory, learning and anticipation of stimuli.",
          "quote": "characterize the behavioral capacity of novel living constructs in terms of their ability to make decisions, form memories, learn from experience, and anticipate future stimuli",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76795",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "A Comprehensive Conceptual and Computational Dynamics Framework for Autonomous Regeneration Systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "computational worm-like artificial organism (AANN tissues + stem cell network)",
          "claim": "The model achieves complete, accurate regeneration from any damage, needing only a single surviving stem cell.",
          "quote": "The model uniquely achieves complete and accurate regeneration from any damage anywhere in the system.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Damage detection and localization",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "computational regeneration model",
          "claim": "Stem cells monitor pattern integrity via entropy; its violation triggers damage detection and repair.",
          "quote": "Through entropy, a measure of communication between a stem cell and differentiated cells, stem cells monitor the tissue pattern integrity, violation of which triggers damage detection and tissue repair.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Local repair without global rework",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "computational regeneration model",
          "claim": "Only the damaged region of the network is activated, and the pattern is restored without extra cells.",
          "quote": "the AANN only activates a small region of its space where the damage is as guided by the stem cell",
          "page": 25,
          "page_end": 26
        },
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical goals and subgoals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "computational regeneration model",
          "claim": "Regeneration operates at two collaborating levels: tissue self-repair and stem-cell network repair using an information field.",
          "quote": "The model accomplishes regeneration at two levels: In the first level, damaged tissues with intact stem cells regenerate themselves.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76797",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Stability and robustness properties of bioelectric networks: A computational approach",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian electrodiffusion bioelectric network model",
          "claim": "Robust gradients across fragment sizes required allometric scaling of gap-junction density with worm size.",
          "quote": "We showed that robustness across fragment sizes required an allometric change in GJscale across worm size.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian bioelectric network model",
          "claim": "With sufficient loop gain (moderate cooperativity, higher-valence morphogen), fragments robustly regenerate the head-tail gradient across positions and sizes.",
          "quote": "creating loop gain by combining a low or moderate cooperativity with a higher-valence morphogen worked quite well across the range of fragment locations and worm sizes",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Robust invariant patterning despite changing cell number",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric networks",
          "claim": "Bioelectric networks can provide invariant patterning cues despite changes in cell number and tissue configuration.",
          "quote": "A key aspect of bioelectric networks is their robustness, which can drive correct, invariant patterning cues despite changing cell number and anatomical configuration of the underlying tissue network.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76799",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Beyond Neurons: Long Distance Communication in Development and Cancer",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric signalling",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "development and cancer (non-neural cells)",
          "claim": "Bioelectric coupling provides high-level patterning instructions in development and drives malignancy cascades in cancer.",
          "quote": "Bioelectric signals can electrically couple cells during development, providing high level instructions for patterning and morphogenesis, and in cancer initiate signaling cascades to increase malignancy.",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cancer",
          "claim": "Cancer reflects breakdown of normal cell communication alongside new communication routes within the tumour 'organism'.",
          "quote": "there is simultaneously a breakdown of normal signaling but also the establishment of new communication routes with the recruitment of macrophages and formation of TMPs",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range communication via nanotubes and macrophage relays",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "development and cancer",
          "claim": "Tunneling nanotubes and macrophages act as long-distance communication relays shaping patterning and metastatic niches.",
          "quote": "acting as relay cells to facilitate crosstalk between different cell types during development and establishing metastatic niches for cancer cells in distant organs",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Whole-group context sensitivity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells in multicellular organisms",
          "claim": "A cell's behaviour is an emergent integration of information from throughout the body rather than a local phenomenon.",
          "quote": "a cell's behavior is not a local phenomenon, but rather an emergent integration of information from throughout the body",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76801",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Scale invariant robot behavior with fractals",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Scale-invariant behaviour via fractal self-similarity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "modular soft robots and ciliated biobots (simulation and physical)",
          "claim": "Under some conditions a robot's behaviour is preserved when fractally connected to copies of itself, across size scales.",
          "quote": "The results demonstrate that, under certain conditions, the nonrandom behavior of a single robot can be preserved when connected with copies of itself fractally.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "ciliated biobots",
          "claim": "Biobots spontaneously attached and kept scale-invariant behaviour up to supermillimeter scales.",
          "quote": "The micrometer length scale biobots investigated here exhibited spontaneous attachment and scale invariant behavior up to supermillimeter length scales.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76803",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Metabolic limits on classical information processing by biological cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Quantum coherence as computational resource",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells",
          "claim": "Cellular energy budgets cannot sustain classical molecular states, so bulk cell biochemistry is proposed to implement quantum information processing.",
          "quote": "We suggest that decoherence is limited to the immediate surroundings of the cell membrane and of intercompartmental boundaries within the cell, and that bulk cellular biochemistry implements quantum information processing.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Energetic limits on classical information processing",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "cells (energy budgets vs decoherence)",
          "claim": "Comparing measured cellular power budgets to the cost of maintaining classical protein states bounds classical computation in cells.",
          "quote": "Measured cellular energy budgets of both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, however, fall orders of magnitude short of the power required to maintain classical states of protein conformation and localization",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76804",
      "year": 2022,
      "title": "Inducing Vertebrate Limb Regeneration: A Review of Past Advances and Future Outlook",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Induced regeneration in non-regenerative species",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "frogs and mammals (mice, rats)",
          "claim": "Genetic, biochemical and bioelectric interventions partially restore limb regeneration in poorly regenerating vertebrates.",
          "quote": "Targeted manipulation of biochemical pathways via systemic or local treatment with pharmacological substances has proven to be the most effective and reproducible means to induce vertebrate limb regeneration",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 19
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "vertebrate appendage regeneration",
          "claim": "The only reported complete induced appendage regeneration in a non-regenerative system used bioelectric manipulation.",
          "quote": "the only ever reported instance of inducing complete vertebrate appendage regeneration occurring in a nonregenerative system was achieved through the manipulation of bioelectrics",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 22
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "vertebrate limb",
          "claim": "Limb regeneration exemplifies how cells cooperate to build specific organs and stop when the correct anatomy is complete.",
          "quote": "how do cells cooperate to build specific complex organs and stop precisely when the correct anatomical structure is complete",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamanders",
          "claim": "Salamanders proficiently regenerate limbs throughout their lifespan via epimorphic blastema formation.",
          "quote": "some animals, such as salamanders, are proficient regenerators of limbs throughout their life span",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76805",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Minimal physicalism as a scale-free substrate for cognition and consciousness",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Scale-free cognition (non-neural generalization)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "basal systems from molecules to organisms (minimal physicalism)",
          "claim": "Consciousness and cognition are characterized scale-free so that basal non-neural and synthetic systems are informative.",
          "quote": "we advance a scale-free characterization of consciousness and cognition that regards basal systems, including synthetic constructs, as not only informative",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stigmergic memory",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "generic physical/biological systems",
          "claim": "Stigmergic memory, perceptual coarse-graining and attention switching follow from thermodynamic requirements of classical computation.",
          "quote": "common phenomena including stigmergic memory, perceptual coarse-graining, and attention switching follow directly from the thermodynamic requirements of classical computation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Selective orienting and attention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "generic physical/biological systems",
          "claim": "Attention switching is derived as a consequence of the thermodynamics of classical computation.",
          "quote": "perceptual coarse-graining, and attention switching follow directly from the thermodynamic requirements of classical computation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-representation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bacteria and other basal systems",
          "claim": "Self-representation underlying autonoetic awareness is traced back to the bacterial stress response.",
          "quote": "the self-representation that lies at the heart of human autonoetic awareness can be traced as far back as, and serves the same basic functions as, the stress response in bacteria",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Allostasis and changing targets",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "E. coli to humans",
          "claim": "Homeostatic/allostatic drives are phylogenetically continuous from prokaryotes to humans.",
          "quote": "Our homeostatic/allostatic drives and the mechanisms that satisfy them are phylogenetically continuous with those of prokaryotic unicells including E. coli.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76806",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Mechanosensation Mediates Long-Range Spatial Decision-Making in an Aneural Organism",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Two-option discrimination",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Physarum reliably prefers heavier, substrate-deforming but chemically inert masses when given multiple options.",
          "quote": "it showed a reliable preference for objects with greater mass when presented with multiple options, demonstrating the ability to detect and compare the physical properties of aspects of its environment",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Decision before overt progress",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Small Physarum pieces detect objects centimetres away and decide which way to go hours before moving there.",
          "quote": "decide which way to go hours before actually moving in that direction",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range mechanosensation via substrate strain",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Mass sensing depends on TRP-channel mechanosensation and is modelled as sensing the fraction of perimeter strained above threshold.",
          "quote": "Physarum may perform this calculation by sensing the fraction of its growth perimeter that is distorted above a threshold strain - a fundamentally novel method of mechanosensation",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Frequency-selective response",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Mass-sensing is abolished by gentle rhythmic mechanical disruption (frequency- and inclination-dependent).",
          "quote": "This long-range mass-sensing is abolished by gentle rhythmic mechanical disruption, changing substrate stiffness, or addition of a mechanosensitive transient receptor potential channel inhibitor.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76810",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Synthetic living machines: A new window on life",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots from Xenopus ectoderm",
          "claim": "Dissociated wild-type cells reboot multicellularity into a novel proto-body with new morphology and behaviour.",
          "quote": "Dissociated cells, liberated from the rest of the embryo, reboot their multicellularity along a novel path: they coalesce and assemble into a spherical proto-body that has a morphology,",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Local repair without global rework",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots repair their novel body form after mechanical damage.",
          "quote": "ability to repair after mechanical damage (to their new Xenobot forms)",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective locomotion from identical local rules",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Groups of Xenobots rearrange particles into patterns predicted by a multiscale computational model.",
          "quote": "collective behavior that rearranges particles in their milieu into patterns that was effectively predicted by a multi-scale computational model",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots with photoconvertible protein",
          "claim": "Xenobots implemented a long-term, externally readable record of light exposure.",
          "quote": "a simple photo-memory functionality, where a synthetic protein was used to implement a long-term, externally readable engram of fluorescent light exposure experience",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Opportunistic unselected behaviour",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Skin cells self-organize into coherent proto-organisms in hours without specific selection for those anatomies/behaviours.",
          "quote": "Skin cells, in a novel configuration, can self-organize structure and function toward that of a coherent proto-organism in hours-without the benefit of evolutionary timescales",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76813",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Learning and synaptic plasticity in 3D bioengineered neural tissues",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Habituation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "3D bioengineered neural tissue in vitro",
          "claim": "Repetitive current injections produced frequency-dependent habituation of evoked potentials.",
          "quote": "we demonstrate response patterns characteristic of habituation, a form of non-associative learning, in 3D bioengineered neural tissues exposed to repetitive injections of current",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Extinction and spontaneous recovery",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "3D bioengineered neural tissue",
          "claim": "The habituated response partially returned after rest, more likely at lower stimulation frequencies.",
          "quote": "A return of the evoked response following rest indicated learning was transient and partially reversible.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Frequency-selective response",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "3D bioengineered neural tissue",
          "claim": "Habituation depended on stimulation frequency.",
          "quote": "We observed a clear frequency-dependent (Figure 3A) and partially reversible (Figure 3B,C) habituation response which achieved an asymptote",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Spaced versus massed training effects",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "3D bioengineered neural tissue",
          "claim": "Massed vs distributed current trains induced different immediate-early gene expression, with distributed patterns inducing plasticity.",
          "quote": "As expected the distributed current pattern successfully induced synaptic plasticity.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76814",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Bioelectric signaling: Reprogrammable circuits underlying embryogenesis, regeneration, and cancer",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus 'Picasso' tadpoles",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with organs in wrong locations still produce largely normal frog faces via unnatural paths.",
          "quote": "even if tadpoles are created in a ''Picasso'' configuration with eyes, jaws, and other organs in the wrong locations, they will produce largely normal frog faces",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Whole-group context sensitivity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamander tail grafted to flank",
          "claim": "Grafted tails remodel into limbs to match the large-scale body plan although local cell environments are normal.",
          "quote": "Salamander tails grafted to the flank slowly remodel into a limb-altering the existing tissue structure to become correct with respect to the large-scale body plan",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Proportional error correction",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "developing and regenerating organisms",
          "claim": "Anatomical homeostasis is the ability to activate cell behaviours that progressively reduce error from the target morphology.",
          "quote": "the ability of the system to activate the necessary sequences of cell behaviors to progressively reduce the error between the current state and the species-specific target morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Switching mechanisms after failure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "newt kidney tubules",
          "claim": "Correct tubule geometry results from either many cells or just one, harnessing different molecular mechanisms.",
          "quote": "kidney tubules of the correct cross-sectional geometry result from the activity of either many or just one cell, showing that diverse underlying molecular mechanisms can be harnessed as needed",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Brief bioelectric perturbation permanently changes the target morphology: two-headed worms keep regenerating two heads.",
          "quote": "The permanent change of the planarians' target morphology is triggered by a brief modulation of bioelectric circuit states.",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "non-neural bioelectric circuits",
          "claim": "Multi-stable bioelectric states in non-neural tissues are thought to resemble neural memory.",
          "quote": "Multi-stable bioelectric states in non-neural tissues are thought to be similar to neural memory",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Alternative stable morphologies",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Gap-junction inhibition yields regenerates with head shapes of other planarian species.",
          "quote": "resulting in regenerates with radical changes in the external shape of the head (among triangular, rounded, and flat morphologies)",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "tissues across species",
          "claim": "Bioelectric networks process morphogenetic information enabling cell collectives to decide about large-scale growth and form.",
          "quote": "These bioelectrical networks process morphogenetic information that controls gene expression, enabling cell collectives to make decisions about large-scale growth and form.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76815",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Living Things Are Not (20th Century) Machines: Updating Mechanism Metaphors in Light of the Modern Science of Machine Behavior",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "machines and living systems",
          "claim": "Systems lie on a persuadability scale measured by intervention energy relative to resulting behavioural change.",
          "quote": "One way to formalize this distinction is through the relative amount of energy or effort used in an intervention compared to the change in the system's behavior.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Graded agency across substrates",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "evolved, designed and hybrid systems",
          "claim": "There is a continuous option space of agents that can be rewired, trained, signalled and persuaded, without sharp life/machine boundaries.",
          "quote": "We live in a universe containing a rich, continuous option space of agents with which we can interact by re-wiring, training, motivating, signaling, communicating, and persuading.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76816",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Uncovering cognitive similarities and differences, conservation and innovation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Morphogenesis as basal cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular animals",
          "claim": "Cognition in 3D space is an evolutionary pivot of an older system guiding body structure in morphospace.",
          "quote": "this function is the result of a clever pivot by the evolution of a much more ancient system: the guidance of body structure in morphospace",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Bioelectrically destabilized planaria stochastically flip between one- and two-headed regeneration, analogous to perceptual bistability.",
          "quote": "these worms exist in a bistable state that can readily (and stochastically) flip between two representations of what anatomy to build following damage",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Latent or counterfactual memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "A two-headed pattern can be stored in a one-headed body, representing anatomy to build after future injury.",
          "quote": "the ability to represent counterfactual states, in this case, a two-headed pattern stored in a one-headed body",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerative medicine",
          "claim": "Cognitive approaches suggest triggering modular responses and rewriting goal states instead of micromanaging cells.",
          "quote": "exploiting triggers of modular responses, re-writing goal states without rewiring cellular hardware and motivating tissue decision making instead of micromanagement",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective foraging benefit",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "fungal mycelia",
          "claim": "Mycelia sense, decide and communicate to forage for scarce resources and redistribute them.",
          "quote": "Fungal mycelia, the network constituted by these hyphae, exhibit sensing, decision making and intercellular communication systems to forage for scarce resources",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ],
      "note": "Theme-issue introduction (basal cognition); mostly reports contributions."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76817",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Reframing cognition: getting down to biological basics",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Basal cognitive toolkit",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "organisms across the tree of life",
          "claim": "Cognition is operationalized as a toolkit of separable capacities: sensing, memory, valence, learning, decision-making, communication.",
          "quote": "introduce a behaviour-generating toolkit of capacities that comprise the function (e.g. sensing/perception, memory, valence, learning, decision making, communication)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Myxococcus xanthus",
          "claim": "Social Myxococcus behaviours arise from cells making memory-based decisions propagated over large spatiotemporal scales.",
          "quote": "allowing them to make memory-based decisions that are propagated over very large spatio-temporal scales",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Cue integration and conflicting evidence",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Myxococcus xanthus",
          "claim": "Multicellular swarming behaviours require sensing, signal integration, memory and decision-making.",
          "quote": "All of these multicellular behaviours require environmental sensing, signal integration, memory and decision-making",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ],
      "note": "Theme-issue introduction defining basal cognition."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76819",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "A Meta-Analysis of Bioelectric Data in Cancer, Embryogenesis, and Regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "channelopathies in mouse, zebrafish, Drosophila, C. elegans, human",
          "claim": "Many ion channel/pump mutations cause structural malformations, showing patterning depends on bioelectric state.",
          "quote": "These data reveal that numerous aspects of pattern formation, especially including the skeletal, neural, craniofacial, and cardiac systems, depend on the function of gene products that regulate bioelectric state.",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Conserved bioelectric regeneration machinery",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "regeneration blastema transcriptomes across taxa",
          "claim": "Bioinformatic analysis finds an electrogenic protein (V-ATPase) expressed in regeneration blastemas across Kingdoms.",
          "quote": "reveals an electrogenic protein to be the one common factor specifically expressed in regeneration blastemas across Kingdoms",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric signature of cancer",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "normal vs cancer cells (Vmem data)",
          "claim": "Meta-analysis of Vmem reveals a specific bioelectric signature corresponding to some malignancies.",
          "quote": "we analyze data on distinct Vmem signatures in normal and cancer cells, revealing a specific bioelectrical signature corresponding to some types of malignancies",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76820",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Bistability of somatic pattern memories: stochastic outcomes in bioelectric circuits underlying regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "A brief gap-junction blocker exposure permanently re-writes the target morphology so fragments keep regenerating two heads.",
          "quote": "a transient (48 h) stimulus permanently alters the pattern to which fragments regenerate in the future",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planaria (Cryptic worms) via perceptual bistability models",
          "claim": "Stochastic one- vs two-headed regeneration of Cryptic worms is interpreted via bistability in brain memory models.",
          "quote": "We propose a new interpretation of recent stochastic regenerative phenotypes in planaria, by appealing to computational models of memory representation and processing in the brain.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Latent or counterfactual memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Regenerating tissue stores latent/counterfactual pattern memories that guide future anatomy only if recalled by injury.",
          "quote": "to store 'potential', future, or 'counterfactual' pattern memories that may be latent (not expressed as anatomy now, but guiding future anatomical events if recalled by injury)",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Induced bioelectric changes are stored in planarian tissue for over a week, a long-term re-writable memory medium.",
          "quote": "bioelectric changes induced in planaria can be stored in tissue for over a week, thus revealing that somatic bioelectric circuits in vivo can implement a long-term, re-writable memory medium",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rejuvenation by local reset",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Two-headed and Cryptic worms can be reset to normal by a proton-potassium pump blocker.",
          "quote": "These animals can be re-set back to normal by exposure to the proton-potassium ion pump blocker SCH28080",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3,
          "map_to": "Rewritable target memory"
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regeneration and regulative development",
          "claim": "Restoration of correct anatomy from diverse starting states is attributed to bioelectric encoding of distributed goal states.",
          "quote": "regeneration and regulative development can restore correct large-scale anatomies from diverse starting states because, like the brain, they exploit bioelectric encoding of distributed goal states",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76821",
      "year": 2021,
      "title": "Gene regulatory networks exhibit several kinds of memory: Quantification of memory in biological and random transcriptional networks",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Boolean gene regulatory network models (Cell Collective)",
          "claim": "GRNs from many model systems are predicted to exhibit Pavlovian conditioning in which a neutral stimulus becomes a conditioned driver of a response.",
          "quote": "We show that GRNs from a wide range of model systems are predicted to possess several types of memory, including Pavlovian conditioning.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Boolean gene regulatory network models",
          "claim": "UCS-based memory: a transient stimulus causes long-term response induction.",
          "quote": "UCS-based memory (UM, long-term response induction by a specific stimulus)",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Pairing memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Boolean gene regulatory network models",
          "claim": "Pairing memory: one-shot stabilization of response to compound cues.",
          "quote": "pairing memory (PM, one-shot stabilization of response to compound cues)",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Transfer memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Boolean gene regulatory network models",
          "claim": "Transfer memory resembles discrimination training yielding a more generalized response.",
          "quote": "transfer memory (TM, resembling discrimination training that results in a more generalized response)",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Long versus short associative recall",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Boolean gene regulatory network models",
          "claim": "Associative memory is split into long-recall and short-recall subtypes.",
          "quote": "associative memory (AM, including two of its sub-categories: long recall associativememory [LRAM] and short recall associative memory [SRAM]), and consolidation memory (CM)",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Memory capacity enriched by evolution",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "biological vs randomized GRNs",
          "claim": "Biological GRNs show more memory than randomized controls; vertebrate and differentiated-cell networks have the most.",
          "quote": "We find evidence of natural selection favoring GRN memory.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "GRNs in biomedicine",
          "claim": "Timed stimulus patterns, rather than genetic rewiring, can stably change GRN behaviour for biomedical control.",
          "quote": "Timed stimuli are a powerful alternative for biomedical control of complex in vivo dynamics without genomic editing or transgenes.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76828",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Machine Learning‐Driven Bioelectronics for Closed‐Loop Control of Cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Closed-loop bioelectronic setpoint control",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "pluripotent mammalian stem cells with proton-conducting bioelectronics and ML controller",
          "claim": "A machine-learning controller drives cell Vmem toward a desired setpoint in real time via bioelectronic pH actuation.",
          "quote": "proof-of-concept real-time control of Vmem toward a desired set-point is demonstrated",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76829",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Precise control of ion channel and gap junction expression is required for patterning of the regenerating axolotl limb",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "axolotl limb blastema",
          "claim": "Misexpressing ion channels or Cx26, or blocking gap junctions, during regeneration caused digit loss, syndactyly and structural defects.",
          "quote": "Our data reveal that manipulating native ion channel and gap junction function in blastema cells results in patterning defects involving the number and structure of the regenerated digits.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Coordination range and topology constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "axolotl limb blastema",
          "claim": "Both increasing and blocking gap-junction communication disrupted patterning, indicating precise coupling is needed for coordination.",
          "quote": "interfering with gap junction communication via lindane-induced blockade, which is a general gap junction blocker, caused more severe defects associated with distal elements lost in all limbs examined",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76830",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Why isn't sex optional? Stem-cell competition, loss of regenerative capacity, and cancer in metazoan evolution",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Hijacking and false signals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "metazoan stem-cell lineages",
          "claim": "Coercive or deceptive cell-cell signalling can make costly cooperation appear less costly to the cooperating cell.",
          "quote": "We show how coercive or deceptive cell-cell signaling can be used to make costly cooperative behaviors appear less costly to the cooperating party.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Cooperation supported by competition",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "germline vs non-germline stem cells",
          "claim": "Winner-take-all competition between stem lineages destabilizes vegetative reproduction with facultative sex, leading to obligate sex.",
          "quote": "competition between stem-cell lineages can render an ancestral combination of vegetative reproduction with facultative sex unstable, with one or the other process driven to extinction",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "obligately sexual animal lineages",
          "claim": "Increased cancer susceptibility is proposed as a side effect of deceptive signalling exacerbated by loss of whole-body regeneration.",
          "quote": "The increased susceptibility to cancer observed in obligatelysexual lineages is, we suggest, a side-effect of deceptive signaling that is exacerbated by the loss of whole-body regenerative abilities.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "whole-body regenerators",
          "claim": "Whole-body regeneration requires dispersed cells able to read local information about target morphology; centralizing that encoding (e.g. CNS) may remove it.",
          "quote": "any transition from a dispersed to a centralized encoding of target morphology can dis­ rupt the capability for WBR by removing local sources of information",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76833",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Interferon-Gamma Stimulated Murine Macrophages In Vitro : Impact of Ionic Composition and Osmolarity and Therapeutic Implications",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Macrophage responses to ionic composition/osmolarity in vitro; cell-level immunology, no organism-level capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76834",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Bioelectronic control of chloride ions and concentration with Ag/AgCl contacts",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Device engineering (Ag/AgCl chloride control); no capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76836",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Nervous system and tissue polarity dynamically adapt to new morphologies in planaria",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Whole-group context sensitivity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "double-headed planaria",
          "claim": "Established tissue polarity (cilia beat direction) reorients to match the new organism-level anatomy of double-headed worms.",
          "quote": "Tracking of cilia-driven flow to characterize planar cell polarity of the epithelium revealed a remarkable reorientation of tissue polarity in double-headed planarians.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Nervous-system control of tissue polarity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "double-headed planaria",
          "claim": "Signals from the intact brain/CNS drive re-orientation of tissue-level polarity to match organism-level anatomy.",
          "quote": "signals from the central nervous system can dynamically control and re-orient tissue-level polarity to match the organismlevel anatomical configuration",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Remodelling of existing tissue without new cells",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "irradiated double-headed planaria",
          "claim": "Cilia reorientation proceeds after stem-cell removal, so pre-existing cells are remodelled in place.",
          "quote": "We found that inhibition of new cell formation did not impact the reorientation of cilia, indicating that the reorientation of the cilia likely takes place in pre-existing multiciliated cells.",
          "page": 20,
          "page_end": 21
        },
        {
          "name": "Sensor and effector remapping",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "double-headed planaria nervous system",
          "claim": "The nervous system adapts its polarity to match the new organismal anatomy.",
          "quote": "The nervous system itself adapts its polarity to match the new organismal anatomy in these animals as revealed by distinct regenerative outcomes driven by polarized nerve transport.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76838",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "On the coupling of mechanics with bioelectricity and its role in morphogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Mechano-bioelectric feedback",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BETSE simulations of cell clusters with mechanosensitive channels",
          "claim": "Bioelectric ion fluxes generate osmotic/electrostatic forces deforming clusters, and mechanosensitive channels feed tension back into bioelectric state.",
          "quote": "We further account for mechanosensitive ion channels, which, gated by membrane tension, modulate ion fluxes and, ultimately, bioelectrical forces.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "BETSE cell cluster simulations",
          "claim": "K+-selective mechanosensitive channels can be exploited to obtain asymmetric patterning or non-local bioelectric signals under mechanical stress.",
          "quote": "K + -selective MCs may be exploited to obtain asymmetric patterning, or to induce non-local bioelectric signals in regions with larger mechanical stress",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "simulated tumour (depolarized) cell ensembles",
          "claim": "Osmotic forces expand depolarized regions; overexpressing K+-selective mechanosensitive channels could hinder cancer progression.",
          "quote": "We suggest that overexpressing K + -selective MCs in depolarized cells could help to hinder cancer progression",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76839",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Richard Borgens, 1946–2019",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "limb development/regeneration, brain development",
          "claim": "Borgens showed endogenous transepithelial electric gradients are important for limb development/regeneration and act instructively in repair.",
          "quote": "He published some of the best functional data showing that endogenous transepithelial electrical gradients were important for limb development and regeneration.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Obituary of Richard Borgens; only a passing mention of his bioelectric regeneration work."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76840",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Emergence of informative higher scales in biological systems: a computational toolkit for optimal prediction and control",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Causal emergence (informative macroscales)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "gene regulatory networks (mammalian cardiac GRN, yeast GRN)",
          "claim": "Effective information shows macro-scale models of GRNs can be more informative than micro-scale models.",
          "quote": "we made use of the effective information (EI) to assess the informativeness of a causal model, and then showed how EI can increase at macro-scales",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Macroscales easing control and evolvability",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biological networks",
          "claim": "Multi-scale structure is proposed to confer error correction, robustness, plasticity and evolvability/learnability.",
          "quote": "Given the advantages that multi-scale structures pos­ sess, which include error-correction, increased robust­ ness, plasticity, and evolvability/learnability, we expect causal emergence to be common across nature.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76841",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "A 3D Tissue Model of Traumatic Brain Injury with Excitotoxicity That Is Inhibited by Chronic Exposure to Gabapentinoids",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "3D tissue model of traumatic brain injury and drug protection; disease-model/pharmacology, no capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76842",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Applications and ethics of computer-designed organisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly under new constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots (Xenopus skin and cardiac cells)",
          "claim": "Wild-type frog cells self-assemble into a novel motile living entity without genomic editing or scaffolds.",
          "quote": "wild-type Xenopus laevis skin and cardiac cells were able to aggregate and self-assemble into a novel motile 'living entity' of ~0.1-0.5 mm in diameter, without genomic editing",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Local repair without global rework",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots regenerate after damage despite lacking nerves or a brain.",
          "quote": "Devoid of nerves or a brain, these synthetic living machines move, regenerate after damage and cooperate with each other to redistribute smaller particles in their environment.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective locomotion from identical local rules",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenobots",
          "claim": "Xenobots cooperate to redistribute particles in their environment.",
          "quote": "cooperate with each other to redistribute smaller particles in their environment",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Proxy-metric artifacts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "evolutionary design of biobots",
          "claim": "Automated scoring in evolutionary design creates an AI control problem: tasks solved in unintended ways.",
          "quote": "this automated scoring introduces an AI control problem: a problem might be solved but not in the way that the user wished",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76847",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "HCN2 Channel-Induced Rescue of Brain Teratogenesis via Local and Long-Range Bioelectric Repair",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric signalling",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos exposed to nicotine",
          "claim": "Distant HCN2 expression or HCN2-expressing transplants non-cell-autonomously reverse brain defects.",
          "quote": "We show that distal HCN2 channel misexpression and distal transplants of HCN2-expressing tissue, non-cell-autonomously reverse profound defects, rescuing brain anatomy, gene expression, and learning.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryonic brain",
          "claim": "Enforcing the endogenous Vmem prepattern restores brain pattern despite genetic, chemical and mechanical insults.",
          "quote": "externally enforcing this pattern restores brain pattern despite a range of genetic, chemical, and mechanical insults",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Proportional error correction",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo (HCN2 channels)",
          "claim": "HCN2 has little effect where Vmem boundaries are strong but restores weakened differentials, correcting only where needed.",
          "quote": "in regions where boundaries have become significantly weakened (e.g., because of teratogens like nicotine), HCN2 increases the differential to normal levels, correcting morphogenesis",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "Small-molecule HCN2 activators rescue brain morphology and learning even with delayed treatment.",
          "quote": "such rescue can be induced by small-molecule HCN2 channel activators, even with delayed treatment initiation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76849",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "von Willebrand factor D and EGF domains is an evolutionarily conserved and required feature of blastemas capable of multitissue appendage regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Conserved blastema regeneration factor",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "axolotl, lungfish, Polypterus, Xenopus appendage blastemas",
          "claim": "vwde expression is a conserved feature of limb/fin-regenerating blastemas and is required for normal axolotl limb regeneration.",
          "quote": "Functional experiments demonstrate a requirement for vwde in regeneration and indicate that Vwde is a potent growth factor in the blastema.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76850",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Morphogenesis as Bayesian inference: A variational approach to pattern formation and control in complex biological systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Morphogenesis as active inference",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated cell ensembles (variational free energy model)",
          "claim": "Cells modelled as Bayesian agents minimizing free energy infer and build a target morphology.",
          "quote": "8 cells with initially unspecified cell types start to infer a correct target morphology by performing chemotaxis and updating their posterior beliefs",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 19
        },
        {
          "name": "Alternative stable morphologies",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated planarian-like cell ensembles",
          "claim": "Manipulating sensory gradients in the generative process produces double-head or double-tail patterns.",
          "quote": "we introduced a positive squared gradient in the generative process for the signaling inputs that each cell receives from its environment, resulting in double head formation",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 19
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated cell ensemble with a single aberrant cell",
          "claim": "A cell with altered sensitivity models carcinogenesis as false beliefs; modifying signalling rescues the pattern.",
          "quote": "we consider aberrant signaling and functional behavior of a single cell within a cellular ensemble - as a first step in carcinogenesis as false 'beliefs'",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated cell ensembles",
          "claim": "Simple modifications of the inference process cause and rescue mispatterning without changing the generative model (DNA).",
          "quote": "simple modifications of the inference process can cause - and rescue - mis-patterning of developmental and regenerative events without changing the implicit generative model of a cell",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76851",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Sertraline induces DNA damage and cellular toxicity in Drosophila that can be ameliorated by antioxidants",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Toxicology of sertraline in Drosophila; no capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76852",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Revisiting Burr and Northrop’s “The Electro-Dynamic Theory of Life” (1935)",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "eye, brain, fin, skin, L-R and A-P axes across species",
          "claim": "Bioelectric gradients act as prepatterns specifying large-scale anatomy, confirming Burr's hypothesis.",
          "quote": "Spatiotemporal patterns of bioelectric gradients are indeed prepatterns that, along with chemical gradients and biomechanical forces, specify large-scale anatomy of the body",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Nervous-system control of tissue polarity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "developing embryos and regenerating planaria",
          "claim": "The nervous system carries instructive bioelectric signals directing morphogenesis and planarian regeneration polarity.",
          "quote": "the role of the central nervous system in directing planarian regeneration polarity",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric software enabling regenerative plasticity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerating and remodelling tissues",
          "claim": "The bioelectric layer is physiological software letting genome-specified hardware exhibit regenerative plasticity.",
          "quote": "the bioelectric signaling layer is an important aspect of physiological software that enables genome-specified hardware to exhibit the remarkable plasticity observed during regeneration and remodeling",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76853",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Eya2 promotes cell cycle progression by regulating DNA damage response during vertebrate limb regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Genome integrity maintenance during regeneration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "axolotl limb blastema",
          "claim": "A DNA damage response via Eya2 regulating H2AX phosphorylation enables proper cell-cycle progression during regeneration.",
          "quote": "highly-regenerative animals employ a robust DNA damage response pathway which involves regulation of H2AX phosphorylation via Eya2 to facilitate proper cell cycle progression upon injury",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76854",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Scalable sim-to-real transfer of soft robot designs",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Reality gap of evolved designs",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "voxel-based soft robots (simulation vs physical)",
          "claim": "The sim-to-real gap of transferred soft-robot morphologies is quantified and depends on the measure (displacement vs velocity).",
          "quote": "Under one measure (net displacement) the reality gap appeared rather small, but under another (velocity) the gap was much wider",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ],
      "note": "Soft-robot sim-to-real methods paper; competency content limited to measuring the reality gap of evolved morphologies."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76855",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Does regeneration recapitulate phylogeny? Planaria as a model of body-axis specification in ancestral eumetazoa",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Alternative stable morphologies",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "asexual planaria",
          "claim": "Planarian regeneration studies produce an array of viable forms with symmetrized or duplicated body axes.",
          "quote": "Regeneration studies in asexual planaria have demonstrated an array of viable forms with symmetrized and, in some cases, duplicated body axes.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "The planarian A-P axis is highly malleable by molecular, pharmacological and bioelectric manipulation, even to a radially symmetric anteriorized form.",
          "quote": "The A-P axis of planaria, in particular, is highly malleable using molecular, pharmacological, and bioelectric manipulations.",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Nervous-system control of tissue polarity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "early eumetazoans, planaria",
          "claim": "Emergence of neurons as long-range signalling systems is proposed as linked to the emergence of complex body plans.",
          "quote": "The evolutionary emergence of complex body plans appears intimately connected to the emergence of neurons as specialized long-range signaling systems",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76856",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "An in vivo brain–bacteria interface: the developing brain as a key regulator of innate immunity",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Brain regulation of innate immunity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos infected with pathogenic E. coli",
          "claim": "The developing brain protects embryos from infection by reducing damage/apoptosis, promoting macrophage migration and suppressing infection transcriptional responses.",
          "quote": "Without a brain, survival of embryos injected with bacteria decreased significantly.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1,
          "map_to": "Robustness to pathogens, toxins and stress"
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range neural control of distant cell behaviour",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos",
          "claim": "Brain-dependent (dopamine) signals regulate migration of immune cells elsewhere in the body.",
          "quote": "in response to infection, signals from the brain are required for proper macrophage migration (Fig. 3), revealing that brain-dependent signals regulate the behavior of immune cells",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76857",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Toward Decoding Bioelectric Events in Xenopus Embryogenesis: New Methodology for Tracking Interplay Between Calcium and Resting Potentials In Vivo",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos",
          "claim": "Both hyperpolarization and depolarization cause persistent calcium elevation, linked to increased cell migration and abnormal craniofacial morphology.",
          "quote": "cell hyperpolarization and depolarization both induce persistent static elevation of cytoplasmic calcium levels that fade over developmental time",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Mainly an imaging methods paper (4D calcium imaging in Xenopus)."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76858",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Formin, an opinion",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Left-right symmetry breaking from cytoskeletal chirality",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis and frog",
          "claim": "LR asymmetry in snails originates in cellular architecture (formin), and the same gene reverses LR asymmetry when overexpressed in frogs.",
          "quote": "The new work puts beyond any doubt that LR asymmetry in snails originates in the cellular architecture.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Correspondence about formin gene naming/priority for snail chirality; minimal competency content."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76859",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Optogenetically induced cellular habituation in non-neuronal cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Habituation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "optogenetically stimulated HEK cells (non-neural)",
          "claim": "Photocurrent-induced depolarization decreased over repeated stimulation and recovered upon withdrawal, i.e. single non-neural cells habituate.",
          "quote": "demonstrates that nonneuronal cells can habituate in a stimulation-dependent manner",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Frequency-selective response",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "HEK cells",
          "claim": "Habituation profiles depend on stimulation frequency and intensity, with higher frequencies producing more pronounced habituation.",
          "quote": "increasing the stimulation frequency produced a more pronounced profile",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Harmful memory and path dependence",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "HEK cells",
          "claim": "Prior stimulation history changes subsequent depolarization responses.",
          "quote": "the history of stimulations on the cells impacted subsequent depolarization in response to further stimulation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1,
          "map_to": "Sustained response memory"
        },
        {
          "name": "Habituation descriptors",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "HEK cells",
          "claim": "Defines quantitative descriptors of habituation: steady-state effect, time constant and probability of habituation.",
          "quote": "gives defined descriptors to analyze the process (% of effect at s.s., τH and probability of habituation)",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76861",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "A scalable pipeline for designing reconfigurable organisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Shape-function coupling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "AI-designed Xenopus reconfigurable organisms",
          "claim": "Evolved shapes and tissue placement produced predicted locomotion; inverting the design reduced displacement.",
          "quote": "Inverting the design significantly reduces its net displacement (P < 0.001), as did inverting the organisms (P < 0.0001).",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Noise and asynchronous update tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "AI-designed reconfigurable organisms (simulation)",
          "claim": "Evolution produced morphologies that derandomize global movement despite random actuation of cells.",
          "quote": "derandomizing morphologies evolved: evolutionary improvement occurred through changes in overall shape, and distribution of the passive and contractile cells, to collectively derandomize the global movement",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Opportunistic unselected behaviour",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "reconfigurable organisms",
          "claim": "Unselected behaviours emerged: spontaneous cardiomyocyte coordination, collective debris aggregation and self-repair.",
          "quote": "although signaling between cardiomyocytes was not enforced, emergent spontaneous coordination among the cardiac muscle cells produced coherent, phase-matched contractions which aided locomotion",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Bridging damage or transporting debris",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "groups of reconfigurable organisms",
          "claim": "Groups of organisms spontaneously and collectively aggregate debris in their environment.",
          "quote": "some of the designs, when combined, spontaneously and collectively aggregate detritus littered within their shared environment",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Local repair without global rework",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "reconfigurable organisms",
          "claim": "Organisms self-maintain their imposed configuration and self-repair damage such as closing lacerations.",
          "quote": "reconfigurable organisms not only self-maintain their externally imposed configuration, but they also self-repair in the face of damage, such as automatically closing lacerations",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76862",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Assessment of Enrichment of Human Mesenchymal Stem Cells Based on Plasma and Mitochondrial Membrane Potentials",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric state predicts cell phenotype",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human mesenchymal stem cells",
          "claim": "hMSCs sorted by TMRE (electrical state) differ in senescence, autophagy and immunomodulatory gene expression.",
          "quote": "EE-hMSCs with low levels of TMRE, indicative of depolarized membrane potential, have reduced mRNA expression of senescence-associated markers",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Cell-therapy study sorting hMSCs by electrical state; competency content limited to bioelectric state correlating with cell phenotype."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76863",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Post-SSRI Sexual Dysfunction: A Bioelectric Mechanism?",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian flatworms",
          "claim": "Brief SSRI exposure induces long-lasting changes in the planarian resting potential profile persisting after withdrawal.",
          "quote": "brief SSRI exposures induce long-lasting changes in resting potential profile",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Harmful memory and path dependence",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "human tissues (post-SSRI sexual dysfunction)",
          "claim": "Persistent dysfunction after SSRI use is proposed to reflect bioelectric circuits stably maintaining altered states.",
          "quote": "Bioelectric circuits (among neural or non-neural cells) could persistently maintain alterations of bioelectric cell properties (resting potential), resulting in long-term changes in electrophysiology and signaling.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76865",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Bioelectrical model of head-tail patterning based on cell ion channels and intercellular gap junctions",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric two-cell and multicellular models of planarian head-tail patterning",
          "claim": "The bioelectric phase space shows a bistability region interpretable as the cryptic planarian state.",
          "quote": "the bioelectrical phase-space of the system shows a bistability region that can be interpreted as the cryptic system state",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Positional information after injury",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric planarian model",
          "claim": "Bioelectric signals help separated cell domains know their relative position after injury.",
          "quote": "bioelectrical signals can help separated cell domains to know their relative position after injury",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric planarian model",
          "claim": "Outcomes depend on cutting plane, initial bioelectric state and intercellular connectivity.",
          "quote": "context-dependent responses are obtained depending on the cutting plane position, the initial bioelectrical state of the multicellular system, and the intercellular connectivity",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Rejuvenation by local reset",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric planarian model",
          "claim": "Polarizing agents facilitate transition from abnormal double-head to normal head-tail state.",
          "quote": "can facilitate the transition from the abnormal DH state to the normal HT state",
          "page": 28,
          "page_end": 29,
          "map_to": "Rewritable target memory"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76866",
      "year": 2020,
      "title": "Morphological Coordination: A Common Ancestral Function Unifying Neural and Non-Neural Signaling",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range morphological coordination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "neural and pre-neural cell communication across metazoa",
          "claim": "An ancestral function of neural and pre-neural signalling is long-distance coordination of division and differentiation to maintain body-axis symmetries.",
          "quote": "the long-distance coordination of cell division and differentiation required to create and maintain body-axis symmetries",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Error correction of target morphology",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular organisms; Micrasterias; ciliates",
          "claim": "Redundantly encoded target-morphology information enables error detection and correction; neurons are hypothesized to enable this in multicellular organisms.",
          "quote": "Neurons, we suggest, similarly enable error correction in multicellular organisms.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Morphogenesis as basal cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "non-neural bioelectric networks and nervous systems",
          "claim": "Non-neural bioelectric networks guiding cells toward morphospace attractors were speed-optimized into behavioural control by nervous systems.",
          "quote": "The functions of non-neural bioelectric networks in guiding cell behaviors toward a specific attractor state in the animal's morphospace were speed-optimized",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "organs and tissues",
          "claim": "Manipulating bioelectric decision-making could control system-level outcomes without micromanaging molecular events.",
          "quote": "Manipulating bioelectrically mediated decision-making may enable control of complex system-level outcomes (e.g., regeneration of whole organs, immune system regulation, etc.) without the need to directly micromanage",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76867",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Defined extracellular ionic solutions to study and manipulate the cellular resting membrane potential",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Methods paper on ionic solutions to set resting potential; no capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76868",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Endogenous Bioelectrics in Development, Cancer, and Regeneration: Drugs and Bioelectronic Devices as Electroceuticals for Regenerative Medicine",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamander, planaria regeneration",
          "claim": "Regeneration stops when the correct pattern is complete, implying cells measure large-scale structure.",
          "quote": "As remarkable as their ability to create new patterned tissue upon injury is the fact that regeneration stops when the correct pattern has been completed.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "embryos, planarian fragments",
          "claim": "Embryos with >50% cells removed still build smaller but morphologically correct bodies; planarian pieces rescale proportions.",
          "quote": "Embryos can build a smaller, but morphologically identical animal body, even when >50% of the cells are removed",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Tolerance of defective parts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "asexual planaria",
          "claim": "Planaria regenerate perfect anatomy despite a highly messy, mixoploid genome.",
          "quote": "asexually reproducing planaria execute 100% perfect anatomical regeneration despite an incredibly messy genome",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus brain (nicotine, Notch mutation)",
          "claim": "Reinforcing the brain bioelectric prepattern via HCN2 rescues gene expression, anatomy and learning despite teratogens and mutation.",
          "quote": "rescues normal gene expression, anatomy, and even learning rate (behavioral IQ) despite the exposure to strong teratogens and Notch mutation",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cancer cells in embryonic/regenerative environments",
          "claim": "Cancer cells can be reprogrammed into normal histogenesis by embryonic and regenerative environments.",
          "quote": "cancer cells can be reprogrammed by embryonic and regenerative environments into normal histogenesis",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76869",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Modeling somatic computation with non-neural bioelectric networks",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Computation in non-neural bioelectric networks",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Bio-Electric Network (BEN) model",
          "claim": "A minimal non-neural bioelectric network can be trained to implement logic gates and pattern detectors.",
          "quote": "a minimal non-neural Bio-Electric Network (BEN) model that utilizes the general principles of bioelectricity (electrodiffusion and gating) can compute",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Graceful degradation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "trained BEN AND-gate",
          "claim": "The network is robust to removal of cells through which little information flows, via distributed information.",
          "quote": "We conclude that the network is more robust to removal of nodes through which less information flows",
          "page": 33,
          "page_end": 34
        },
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "BEN models",
          "claim": "Transfer entropy/information flow is used to characterize BEN mechanism and predict robustness to node removal.",
          "quote": "we correlated the net amount of information about the inputs and outputs flowing through the rest of the nodes with the network performance upon removal of those nodes",
          "page": 33,
          "page_end": 34
        },
        {
          "name": "Logic computation in non-neural media",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric network model",
          "claim": "Small non-neural bioelectric networks are constructed that implement elementary logic gates.",
          "quote": "We demonstrate the logic-capabilities of BEN networks by constructing (1) small elementary logic gates",
          "page": 7,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76870",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "The Computational Boundary of a \"Self\": Developmental Bioelectricity Drives Multicellularity and Scale-Free Cognition",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Cognitive light cone",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "agents of any substrate",
          "claim": "An agent's cognitive capacity is characterized by the spatiotemporal boundary of events it can measure, model and affect.",
          "quote": "Any Self is demarcated by a computational surface - the spatio-temporal boundary of events that it can measure, model, and try to affect.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scale-free cognition (non-neural generalization)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cells to organisms via developmental bioelectricity",
          "claim": "Higher-level agency evolves from cell homeostatic stress reduction scaled up through bioelectric networks.",
          "quote": "I hypothesize that higher level goal-directed activity and agency, resulting in larger cognitive boundaries, evolve from the primal homeostatic drive of living things to reduce stress",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Competency ratchet",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "morphogenetic systems under evolution",
          "claim": "Morphogenetic goal-directedness smooths the fitness landscape by hiding disruptive mutations, acting as an evolutionary ratchet.",
          "quote": "Morphogenetic goal-directedness is a major evolutionary ratchet, smoothing the anatomical fitness landscape by hiding the otherwise potentially disruptive effects of random mutations.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Cryptic variation and smoother fitness landscapes",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryonic limbs (ectopic bone)",
          "claim": "Neighbouring tissues accommodate an ectopic bone to build a workable extra finger, buffering mutations.",
          "quote": "the nearby muscle cells, blood vessels, and tendons make up for this novel circumstance and build an extra, workable finger",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cancer",
          "claim": "Cancer is a reversible shrinking of the computational boundary of cells.",
          "quote": "Cancer is a (reversible) shrinking of the computational boundary of a biosystem",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Coordination range and topology constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular collectives",
          "claim": "Too little information sharing fails to bind subunits into a Self; too much yields an undifferentiated soup.",
          "quote": "Too little sharing results in a failure to bind subunits into a new Self.",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Sensor and effector remapping",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with ectopic eyes",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with eyes on their tails can see despite eyes connecting to the spinal cord.",
          "quote": "Tadpoles engineered to develop with eyes on their tails instead of in their usual spot can see quite well",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles",
          "claim": "Rearranged tadpole faces rearrange their organs into normal frog faces.",
          "quote": "like the rearranged tadpole faces whose organs then move around to make a normal frog face",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76871",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Regenerative Adaptation to Electrochemical Perturbation in Planaria: A Molecular Analysis of Physiological Plasticity",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Unseen stressor workarounds",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian Dugesia japonica exposed to BaCl2",
          "claim": "After heads degenerate in BaCl2, planaria regenerate new heads that are insensitive to the novel stressor.",
          "quote": "continued exposure to fresh solution of BaCl2 results in regeneration of heads that are insensitive to BaCl2",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Switching mechanisms after failure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BaCl2-adapted planarian heads",
          "claim": "Adaptation involves transcriptional rewiring of ion channels and transporters to compensate for excitotoxic stress.",
          "quote": "the physiological buffering of a depolarizing treatment is dependent on employing alternative means of transporting ions into and out of anterior cells and tissues",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Extinction and spontaneous recovery",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BaCl2-adapted planaria",
          "claim": "Acquired insensitivity is lost after 30 days in water, suggesting a monitoring system that detects stressor cessation.",
          "quote": "it is compatible with a dynamic monitoring system that adjusts to novel stressors but can also detect their cessation",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Blocking chloride and calcium channels induced adaptation without prior BaCl2 exposure; TRPM blockade reversed adaptation.",
          "quote": "blockage of chloride and calcium channels allowed heads to survive initial BaCl2 exposure, inducing adaptation without prior exposure, whereas blockade of TRPM channels reversed adaptation",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76872",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "L-type voltage-gated Ca 2+ channel Ca V 1.2 regulates chondrogenesis during limb development",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of cell fate",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "chick and mouse limb bud chondrocytes",
          "claim": "Membrane depolarization via CaV1.2 triggers chondrogenesis during limb development.",
          "quote": "We show a critical role for membrane depolarization in triggering chondrogenesis during limb development, mediated through the opening of a voltage-gated Ca 2+ channel, CaV1.2",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76873",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Hyperosmolar potassium inhibits myofibroblast conversion and reduces scar tissue formation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of cell fate",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "fibroblasts in vitro and mouse full-thickness skin wounds",
          "claim": "Hyperosmolar potassium gluconate depolarizes fibroblasts, inhibits myofibroblast differentiation and yields more mature, less scarred skin.",
          "quote": "KGluc treatment reduced the number of myofibroblasts present in the dermis, increased the density of blood vessels, and developed a more mature dermal-epidermal junction",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 13
        }
      ],
      "note": "Wound-healing/biomaterials study; competency content limited to ionic control of cell phenotype in repair."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76874",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Managing Ideas, People, and Projects: Organizational Tools and Strategies for Researchers",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Research-management/organizational advice; unrelated topic."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76875",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Bioelectric Control of Metastasis in Solid Tumors",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric regulation of cancer invasion",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "solid tumours (prostate, breast, skin, lung, colorectal, glioblastoma)",
          "claim": "Ion flux and Vmem control cancer cell migration machinery, and tissue electric fields can affect cells at a distance.",
          "quote": "At the cellular level, ion flux mediated by ion channels and Vmem has been shown to control cell migration cytoskeletal machinery, protease activity, and pH, and cell volume changes.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric signalling",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "tumour tissues",
          "claim": "Electric fields can alter Vmem and ion flux across many cells and affect cells elsewhere in the body.",
          "quote": "EFs can alter Vmem and ion flux propagated over multiple cells, and even affect cells in other areas of the body",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Early bioelectric detection of disease",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "breast tissue",
          "claim": "Bioelectric changes at the skin surface may precede detectable genetic or molecular changes in malignant tissue.",
          "quote": "bioelectric changes occur before any detectable genetic or molecular changes in the tissue",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective amplification of sensing",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cancer cells (in vitro)",
          "claim": "Clustered cells migrate in electric fields half the strength needed to move isolated cells.",
          "quote": "Partially confluent or ''clustered'' cells exhibited electrotaxis with an EF half the strength required to stimulate migration in isolated cells",
          "page": 9,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Field-directed migration (electrotaxis)",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cancer cells",
          "claim": "Applied electric fields of physiological strength elicit directed migration (electrotaxis).",
          "quote": "The application of an in vitro EF of strength comparable with the TEP will elicit electrotaxis in a variety of cancer cell types",
          "page": 8,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76876",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Somatic multicellularity as a satisficing solution to the prediction-error minimization problem",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical active inference",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "unicellular to multicellular organisms",
          "claim": "Biological entities at all levels seek to minimize surprise; multicellularity is framed as prediction-error minimization.",
          "quote": "From chemical networks to organisms to whole communities, biological entities at all levels of organization seek to optimize their predictive power.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Somatic shielding as Markov blanket",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "model of evolving multicellularity",
          "claim": "Simulations show multicellular bodies arise as a phase transition when somatic cells protect reproductive cells from environmental lethality.",
          "quote": "We present modeling results showing how multicellular bodies can arise if non-reproductive somatic cells protect their reproductive parents from environmental lethality.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Delayed benefit requiring short-term sacrifice",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "early multicellular organisms",
          "claim": "Somatic cells forgo reproduction (cell-cycle arrest) to ameliorate environmental threats for reproductive cells.",
          "quote": "the ability to arrest the cell cycle of daughter cells and redirect their resource utilization from division to environmental threat amelioration is the key innovation of obligate multicellular eukaryotes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cancer",
          "claim": "Cancer is an escape by somatic cells from control imposed by reproductive/stem cells.",
          "quote": "cancer is an escape by somatic cells from the control of reproductive cells",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76877",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "A flow through device for simultaneous dielectrophoretic cell trapping and AC electroporation",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Microfluidic trapping/electroporation device engineering; no capability claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76878",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Bioelectrical controls of morphogenesis: from ancient mechanisms of cell coordination to biomedical opportunities",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria (Dugesia japonica)",
          "claim": "Transient gap-junction blockade permanently changes the encoded pattern planaria regenerate to, without genomic editing.",
          "quote": "transient physiological signaling, not requiring genomic editing, can permanently change the encoded pattern to which animals regenerate upon damage",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cryptic planaria",
          "claim": "Treatment produces a bistable stochastic target morphology; each fragment decides head number independently.",
          "quote": "It also reveals these treatments can produce a unique bi-stable stochastic target morphology.",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole brain",
          "claim": "Forcing the correct bioelectric prepattern via HCN2 rescues nicotine- and Notch-induced brain and learning defects.",
          "quote": "intervention at the physiological control level could be an effective strategy to address even some genetic defects",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "adult Xenopus hindlimb",
          "claim": "A 24-hour progesterone-loaded wearable device markedly improved limb regeneration towards normal patterns.",
          "quote": "treating them with progesterone (a drug that is known to induce specific bioelectric tissue states) loaded into a small device worn at the amputation site for just 24 hours",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76880",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Automated Shapeshifting for Function Recovery in Damaged Robots",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Recovery through morphological change",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated soft quadruped robot (voxel-based)",
          "claim": "A damaged robot recovers locomotion by evolving deformations of its resting shape while keeping its original controller.",
          "quote": "the damaged machine evolves shape changes that not only recover the original level of function (locomotion) as before, but can in fact surpass the original level of performance (speed)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated soft robot",
          "claim": "One evolved solution amounted to spontaneous 'regeneration' of the lost legs.",
          "quote": "One of the evolved solutions (shown here) yields the spontaneous",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Switching mechanisms after failure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "damaged robots",
          "claim": "Shape change rather than control readaptation may be the better recovery strategy after some damage.",
          "quote": "shape change, instead of control readaptation, may be a better method to recover function after damage in some cases",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76882",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "On the Generalization of Habituation: How Discrete Biological Systems Respond to Repetitive Stimuli: A Novel Model of Habituation That Is Independent of Any Biological System",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Habituation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "substrate-independent abstract model (molecular, cellular, organismal)",
          "claim": "Habituation is abstracted into five generalizable elements so any system with them can habituate.",
          "quote": "an abstraction of the habituation process that does not rely upon particular biological pathways or substrates is presented",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Sensitization",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "abstract habituation model",
          "claim": "Both habituation and sensitization emerge from the model, suggesting they are facets of one phenomenon.",
          "quote": "both habituation and sensitization processes emerge (Figure 2A,B), suggesting that they are different facets of the same phenomenon",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Savings during relearning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "abstract habituation model",
          "claim": "Repeated habituation-recovery series are modelled to become successively faster, with scenarios for where memory is stored.",
          "quote": "If repeated series of habituation training and spontaneous recovery are given, habituation becomes successively more rapid/pronounced.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Frequency-selective response",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "abstract habituation model",
          "claim": "The model reproduces effects of stimulus frequency and magnitude on habituation profiles.",
          "quote": "The formulation can be applied to interrogate systems as they respond to several stimulation paradigms, providing new insights and supporting existing behavioral data.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76883",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Live imaging of intracellular pH in planarians using the ratiometric fluorescent dye SNARF-5F-AM",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Imaging protocol for planarian intracellular pH; methods only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76884",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Synchronization of Bioelectric Oscillations in Networks of Nonexcitable Cells: From Single-Cell to Multicellular States",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Synchronization and entrainment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "model multicellular ensembles of non-excitable cells",
          "claim": "Coherent bioelectric oscillations emerge in heterogeneous non-neural ensembles without centralized coordination.",
          "quote": "the model predicts that coherent oscillations can emerge in a heterogeneous ensemble of non-neural cells without any centralized coordination",
          "page": 25,
          "page_end": 26
        },
        {
          "name": "Top-down control via ensemble bioelectric state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multicellular bioelectric networks",
          "claim": "Ensemble-averaged electric potential could allow top-down control of multicellular networks complementary to cell-level manipulation.",
          "quote": "multicellular ensemble-averaged properties such as the electric potential can be used to gain network control",
          "page": 25,
          "page_end": 26
        },
        {
          "name": "Sustained response memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric networks",
          "claim": "A memory based on bioelectric patterns is suggested to permit top-down control complementary to biochemical bottom-up approaches.",
          "quote": "We have suggested that a memory based on bioelectric patterns could permit a top-down control complementary to the dominant bottom-up approach",
          "page": 25,
          "page_end": 26
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76885",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "The Cognitive Lens: a primer on conceptual tools for analysing information processing in developmental and regenerative morphogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "gene regulatory network model and equivalent ANN",
          "claim": "A simple GRN displays associative learning, and an ANN with the same function shows the same dynamics, suggesting substrate independence.",
          "quote": "we present a simple GRN that displays associative learning (figure 5), then explicate the learning mechanism from a dynamical systems perspective",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Learning as increased information association",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "GRN associative learning model",
          "claim": "Learning can be quantified as an increase in information-level association between components.",
          "quote": "learning can be quantified by an increase in the information-level association between the components involved",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Morphogenesis as basal cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "developmental and regenerative patterning",
          "claim": "Tools from cognitive science (dynamical systems, information theory, least action) can treat patterning as primitive cognition and enable top-down control.",
          "quote": "We propose that these tools can be extended beyond neural settings to predict and control systems-level outcomes, and to understand biological patterning as a form of primitive cognition.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerating tissues",
          "claim": "Offloading complexity onto cells via training and modifying tissue self-models rather than micromanaging.",
          "quote": "Offloading the complexity onto the cells themselves (not micromanaging), using training and other ways to modify tissue self-models and goal-seeking behaviours",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76886",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Neural control of body-plan axis in regenerating planaria",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "computational model of regenerating planaria",
          "claim": "Vector transport of morphogens yields virtually scale-free self-assembly of gradients across fragment sizes.",
          "quote": "Vector transport of morphogens was identified as a fundamental requirement to account for virtually scale-free self-assembly of the morphogen gradients observed in planarian homeostasis and regeneration.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Nervous-system control of tissue polarity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "regenerating planaria",
          "claim": "The head-tail axis is controlled by the net polarity of neurons in a regenerating fragment.",
          "quote": "demonstrate that the headtail axis is controlled by the net polarity of neurons in a regenerating fragment",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian model and experiments",
          "claim": "The model predicts body-plan outcomes (including heteromorphoses) after manipulations and novel cuts, confirmed experimentally.",
          "quote": "The model correctly describes altered body-plans following many known experimental manipulations, and accurately predicts outcomes of novel cutting scenarios, which we tested.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76887",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "A call for a better understanding of causation in cell biology",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamander limb regeneration",
          "claim": "Salamanders regenerate entire limbs and stop precisely when the correct structure is complete.",
          "quote": "Salamanders regenerate entire limbs and, crucially, they stop precisely when a correct limb structure is complete.",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with abnormal faces still become normal frogs, reaching the target morphology despite drastic interventions.",
          "quote": "Tadpoles with highly abnormal faces nevertheless can become normal frogs",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "deer antlers; planaria",
          "claim": "The setpoint of anatomical homeostasis can be rewritten, e.g. trophic memory in antlers and permanent 2-headed planarian lines.",
          "quote": "Remarkably, the setpoint of this anatomical homeostasis can be re-written, e.g. as trophic memory.",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Physical constraints as organizers of cell fate",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "mammalian cells in microgravity",
          "claim": "Without the gravity constraint cells keep transitioning between phenotypes; constraints force a specific differentiated state.",
          "quote": "in the absence of physical constraints the environment cannot select between two different phenotypes due to the emergence of a 'permanent transition state'",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ],
      "note": "Opinion piece on causation in cell biology."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76888",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Membrane Potential Depolarization Alters Calcium Flux and Phosphate Signaling During Osteogenic Differentiation of Human Mesenchymal Stem Cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of cell fate",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human mesenchymal stem cells",
          "claim": "Vmem depolarization alters osteogenic differentiation via a phosphate/STC1 pathway.",
          "quote": "Depolarization alters hMSC differentiation through a phosphate signaling pathway involving STC1.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Mechanistic stem-cell differentiation study."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76890",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor Use During Pregnancy and Major Malformations: The Importance of Serotonin for Embryonic Development and the Effect of Serotonin Inhibition on the Occurrence of Malformations",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "human and animal embryos",
          "claim": "Serotonergic, bioelectric and calcium signalling pathways that pattern embryonic organs are perturbed by SSRIs, causing malformations.",
          "quote": "three major pathways known to be crucial for patterning of many embryonic organ systems, serotonergic signaling, bioelectric signaling, and calcium signaling all can be perturbed by SSRIs",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ],
      "note": "Clinical/teratology review of SSRI use in pregnancy; competency content limited to bioelectric/serotonergic control of embryonic patterning."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76891",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "Effects of Ivermectin Exposure on Regeneration of D. dorotocephala Planaria: Exploiting Human-Approved Ion Channel Drugs as Morphoceuticals",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian Dugesia dorotocephala",
          "claim": "Ivermectin (chloride channel opener) during regeneration caused patterning abnormalities such as bifurcated tails with partial heads.",
          "quote": "Exposure to IVM during regeneration resulted in patterning abnormalities, such as bifurcated tails with partial heads, as well as delayed regeneration.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76892",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Planarian regeneration as a model of anatomical homeostasis: Recent progress in biophysical and computational approaches",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Transient physiological alterations permanently rewrite the anatomical setpoint planaria regenerate to, without genomic editing.",
          "quote": "The planarian model system offers experimentally-tractable examples of rewriting the anatomical setpoint for regeneration without genomic editing",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Alternative stable morphologies",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Genetically normal planaria can permanently store and regenerate to one of several target morphologies.",
          "quote": "Planaria with a normal histological configuration and genome can permanently store (and regenerate to) one of several target morphologies",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "bisected planaria",
          "claim": "Adjacent wound cells with identical positional information make a head or a tail depending on the cut, posing a decision-making puzzle.",
          "quote": "One wound site will make a head while the other will make a tail; the cells in those two wound sites were adjacent neighbors",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria",
          "claim": "Planaria regenerate complete anatomy from fragments while being remodelled, a 'computational medium' fulfilling a design spec.",
          "quote": "a material that actively fulfills a complex design spec while itself being drastically remodeled",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76893",
      "year": 2019,
      "title": "The Role of Early Bioelectric Signals in the Regeneration of Planarian Anterior/Posterior Polarity",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric instructive control of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "regenerating planaria",
          "claim": "Brief depolarization in the first 3 h after injury alters notum expression and yields double-headed regenerates.",
          "quote": "Briefly manipulating the endogenous bioelectric state by depolarizing the injured tissue during the first 3 h of regeneration alters gene expression by 6 h postamputation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "regenerating planaria",
          "claim": "Bioelectric state shifts in a polarized manner immediately after injury, breaking axial symmetry before known gene expression.",
          "quote": "upon injury, the bioelectric state shifts in a polarized manner, establishing an anterior-posterior axis at an extremely early time point",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "regenerating planaria",
          "claim": "Vmem regulates AP polarity while beta-catenin also controls tissue scaling; Vmem-induced double heads are properly scaled.",
          "quote": "although Vmem regulates AP polarity, b-catenin is likely to serve not only AP polarity but also tissue scaling during regeneration",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76894",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "EDEn–Electroceutical Design Environment: Ion Channel Tissue Expression Database with Small Molecule Modulators",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Database of ion-channel expression and modulators; tool/database."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76898",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "The Bacterial Metabolite Indole Inhibits Regeneration of the Planarian Flatworm Dugesia japonica",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian (Dugesia japonica)",
          "claim": "Planarian head/eye regeneration is modulated (delayed) by microbiome bacteria and their metabolite indole, showing regeneration outcomes depend on host-associated microbes.",
          "quote": "Individual members of the D. japonica microbiome can delay regeneration including the development of eye spots and blastema formation.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Microbiome resistance to invasion",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian microbiome",
          "claim": "The established planarian microbiome is stable and resists colonization by transient exogenous bacteria.",
          "quote": "The composition of an established planarian microbiome shows a degree of stability and resistance, as transient exogenous bacteria are unable to colonize and persist after introduction.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76899",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Brief Local Application of Progesterone via a Wearable Bioreactor Induces Long-Term Regenerative Response in Adult Xenopus Hindlimb",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "adult Xenopus hindlimb",
          "claim": "A 24-hour local progesterone pulse via a wearable bioreactor triggers a long-lasting regenerative response producing paddle-like regenerates instead of spikes.",
          "quote": "delivered progesterone to the wound site immediately after hindlimb amputation for only 24 hr induced the regeneration of paddle-like structures in adult frogs",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Latent regenerative capacity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "adult Xenopus hindlimb",
          "claim": "Regenerative ability is an intrinsic but dormant property of adult limb cells that can be reactivated by appropriate master regulators.",
          "quote": "the regenerative ability is an intrinsic property of limb cells in adult non-regenerative animals (Sessions and Bryant, 1988), susceptible to reactivation by appropriate master regulators",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Functional use of novel regenerated structures",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "adult Xenopus hindlimb",
          "claim": "Frogs with patterned regenerates use them differently in locomotion than untreated frogs use cartilaginous spikes.",
          "quote": "animals regenerating complex patterned structures use them differently than untreated animals use their cartilaginous spikes",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76900",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Perspective: The promise of multi-cellular engineered living systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-repair and adaptation of engineered living systems",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "multi-cellular engineered living systems (organoids, biobots)",
          "claim": "Multi-cellular engineered living systems possess emergent capabilities such as self-assembly, growth, self-repair, adaptation and learning that engineering should exploit.",
          "quote": "fail to take advantage of their extraordinary capabilities-self-assembly, growth, self-repair, adaptation, learning, etc.",
          "page": 17,
          "page_end": 17
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76901",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Ivermectin Promotes Peripheral Nerve Regeneration during Wound Healing",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Drug-induced cell phenotype conversion",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human dermal fibroblasts / mouse wound model",
          "claim": "Ivermectin induces fibroblasts to adopt a glia-like phenotype that supports neural stem cell proliferation and nerve regeneration in wounds.",
          "quote": "we demonstrate that ivermectin promotes peripheral nerve regeneration by inducing fibroblasts to adopt a glia-like phenotype",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Non-neural tissue instructing nerve growth",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole ectopic eye grafts",
          "claim": "Ivermectin treatment of non-neuronal stromal tissue induces hyperinnervation from adjacent engrafted eye tissue.",
          "quote": "ivermectin treatment of non-neuronal stromal tissue can be exploited to induce the expansion of neurons from the adjacent engrafted neuronal tissue",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76902",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Activating PAX gene family paralogs to complement PAX5 leukemia driver mutations",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Paralog compensation for lost gene function",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human pre-B ALL leukemia cells",
          "claim": "Forced or osmotically induced expression of PAX2/PAX8 paralogs complements PAX5 loss-of-function, restoring differentiation and reducing proliferation.",
          "quote": "forced expression of PAX2 or PAX8 complements PAX5 loss-of-function mutation in ALL cells",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Cancer normalization by restoring differentiation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human pre-B ALL leukemia cells",
          "claim": "Restoring PAX activity reverses the developmental block of leukemic cells, normalizing differentiation and growth.",
          "quote": "can function equivalently to normalize",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 17
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76904",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Pattern Regeneration in Coupled Networks",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "CANN(k) model (neural network coupled to 1D k-color cellular automaton)",
          "claim": "An ANN that dynamically chooses CA update rules makes a target pattern a fixed-point attractor that is recovered after perturbation.",
          "quote": "The CANN(k) models are constructed to generate target patterns which are stable under perturbations of the pattern.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Neural control of morphogenesis",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "CANN(k) model",
          "claim": "A global information-processing network that generates state-dependent local rules is proposed as a model of neural control of cellular patterning.",
          "quote": "This provides a novel model for understanding the important biological phenomenon of neural control of cellular morphogenesis in development or regeneration.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76905",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Modeling Cell Migration in a Simulated Bioelectrical Signaling Network for Anatomical Regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated planarian cell-cell communication model",
          "claim": "A gap-junction-like message-passing model regenerates the full worm shape after half the body is removed, even with only 10% neoblasts.",
          "quote": "We verified that the model was capable of fully regenerating the planarian-like morphology even with a ratio of 10% of neoblasts.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "simulated planarian cell-cell communication model",
          "claim": "Dividing cells must migrate to injury sites and stop proliferating once the needed structures are complete.",
          "quote": "these cells must stop proliferating when the needed structures are completed",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stem cell recruitment to injury by signalling",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated planarian cell-cell communication model",
          "claim": "Somatic cells detecting injury emit migration messages that guide neoblasts to where new tissue is needed.",
          "quote": "When somatic cells detect an injury, they create migration messages that travel through the organism until they reach a neoblast.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76906",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "From Physics to Pattern: Uncovering Pattern Formation in Tissue Electrophysiology",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric tissue simulation (BETSE) with genetic algorithm search",
          "claim": "Voltage-gated NaP channel feedback produces cell-autonomous Vmem bistability that serves as a pattern memory.",
          "quote": "leads to \"negative resistance\" and cellautonomous Vmem bistability",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Spontaneous bioelectric pattern formation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectric tissue simulation (BETSE)",
          "claim": "Turing-like spot and stripe patterns can arise purely bioelectrically, without differential gene expression.",
          "quote": "Turing-like patterns can arise purely bioelectrically, without requiring any variation in gene expression",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76907",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Inform: Efficient Information-Theoretic Analysis of Collective Behaviors",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "Inform library applied to planaria, ants and multi-agent simulations",
          "claim": "Information-theoretic measures (transfer entropy, active information storage, partial information decomposition) are provided to quantify information flow in collective behaviours.",
          "quote": "information dynamics measures such as active information storage and transfer entropy, and information-based concepts conceived to investigate the causal architecture of collective systems",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "multi-agent best-of-n simulation; Temnothorax ants",
          "claim": "Agent collectives choose the better of two options via local majority or voter rules; information flow during this decision is analysed.",
          "quote": "a collective of agents needs to chose between two options: 0 or",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Bioelectric perturbation produces two-headed planaria whose altered morphology persists through subsequent regenerations, indicating stored, rewritable patterning information.",
          "quote": "The resulting two-headed morphology is persistent under subsequent regeneration events outside of the presence of ivermectin.",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76910",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Bioelectrical control of positional information in development and regeneration: A review of conceptual and computational advances",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "regulative development and regeneration (bioelectric networks)",
          "claim": "Bioelectric-chemical interplay amplifies single-cell processes into large-scale pattern homeostasis during regulative development and regeneration.",
          "quote": "such biophysical systems are an ideal way to amplify individual cell processes, such as symmetry breaking, toward the remarkable large-scale pattern homeostasis",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 16
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-organized morphogen gradients via gap junctions",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled cell network models",
          "claim": "Electrodiffusive transport of charged morphogens through gap junctions can self-assemble morphogen gradients and positional information patterns.",
          "quote": "intercellular coupling facilitated by gap junction channels may induce directed, electrodiffusive transport of charged molecules between cells of the network to generate new positional information patterning possibilities",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76911",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "The body electric 2.0: recent advances in developmental bioelectricity for regenerative and synthetic bioengineering",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cellular collectives (bioelectric networks)",
          "claim": "Non-neural bioelectric signalling lets cell collectives make global decisions and implement large-scale pattern homeostasis.",
          "quote": "enables cellular collectives to make global decisions and implement large-scale pattern homeostasis",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "A transient shift of the bioelectric circuit permanently rewrites the regenerative target to double-headed without genomic change.",
          "quote": "pattern memories encoded in somatic bioelectric circuits can be re-written away from default target morphologies without editing the genomic sequence",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Latent or counterfactual memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "An anatomically normal one-headed body can store a latent two-headed bioelectric memory that is expressed only upon future injury.",
          "quote": "The same body can apparently store (at least) two different bioelectric 'memories' which are latent but will guide regenerative patterning if the animal is cut at some future time.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Overriding genetic defaults via bioelectric state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus brain, KRAS tumours, planarian head shape",
          "claim": "Enforcing bioelectric prepatterns can override genome-default outcomes such as mutant Notch brain defects or oncogene-induced tumours.",
          "quote": "The ability to override genome-default states",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Consolidation after cue release",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cancer cells (hERG1 activator); planarian",
          "claim": "Transient Vmem changes are consolidated into long-term biochemical states that persist after the stimulus is removed.",
          "quote": "an example of the consolidation of short-term memory (transient Vmem state) into long-term biochemical (phosphorylation, gene expression) states",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Active inference in cellular collectives",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric tissue networks",
          "claim": "Tissues may represent internal models of themselves and their environment, and neuroscience concepts like active inference may apply to bioelectric cell interactions.",
          "quote": "emerging concepts in neuroscience such as active inference [98] might be well-applied to cellular interactions via bioelectric states",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76914",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "HCN2 Rescues brain defects by enforcing endogenous voltage pre-patterns",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rescue of birth defects by enforcing bioelectric prepattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo brain (nicotine exposure), BETSE model",
          "claim": "Model-predicted HCN2 expression restores the endogenous Vmem prepattern and rescues nicotine-induced brain defects and learning.",
          "quote": "exogenous expression of the HCN2 ion channel rescues nicotine-exposed embryos, resulting in normal brain morphology and molecular marker expression, with near-normal learning capacity",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-sensitive amplification of pattern",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BETSE model of Xenopus neural tube",
          "claim": "HCN2 channels act context-specifically to amplify differential Vmem across the neural plate, correcting defects appropriately by location.",
          "quote": "they can indeed overcome the effects of nicotine on Vmem and do so appropriately depending on location in the neural tube center and its lateral areas",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76916",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "The bioelectric code: An ancient computational medium for dynamic control of growth and form",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerating and developing organisms (bioelectric code)",
          "claim": "Achieving the correct target morphology from diverse initial conditions shows the morphogenetic code implements pattern-homeostatic processes.",
          "quote": "The ability to obtain the correct target morphology from a diversity of initial conditions reveals that the morphogenetic code implements a rich system of pattern-homeostatic processes.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian, axolotl and other regenerating animals",
          "claim": "Regenerative remodeling and growth stop once the correct target morphology is achieved.",
          "quote": "correct target morphology is achieved, large-scale remodeling and growth ceases",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus (ectopic eyes, tail), planarian blastema",
          "claim": "Simple bioelectric triggers act like subroutine calls that induce complex, self-limiting organ formation such as whole eyes in the gut.",
          "quote": "this type of \"subroutine call\" effect, where a simple master trigger causes a complex, self-limiting morphogenetic response",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Overriding genetic defaults via bioelectric state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus, planarian",
          "claim": "The bioelectric code provides a layer of control that can override genome-default anatomical outcomes.",
          "quote": "the bioelectric code should allow a rich layer of control that can override genome-default outcomes",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric circuits in tissues",
          "claim": "Long-term anatomy can be changed by transiently rewriting bioelectric states, and future work should rewrite the encoded goal state rather than micromanage cells.",
          "quote": "Manipulation of long-term, large-scale anatomical structure can now be achieved by transiently re-writing the bioelectric states of living tissue.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical goals and subgoals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "morphogenetic control (bioelectric code)",
          "claim": "Pattern regulation combines emergent local filling-in with top-down controls deciding large-scale patterning.",
          "quote": "biological pattern regulation is a combination of emergent features that fill in local features and top-down controls that make decisions about large-scale patterning",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76917",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Niclosamide rescues microcephaly in a humanized in vivo model of Zika infection using human induced neural stem cells",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Zika microcephaly model and niclosamide rescue; disease model/pharmacology, not a capability of the system."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76918",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Booting up the organism during development: Pre-behavioral functions of the vertebrate brain in guiding body morphogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range instructive control by the brain",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "The nascent brain, before behaviour, is required for correct patterning of distant muscle and nerve networks.",
          "quote": "While the nascent brain is being constructed, it is required for normal patterning of the muscle and peripheral nerve networks, including those far away from the head.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Buffering against teratogens",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "The presence of the early brain renders exposure to certain teratogenic chemicals harmless.",
          "quote": "its presence is also able to render harmless exposure to specific chemicals that normally act as teratogens",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "brainless Xenopus embryos",
          "claim": "Brain loss effects can be partially compensated by a limited set of neurotransmitter and ion channel interventions such as HCN2 misexpression.",
          "quote": "These activities of the early brain can be partially compensated for in a brainless embryo by experimental modulation of neurotransmitter and ion channel signaling.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76919",
      "year": 2018,
      "title": "Slime mould: The fundamental mechanisms of biological cognition",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Decentralized decision-making",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Physarum perceives in parallel, processes information concurrently and decides in a decentralised way, representing results in its tube network.",
          "quote": "the slime mould perceives its world in parallel, process the information perceived concurrently, makes decisions in a decentralised manner",
          "page": 33,
          "page_end": 34
        },
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "slime mould regulatory subsystems",
          "claim": "Regulation, the internal compensation of disturbances, is proposed as the basis from which minimal cognition emerges.",
          "quote": "It is understood as regulation as the capacity of living beings of internally compensates disturbances",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Chemotaxis as minimal cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "myxomycetes",
          "claim": "Chemotaxis in slime moulds exemplifies how fundamental cognitive capacities arise in minimal living systems through regulation.",
          "quote": "chemotaxis of myxomycetes represents a clear comparative example of how certain fundamental capabilities for the origin of cognition may arise in the minimum living systems",
          "page": 33,
          "page_end": 34
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76922",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Ion Channel and Neurotransmitter Modulators as Electroceutical Approaches to the Control of Cancer",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cancer (tissue-level bioelectric networks)",
          "claim": "Cancer is framed as cells failing to interact with the morphodynamic field of instructive signals that keeps proliferation orchestrated toward host needs.",
          "quote": "a network disorder affecting the ability of cells to properly interact with a morphodynamic field of instructive signals",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Cancer normalization by restoring differentiation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "embryos and regenerating limbs; tumours",
          "claim": "Appropriate patterning environments can normalize aggressive transformed cells, suggesting cancer can be reprogrammed rather than killed.",
          "quote": "appropriate patterning environments, such as embryos and regenerating limbs [15, 104], can normalize aggressive transformed cells",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "somatic cell networks",
          "claim": "Ionic coupling of cells into networks allows them to implement tissue-level patterning decisions.",
          "quote": "the ionic coupling of cells into networks via electrochemical synapses allows them to implement tissue-level patterning decisions",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76923",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "The brain is required for normal muscle and nerve patterning during early Xenopus development",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range instructive control by the brain",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo (brain removal assay)",
          "claim": "Removal of the early brain causes muscle and peripheral nerve mispatterning far from the head, revealing long-range brain cues for morphogenesis.",
          "quote": "The observed defects occur at considerable distances from the head, suggesting that the brain provides long-range cues for other tissue systems during development.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Buffering against teratogens",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "The presence of the brain protects embryos from otherwise teratogenic agents.",
          "quote": "The presence of brain also protects embryos from otherwise-teratogenic agents.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "brainless Xenopus embryos",
          "claim": "HCN2 expression in CNS-fated cells, even far from mispatterned tissues, mimics brain signals and rescues muscle and nerve patterning.",
          "quote": "rescues the muscle phenotype and the neural mispatterning that occur in brainless embryos, even when expressed far from the muscle or neural cells that mispattern",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76924",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Coordinating heart morphogenesis: A novel role for hyperpolarization-activated cyclic nucleotide-gated (HCN) channels during cardiogenesis in Xenopus laevis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric coordination of organ positioning",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus heart development",
          "claim": "HCN4 channel function coordinates positional information genes for heart morphogenesis; disruption yields malformed, mispositioned hearts without blocking differentiation.",
          "quote": "Our results suggest that HCN4 serves to coordinate morphogenetic control factors that provide positional information during heart morphogenesis in Xenopus.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76925",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Bioelectric gene and reaction networks: computational modelling of genetic, biochemical and bioelectrical dynamics in pattern regulation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Setpoint maintenance without learning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "bioelectricity-integrated gene and reaction (BIGR) network model",
          "claim": "Feedback between Vmem and K+ channel state yields a homeostat that holds Vmem at a set value and resists perturbation.",
          "quote": "A homeostat describes a device that maintains a parameter at a singular value and is capable of resisting change from perturbations.",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BIGR network model",
          "claim": "BIGR networks show Vmem memory and state switching, and hysteretic networks spontaneously generate stable Vmem spots and stripes.",
          "quote": "BIGR networks demonstrating hysteresis are identified as a mechanisms through which more complex patterns of stable Vmem spots and stripes, along with correlated concentration patterns, can spontaneously emerge.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BIGR spatial model of planarian-like regeneration",
          "claim": "A gap-junction-coupled BIGR model regenerates instructive Vmem gradients scale-free so each fragment produces what is missing with correct polarity.",
          "quote": "when cut, each piece produces exactly what is missing at each wound edge. It rescales and maintains its normal anterior-posterior polarity.",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BIGR network model",
          "claim": "Stable positional information patterns can be edited solely by altering bioelectric signals without directly changing gene expression.",
          "quote": "stable patterns of positional information (and subsequent patterning outcomes) can be edited solely by altering bioelectric signals without changing gene expression directly",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76926",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Bioelectric signaling in regeneration: Mechanisms of ionic controls of growth and form",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "regenerating animals (bioelectric signalling)",
          "claim": "Bioelectric cues not only guide initial development but enable robust restoration of normal pattern after injury.",
          "quote": "they also enable the robust restoration of normal pattern after injury",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus, planarian, zebrafish",
          "claim": "Vmem gradients act as triggers that initiate complex, self-limiting organogenesis and set axial polarity and organ size.",
          "quote": "initiating modules for complex self-limiting organogenesis",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerating tissues",
          "claim": "Understanding how growth is limited once correct anatomy is restored is a key open question for bioelectric circuits.",
          "quote": "how growth is limited once appropriate anatomy has been restored",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76927",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "HCN4 ion channel function is required for early events that regulate anatomical left-right patterning in a Nodal- and Lefty asymmetric gene expression-independent manner",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Redundant parallel pathways for robust laterality",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenopus left-right patterning",
          "claim": "Laterality is ensured by redundant, robust mechanisms; HCN4 acts early via a pathway that bypasses the canonical Nodal-Lefty-Pitx2 cascade.",
          "quote": "the mechanisms of establishing and executing laterality are redundant and highly robust to ensure correct organ situs even in presence of certain errors in the pathway",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76928",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Cancer as a disorder of patterning information: computational and biophysical perspectives on the cancer problem",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cancer in multicellular tissues",
          "claim": "Cancer arises when cells shrink the boundary of their computational self to the single-cell level and stop maintaining higher-order structures.",
          "quote": "Cancer may result when cells stop maintaining higher-order structures and reduce the boundary of their computational selves to a single-cell level",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Information integration as a mechanism measure",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "cancer and tissues (information-theoretic tools)",
          "claim": "Integrated information and other information metrics are proposed to determine the organizational level at which cancer decisions are made.",
          "quote": "determining (perhaps using integrated information metrics) the organizational level at which decisions in cancer are made",
          "page": 20,
          "page_end": 20
        },
        {
          "name": "Quantifying agency via integrated spatiotemporal patterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "tissues and tumours",
          "claim": "Integrated spatiotemporal patterns (ISTP) provide a quantitative notion of agency (individuality, perception, action) applicable to tissues and cancer.",
          "quote": "ISTP attempts to provide a quantitative notion of agency",
          "page": 17,
          "page_end": 17
        },
        {
          "name": "Active information storage as memory measure",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "cells and tissues (information dynamics)",
          "claim": "Local active information storage quantifies how much an agent's past reduces uncertainty about its future, as a measure of stored information.",
          "quote": "Local active information storage (LAIS) quantifies the degree to which uncertainty about the future of an agent X is reduced by knowledge of its own past states",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76929",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Repeated removal of developing limb buds permanently reduces appendage size in the highly-regenerative axolotl",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "axolotl limb",
          "claim": "Repeated limb-bud removal permanently miniaturizes limbs, an altered target morphology preserved through later amputation and regeneration.",
          "quote": "This altered target morphology was preserved upon amputation and regeneration.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "axolotl limb",
          "claim": "Within a species, larger animals regenerate larger limbs, matching appendage size to body size.",
          "quote": "When challenged, larger animals are programmed to regenerate larger limbs than smaller animals within a single species.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Persistence under repeated disturbance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "axolotl limb bud",
          "claim": "Axolotls fully compensate for a single bud removal and mostly regrow normal limbs after several removals, before eventually failing or miniaturizing.",
          "quote": "axolotls can completely compensate for the loss of that first instance of limb bud",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76931",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Investigating the effects of noise on a cell-to-cell communication mechanism for structure regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Noise and asynchronous update tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated planarian cell-cell communication model",
          "claim": "Adding an activation threshold (cells must receive several messages before dividing) exploits message redundancy to keep regeneration accurate under noisy message routing.",
          "quote": "due to the inherent message redundancy in the organism this mechanism improved the performance of the model even when noise is present on packets",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Cue integration and conflicting evidence",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "simulated planarian cell-cell communication model",
          "claim": "Cells confirming evidence from multiple sources within a time window before regenerating is predicted as an evolved strategy in regenerating organisms.",
          "quote": "a method for confirming evidence from different sources within a given time span before regenerating cells like the activation mechanism we proposed might have evolved",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated planarian cell-cell communication model",
          "claim": "Shape information distributed with partial redundancy across the cell network allows missing cells to be regrown.",
          "quote": "The reliability of our model is based on shape information existing across the network of cells.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76932",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "The Zahn drawings: new illustrations of Xenopus embryo and tadpole stages for studies of craniofacial development",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Illustration resource of Xenopus stages; no claims."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76934",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Bioelectric regulation of innate immune system function in regenerating and intact Xenopus laevis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric modulation of immune defence",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos infected with E. coli",
          "claim": "Depolarizing Vmem increases embryo resistance to infection via serotonergic melanocyte signalling and more myeloid cells, while hyperpolarization increases susceptibility.",
          "quote": "General depolarization of the organism's Vmem by pharmacological or molecular genetic (ion channel misexpression) methods increased resistance to infection",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Injury-triggered systemic resistance",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos",
          "claim": "Tail amputation and regeneration potentiate systemic resistance to infection by increasing peripheral myeloid cells.",
          "quote": "amputation of the tail bud potentiates systemic resistance to infection by increasing the number of peripheral myeloid cells",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76935",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Long-Term, Stochastic Editing of Regenerative Anatomy via Targeting Endogenous Bioelectric Gradients",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian (Dugesia japonica)",
          "claim": "Brief gap-junction blockade permanently rewrites the regenerative anterior-posterior pattern, stored in resting potential gradients, and can be reset by reversing bioelectric state.",
          "quote": "regenerating planarians' normal anterior-posterior pattern can be permanently rewritten by a brief perturbation of endogenous bioelectrical networks",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Latent or counterfactual memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Morphologically normal 'cryptic' worms carry a hidden altered pattern memory revealed only upon later amputation.",
          "quote": "revealing a cryptic phenotype that is not apparent unless the animals are cut",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Alternative stable morphologies",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "The bioelectric gradient acts as a multistable epigenetic anatomical switch among wild-type, cryptic and double-headed states.",
          "quote": "represents a multistable, epigenetic anatomical switch: experimental reversals of bioelectric state reset subsequent regenerative morphology back to wild-type",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Overriding genetic defaults via bioelectric state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Bioelectric properties can stably override the genome-default target morphology.",
          "quote": "bioelectric properties can stably override genome-default target morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76936",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Space travel has effects on planarian regeneration that cannot be explained by a null hypothesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian after space travel",
          "claim": "Reply defending the observation that a space-exposed planarian regenerated as a double-headed form, alongside persistent behavioural and microbiome differences.",
          "quote": "one of the animals came back as a biaxial heteromorphosis (having heads on both ends of the main body axis)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Response letter defending an earlier space-flight planarian study."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76937",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Planarian regeneration in space: Persistent anatomical, behavioral, and bacteriological changes induced by space travel",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian (Dugesia japonica) after ISS flight",
          "claim": "A space-exposed fragment regenerated double-headed and, when re-amputated in plain water, again regenerated double-headed.",
          "quote": "amputating this double-headed worm again, in plain water, resulted again in the double-headed phenotype",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-term persistence of environmentally induced change",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Space travel induced behavioural and microbiome differences that persisted 20 months after return to Earth.",
          "quote": "even when tested 20 months after return to Earth, the space-exposed worms displayed significant quantitative differences in behavior and microbiome composition",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76938",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Gap junctional signaling in pattern regulation: Physiological network connectivity instructs growth and form",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Coordination range and topology constraints",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled tissues (zebrafish fin, planaria, Xenopus)",
          "claim": "By dynamically regulating bioelectric network topology, gap junctions enable tissues to implement complex morphogenesis and neural-like global dynamics.",
          "quote": "By dynamically regulating the topology of bioelectric networks in vivo, GJs underlie the ability of many tissues to implement complex morphogenesis.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigation in morphospace",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian (Girardia dorotocephala)",
          "claim": "Physiological perturbation of gap-junction connectivity alone shifts regenerating planaria among regions of morphospace including other species' head shapes.",
          "quote": "shifting among different regions of planarian morphospace (Stone, 1997) is possible by physiological perturbation alone",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled somatic tissues",
          "claim": "Target morphology may be stored as a stably re-writable memory in real-time bioelectric current dynamics, as in permanently two-headed planaria.",
          "quote": "patterning information that can be stably re-written (e.g., permanently 2-headed planaria)",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 20
        },
        {
          "name": "Training tissues by reinforcement",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled non-neural tissues",
          "claim": "If GJ-coupled tissues are information-processing agents, morphogenesis might be trained with positive and negative reinforcement toward desired outcomes.",
          "quote": "providing positive and negative reinforcement for collections of cells undergoing morphogenesis to encourage specific types of growth patterns",
          "page": 19,
          "page_end": 20
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76939",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Endogenous Bioelectric Signaling Networks: Exploiting Voltage Gradients for Control of Growth and Form",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Transient gap-junction inhibition yields two-headed worms that keep regenerating two heads across repeated amputations and fission, despite normal genome.",
          "quote": "a transient perturbation of physiological cell-to-cell communication stably changes the pattern to which the animal regenerates upon damage, despite a normal genomic sequence",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Distributed storage of body-plan information",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Because any gut fragment 'knows' to build two heads, anatomical information must be stored in distributed form throughout the body.",
          "quote": "the information about basic anatomical polarity and body organization must be stored in a distributed form throughout the animal",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        },
        {
          "name": "Somatic memory and decision-making",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "non-neural bioelectric tissues",
          "claim": "Somatic tissues communicating electrically may implement memory, decision-making and other functions traditionally reserved for neural systems.",
          "quote": "may reveal memory, decision making, and other functions formerly reserved for neural systems implemented in somatic tissues",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 19
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-repair and adaptation of engineered living systems",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "living systems generally",
          "claim": "Living systems self-assemble, regenerate and remodel complex shapes, abilities bioengineering seeks to harness.",
          "quote": "Living systems exhibit remarkable abilities to self-assemble, regenerate, and remodel complex shapes.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective amplification of sensing",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cell collectives",
          "claim": "Cells in groups respond to and interpret bioelectric signals differently from single cells.",
          "quote": "Cells in groups respond to and interpret bioelectrical signals differently than single cells.",
          "page": 9,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76940",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "IK channel activation increases tumor growth and induces differential behavioral responses in two breast epithelial cell lines",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Cancer as loss and restoration of collective goals",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "breast cancer xenograft (mouse)",
          "claim": "Raising one potassium channel's activity is sufficient to increase tumour growth and metastasis in vivo, a bioelectric lever on cancer aggression.",
          "quote": "IK over-expression increased primary tumor growth and metastasis of MDA-MB-231 in orthotopic xenografts",
          "page": 1,
          "source": "consistency with 76790 (catalogue audit)",
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "IK channel overexpression promotes breast tumour growth/metastasis; cancer cell biology not framed as an organism/collective capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76941",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Serotonergic stimulation induces nerve growth and promotes visual learning via posterior eye grafts in a vertebrate model of induced sensory plasticity",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Sensor and effector remapping",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "blind Xenopus tadpoles with ectopic eye grafts",
          "claim": "Eyes grafted to the trunk of blinded tadpoles, when innervation is boosted by a 5-HT1B/D agonist, support learning in visual assays.",
          "quote": "Blind animals possessing eye grafts with the augmented innervation demonstrate increased performance over untreated siblings in wavelength-based learning assays.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Operant and instrumental learning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles in automated training device",
          "claim": "Tadpoles learn a light-colour preference under punishment; learners receive fewer punishments than non-learners.",
          "quote": "learners receive significantly less punishments than individuals who do not learn in the device",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Functional integration of ectopic organs",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with ectopic eyes",
          "claim": "Increased innervation enables integration of an ectopic eye with host CNS and behavioural programs, including visual pattern recognition.",
          "quote": "leads to enhanced functional integration of the ectopic organ with the host central nervous system and behavioral programs",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76942",
      "year": 2017,
      "title": "Discovering novel phenotypes with automatically inferred dynamic models: a partial melanocyte conversion in Xenopus",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus melanocytes",
          "claim": "Melanocyte conversion to a metastatic-like phenotype is all-or-none: within each animal, cells either all convert or none do.",
          "quote": "individual animals either fully convert or remain normal, at some characteristic frequency after a given perturbation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Model-guided discovery of novel phenotypes",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "machine-learned signalling network model; Xenopus melanocytes",
          "claim": "An inferred dynamic model predicted a three-reagent combination that breaks the all-or-none concordance, producing a never-seen partial conversion confirmed in vivo.",
          "quote": "applying the predicted combination of three reagents in vivo revealed precisely the expected novel outcome, resulting in partial conversion of melanocytes within individuals",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76944",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Modeling regenerative processes with membrane computing",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "regenerative P system (membrane computing) model of planaria",
          "claim": "The P-system model regenerates complete flatworm morphology from surgically manipulated fragments, including bisected-head cases.",
          "quote": "the model simulates the regeneration of a complete flatworm from a surgically manipulated morphology",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Cell polarity compass for regeneration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerative P system model",
          "claim": "The model predicts that a cell-level polarity compass orienting cells to large-scale axes is necessary for regeneration.",
          "quote": "cell polarity (a compass that orients individual cells to large-scale axial cues in many patterning organisms [23,24] ), is necessary in these regeneration processes",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76947",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Introduction to provocative questions in left–right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Cross-scale amplification of cell chirality",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "left-right asymmetry across single cells to vertebrates",
          "claim": "Single-cell chirality mechanisms (cytoskeleton, DNA chain asymmetry) are amplified and coordinated with body axes to produce organism-level asymmetry.",
          "quote": "These include cytoskeleton and DNA chain asymmetry-mechanisms that are amplified and coordinated with those employed for the determination of the anterior-posterior and dorsal-ventral axes of the embryo.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Theme-issue introduction on left-right asymmetry."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76948",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "From cytoskeletal dynamics to organ asymmetry: a nonlinear, regulative pathway underlies left–right patterning",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Developmental self-correction of patterning errors",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus left-right patterning pathway",
          "claim": "Many embryos with incorrect early Nodal sidedness still develop correct organ situs, showing the LR pathway corrects patterning errors over developmental time.",
          "quote": "some defects in expression of early laterality markers are being corrected by the time of organ placement",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus craniofacial development",
          "claim": "Frog embryos with severely malformed faces self-correct over time to produce largely normal faces.",
          "quote": "the derivation of largely normal frog faces from early embryos with severely malformed facial structures, which self-correct over time",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Cross-scale amplification of cell chirality",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "cytoskeleton to organ asymmetry",
          "claim": "Cytoskeletal dynamics underlie single-cell chirality that is propagated to body-scale left-right patterning.",
          "quote": "cytoskeletal dynamics underlie the asymmetry of single cell behavior and of patterning of the left-right axis",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76949",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Top-down models in biology: explanation and control of complex living systems above the molecular level",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Hierarchical goals and subgoals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryogenesis and regeneration (top-down models)",
          "claim": "Argues that top-down models with higher-order causal elements can complement the mainstream bottom-up paradigm for explaining pattern homeostasis.",
          "quote": "By targeting system controls at multiple levels of organization and demystifying goal-directed (cybernetic) processes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryos and regenerating organisms",
          "claim": "Cells cooperate toward large-scale anatomical goal states, exemplified by pattern homeostasis in embryogenesis and regeneration.",
          "quote": "requires new approaches to understand how cells cooperate towards large-scale anatomical goal states",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76951",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Vertically- and horizontally-transmitted memories – the fading boundaries between regeneration and inheritance in planaria",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Memory through damage or remodelling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Tail fragments of trained planaria retain learned information after decapitation and brain regeneration.",
          "quote": "tail fragments of trained worms can retain information acquired during learning phases of the worm's life",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Collective memory beyond an individual lifetime",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planaria reproducing by fission",
          "claim": "Somatic experiences fixed as stable biochemical or physiological states may be transmitted across fission-based reproduction and contribute to evolution.",
          "quote": "The maintenance and fixing of somatic experiences, encoded via stable biochemical or physiological states, may contribute to evolutionary processes in the absence of classically defined generations.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76952",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Dynamic Structure Discovery and Repair for 3D Cell Assemblages",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Functional homeostasis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "3D agent-based cell communication model (planarian-like shape)",
          "claim": "Cells exchanging path-encoding packets discover their structure and replace dying cells, maintaining shape indefinitely even under high random death rates.",
          "quote": "allows a 3D arrangement of cells to discover its structure and maintain it in the light of random cell death, even at very high death rates",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Self-modelling of body structure",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "3D agent-based cell communication model",
          "claim": "The cell collective discovers its own structure via message passing, information then used for repair.",
          "quote": "there exists a parameter space in which our model can repair death cells and maintain the individual's structure indefinitely",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76953",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "A Level Set Approach to Simulating Xenopus laevis Tail Regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "level-set simulation of Xenopus tail regeneration",
          "claim": "Patterning-control growth switches off as the simulated shape approaches the reference map.",
          "quote": "The patterning control switches off when the organism shape approaches the reference map (Case A).",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "level-set simulation of Xenopus tail regeneration",
          "claim": "The control scheme regenerates tail morphology after amputation while the tail continues to grow.",
          "quote": "morphology is regenerated while the tail grows in size, a behavior seen in Xenopus regeneration",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76954",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Exploring Instructive Physiological Signaling with the Bioelectric Tissue Simulation Engine",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BETSE bioelectric simulation of single cells",
          "claim": "A cell's resting Vmem acts as an attractor reached from highly variable initial ion concentrations and voltages.",
          "quote": "a cell's resting Vmem is an attractor state that can be reached even with remarkably variable initial conditions",
          "page": 22,
          "page_end": 22
        },
        {
          "name": "Setpoint maintenance without learning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BETSE bioelectric simulation",
          "claim": "After transient perturbation such as high external K+, cell Vmem returns to its original resting value.",
          "quote": "cell Vmem returns to its original resting value once the perturbation ceases",
          "page": 22,
          "page_end": 22
        },
        {
          "name": "Spontaneous bioelectric pattern formation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "BETSE gap-junction-coupled cell cluster",
          "claim": "Positive feedback in GJ-networked cells amplifies small asymmetries into a strong dipolar axial Vmem gradient.",
          "quote": "An example feedback mechanism was found capable of generating a strong, dipolar axial Vmem gradient in a cluster of voltage-sensitive GJ networked cells with TJ",
          "page": 20,
          "page_end": 21
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76955",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryogenesis, regeneration, metamorphosis",
          "claim": "Morphogenesis is goal-directed: it pursues multiple paths to the same anatomical goal and accommodates unpredictable perturbations.",
          "quote": "the system can pursue multiple paths toward the same (anatomical) goal state, can accommodate unpredictable external perturbations",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryogenesis, regeneration, metamorphosis",
          "claim": "Morphogenetic processes stop precisely when correct shape is produced, recognising goal achievement.",
          "quote": "Embryogenesis, regeneration, and metamorphosis stop precisely when the correct anatomical shape has been produced",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Navigation in morphospace",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "non-neural somatic cell networks",
          "claim": "Somatic networks process information to control cell behaviours that move the body through morphospace, analogous to brains guiding movement in ecological space.",
          "quote": "control cell behaviors (differentiation, migration, proliferation) to optimize the body's movement through morphospace",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Mechanical or sensory illusions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "slime molds, multi-animal colonies",
          "claim": "Perceptual illusions that afflict brains are also found in aneural systems from slime molds to colonies.",
          "quote": "some of the same illusions to which advanced brains' perception and rational reasoning fall prey are being found in systems from slime molds to multi-animal colonies",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Single-cell memory",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "budding yeast, Dictyostelium, bacteria",
          "claim": "Single cells keep histories of past events (yeast 'mnemons', pseudopod memory in amoebae, chemotactic short-term memory in bacteria).",
          "quote": "Budding yeast also keep a history which influences their future behavior - a memory of past events.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "non-neural cells expressing ion channels (models)",
          "claim": "Somatic and free-living cells with ion channels can keep stable resting-potential memories.",
          "quote": "cells expressing ion channels can keep a stable memory with respect to resting potential",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Multiscale nested cognition",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "biological systems from molecules to organisms",
          "claim": "Memory and computation at many levels suggests a fractal organization of cognitive subsystems within systems.",
          "quote": "suggests a fractal organization of cognitive subsystems within systems - molecular, cellular, tissue, and body-wide",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76956",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Genome-wide analysis reveals conserved transcriptional responses downstream of resting potential change in Xenopus embryos, axolotl regeneration, and human mesenchymal cell differentiation",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Comparative transcriptomics of responses to depolarization; mechanistic gene lists not framed as how a system achieves a capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76957",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "A Tunable Silk Hydrogel Device for Studying Limb Regeneration in Adult Xenopus Laevis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Inducing regeneration where it normally fails",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "adult Xenopus laevis hindlimb amputation with a silk hydrogel wound-site device",
          "claim": "A hydrogel insert at the amputation site of adult frogs yielded more complex calcified regenerate tissue, which the authors tentatively interpret as a pro-regenerative response.",
          "quote": "the complexity of the calcified tissue in the device animals appears to be a pro-regenerative response, above and beyond adaptation to the environment alone",
          "page": 16,
          "page_end": 17
        }
      ],
      "note": "Mainly a device paper, but it reports an organism-level regenerative outcome (altered spike regenerate) in a poorly regenerating adult; authors hedge the interpretation."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76958",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Physiological inputs regulate species-specific anatomy during embryogenesis and regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Alternative stable morphologies",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian (Girardia dorotocephala)",
          "claim": "Transient perturbation of electrical coupling makes genetically wild-type fragments regenerate coherent head shapes, brains and stem cell distributions of other planarian species.",
          "quote": "octanol-treated fragments stochastically regenerate as several discrete shapes belonging to other species",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Overriding genetic defaults via bioelectric state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria and Xenopus",
          "claim": "Manipulating physiological circuits overrides genome-default patterning, producing head shapes of other species.",
          "quote": "Experimental manipulation of these circuits was recently shown to override genome default patterning outcomes, resulting in head shapes resembling those of other species in planaria and Xenopus.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Tolerance of defective parts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric circuits",
          "claim": "Bioelectric patterning is robust to channel mutations because multiple channels compensate for one another to reach the same Vmem state.",
          "quote": "Morphogenetic functions guided by bioelectric circuits are also robust to mutation in channels and their transcriptional regulation.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioelectric circuits",
          "claim": "Bioelectric states act as master regulators initiating self-limiting patterning subroutines from low-information triggers, amplified by positive feedback.",
          "quote": "allowing the initiation of self-limiting patterning modules as subroutines from a low information content input (trigger)",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Versatility of reachable outcomes",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria and Xenopus under physiological manipulation",
          "claim": "Manipulating physiological signals yields a much wider range of patterning outcomes than single-gene genetic screens.",
          "quote": "manipulation of physiological signals results in a much wider overall range of patterning outcomes (Fig. 5) than has been seen in genetic screens targeting individual gene products",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76959",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Computational discovery and in vivo validation of hnf4 as a regulatory gene in planarian regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Model-guided discovery of novel phenotypes",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "reverse-engineered planarian regeneration network model",
          "claim": "A machine-inferred regulatory model predicted an unknown gene (hnf4) and that its knockdown would rescue the tailless hh-RNAi phenotype, validated in vivo.",
          "quote": "the model predicted that RNAi of hnf4 would rescue the abnormal regenerated phenotype (tailless) of RNAi of hh in amputated trunk fragments",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76960",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Color and intensity discrimination in Xenopus laevis tadpoles",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stimulus discrimination",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis tadpoles",
          "claim": "Tadpoles learn active-avoidance tasks discriminating wavelengths independent of intensity, and intensities above a threshold difference.",
          "quote": "individuals can correctly distinguish between wavelengths even in the absence of intensity differences",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis tadpoles",
          "claim": "Tadpoles acquire light-mediated active-avoidance associations in automated assays.",
          "quote": "Xenopus is a tractable model organism for cognitive research and can learn a variety of associative tasks in the laboratory settings",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Extinction and spontaneous recovery",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis tadpoles",
          "claim": "Loss of learned avoidance is driven by extinction trials rather than the passage of time.",
          "quote": "identifying active extinction effects as far more potent than the passage of time in the loss of behavior",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76962",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Formin Is Associated with Left-Right Asymmetry in the Pond Snail and the Frog",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Cross-scale amplification of cell chirality",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "pond snail (Lymnaea) and Xenopus",
          "claim": "A cytoskeletal formin underlies the earliest chiral symmetry breaking, suggesting diverse animals derive body asymmetry from the same intracellular chiral elements.",
          "quote": "animals with diverse body plans may derive their asymmetries from the same intracellular chiral elements",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76963",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Physiological controls of large-scale patterning in planarian regeneration: a molecular and computational perspective on growth and form",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planaria repair bodily damage and cease remodelling when correct anatomy is achieved.",
          "quote": "Planaria are complex metazoans that repair damage to their bodies and cease remodeling when a correct anatomy has been achieved.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planaria allometrically rescale organs and tissues to maintain proportions after regeneration, a process involving Vmem.",
          "quote": "Planaria have the striking ability to allometrically scale their organs and tissues in order to maintain their proper proportions after regeneration",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Coherent group decisions",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planarian body (bioelectric networks)",
          "claim": "The planarian body shows robustness, long-range integration, decision-making and activity that continues until the correct end-state is reached.",
          "quote": "The information processing capabilities of the planarian body exhibit robustness, distributed (long-range) integration, decision-making, and cellular activity that drives changes until the correct anatomical end-state is reached.",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76964",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Neurotransmitter signaling pathways required for normal development in Xenopus laevis embryos: a pharmacological survey screen",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Pharmacological teratology screen (malformations); defects not framed as a capability such as LR asymmetry or regeneration."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76965",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Use of genetically encoded, light-gated ion translocators to control tumorigenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Cancer normalization by restoring differentiation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with KRAS-induced tumour-like structures (optogenetics)",
          "claim": "Light-activated hyperpolarizing ion translocators prevent KRAS tumour formation and, after formation, increase tumour regression (normalization).",
          "quote": "activation of co-expressed light-activated ion translocators after tumor formation significantly increases the frequency with which the tumors regress in a process called normalization",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76966",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Bioelectric signalling via potassium channels: a mechanism for craniofacial dysmorphogenesis in KCNJ2-associated Andersen-Tawil Syndrome",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric prepattern instructing anatomy",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus and mouse craniofacial development (Kir2.1/KCNJ2)",
          "claim": "Kir2.1-dependent Vmem regionalization forms a bioelectric face prepattern that precedes and regulates craniofacial gene expression domains.",
          "quote": "This regionalization precedes and functionally regulates the gene expression domains known to pattern the neural crest and placodes.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76967",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Conserved roles for cytoskeletal components in determining laterality",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Developmental self-correction of patterning errors",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus left-right patterning",
          "claim": "Many embryos normalize organ positions despite incorrect asymmetric gene expression, revealing a self-repair checkpoint.",
          "quote": "The ability of many embryos to normalize organ locations despite incorrect asymmetric gene expression reveals the existence of a kind of self-repair or fixing checkpoint",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Cross-scale amplification of cell chirality",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos (cytoskeletal manipulations)",
          "claim": "Subcellular chiral cytoskeletal events immediately post-fertilization are integrated and amplified into body-wide left-right patterning.",
          "quote": "chiral events at the subcellular level are integrated and amplified into asymmetric transcriptional cascades and ultimately into the anatomical patterning of the entire body",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76968",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Bioelectric modulation of macrophage polarization",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of cell state plasticity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "human macrophages (THP-1 and primary)",
          "claim": "Modulating KATP channels alters macrophage polarization and can shift the phenotype of already-polarized macrophages.",
          "quote": "modulation of cell membrane electrical properties can fine-tune macrophage plasticity",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76969",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "On chirality of slime mould",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Lateralized behavioural bias",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum) in T-maze",
          "claim": "Physarum shows a consistent right-turn bias in a T-shaped arena, a laterality possibly derived from cytoskeletal chirality.",
          "quote": "we found that Physarum turns right in more than 74% of trials",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Edge following and spatial exploration",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "A consistent turning bias implements a wall-follower rule that shortens exploration of unknown constrained environments like mazes.",
          "quote": "An evolutionary advantage of preferential right turn (left turn is also OK as long as it always left) is in decreasing exploration time of an unknown geometrically constrained environment.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76970",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "MoCha: Molecular Characterization of Unknown Pathways",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Bioinformatics tool (MoCha) for unknown pathway components; tool only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76971",
      "year": 2016,
      "title": "Towards a Physarum learning chip",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stimulus-dependent network plasticity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum) on electrode grid; particle model",
          "claim": "Low-frequency AC stimulation strengthens connectivity between stimulated electrodes while high-frequency stimulation weakens it, giving pathway-dependent plasticity akin to weighted learning.",
          "quote": "low frequency (10 Hz) sinusoidal (0.5 V peak-to-peak) voltage increases connectivity between stimulated electrodes while decreasing connectivity elsewhere",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Frequency-selective response",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Physarum tube networks respond oppositely to low- versus high-frequency electrical stimulation.",
          "quote": "high frequency (1000 Hz) sinusoidal (2.5 V peak-to-peak) voltage stimulation decreases network connectivity between stimulated electrodes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Network optimisation by foraging organism",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "slime mould (Physarum polycephalum)",
          "claim": "Physarum protoplasmic tube networks optimally span food sources, avoiding repellents while maximizing attractant coverage, mapping data configurations into networks.",
          "quote": "Networks of protoplasmic tubes of organism Physarum polycehpalum are macro-scale structures which optimally span multiple food sources to avoid repellents yet maximize coverage of attractants.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Logic computation in non-neural media",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Physarum polycephalum",
          "claim": "Physarum propagation along agar channels has implemented Boolean logic gates.",
          "quote": "First recognisable Boolean logic gate using propagation of plasmodial P. polycephalum along agar channels",
          "page": 1,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76973",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Comparison of the depolarization response of human mesenchymal stem cells from different donors",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Donor variability in hMSC depolarization responses in vitro; cell-level, no organism/collective capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76974",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Gap Junctional Blockade Stochastically Induces Different Species-Specific Head Anatomies in Genetically Wild-Type Girardia dorotocephala Flatworms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian (Girardia dorotocephala)",
          "claim": "Supplementary material shows wild-type fragments recapitulate adult morphology by day 10 of regeneration (control for GJ-blockade species-head experiments).",
          "quote": "Adult morphology is recapitulated by day 10 of regeneration in water",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ],
      "note": "Only supplementary materials are in the corpus; the main paper's species-specific head shape result could not be quoted."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76975",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Re-membering the body: applications of computational neuroscience to the top-down control of regeneration of limbs and other complex organs",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerating limbs and organs (bioelectric networks)",
          "claim": "Target morphology may be encoded as a true memory of shape in bioelectric networks, which could be rewritten using tools adapted from memory modification.",
          "quote": "We hypothesize that developmental bioelectricity implements true pattern memory.",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Proportional error correction",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerating tissues",
          "claim": "Cell behaviour may be guided by a cybernetic error-correction algorithm minimizing deviation from a target morphology.",
          "quote": "Could cell behavior be guided by an algorithm that minimizes - in the cybernetic sense of error-correction - the deviation from a specific Target Morphology?",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "developing and regenerating bodies",
          "claim": "Bodies adjust their shape to the same final outcome despite external perturbation, analogous to goal-seeking behaviour.",
          "quote": "how bodies adjust their shape to the same final outcome despite external perturbation",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Training tissues by reinforcement",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "morphogenetic systems",
          "claim": "Morphogenetic systems might be trained to desired outcomes by rewarding outcomes rather than micromanaging signalling.",
          "quote": "It may be possible to efficiently \"train\" morphogenetic systems to desired outcomes, by providing rewards (or \"objective functions\") for specific outcomes",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 19
        },
        {
          "name": "Somatic memory and decision-making",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "non-neural bioelectric tissues",
          "claim": "In non-neural cells as in brains, bioelectric signalling implements information processing, decision-making and memory for pattern regulation.",
          "quote": "In non-neural cells, as in the brain, bioelectric signaling implements information processing, decision-making, and memory in regulating pattern and its remodeling.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76976",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Automatic neuron segmentation and neural network analysis method for phase contrast microscopy images",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Image-segmentation method for neuron images; tool only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76978",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Bioelectric memory: modeling resting potential bistability in amphibian embryos and mammalian cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "single-cell membrane models (amphibian oocyte and mammalian channels)",
          "claim": "Cells expressing particular channel subsets (persistent Na+ or inward-rectifying K+) stably maintain one of several resting potentials, a voltage memory.",
          "quote": "Our results reveal conditions under which cells can stably maintain one of several resting voltage potential values.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "single-cell membrane models",
          "claim": "Transient voltage clamps reversibly switch the cell between stable voltage attractors, implementing a writable memory element.",
          "quote": "it is possible to reversibly drive the voltage from one attractor to the other, implementing a true memory element",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76981",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "The stability of memories during brain remodeling: A perspective",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Memory through damage or remodelling",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "metamorphosing insects, regenerating planaria, hibernating ground squirrels",
          "claim": "Evidence from several taxa indicates memories can survive drastic rearrangement and rebuilding of the CNS.",
          "quote": "Convincing data from insects, planaria, and mammals suggest the ability of memories to survive drastic rearrangement and rebuilding of the CNS.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Memory stored outside the brain",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planaria; frog eggs",
          "claim": "Memory may be stored in non-neural tissue and imprinted on the regenerating brain, and pre-neural eggs can pass learned preferences to later nervous systems.",
          "quote": "in planaria, it is possible that memory can be stored outside the brain and imprinted on the nascent brain during regeneration",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planaria (McConnell experiments)",
          "claim": "Planaria were classically conditioned (light paired with shock) before being cut to test which half retained the memory.",
          "quote": "McConnell and his students trained worms using a classical conditioning protocol (paring light with an electric shock)",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76982",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Local and long-range endogenous resting potential gradients antagonistically regulate apoptosis and proliferation in the embryonic CNS",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric coordination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryonic CNS",
          "claim": "Local and distant (ventral non-neural) Vmem signals antagonistically regulate apoptosis-proliferation balance in the developing brain, with long-range rescue effects.",
          "quote": "Especially interesting are the long-range rescue effects",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76983",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Selective depolarization of transmembrane potential alters muscle patterning and muscle cell localization in Xenopus laevis embryos",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Hijacking and false signals",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos (GlyR instructor cells)",
          "claim": "Depolarizing a small, distant instructor-cell population non-cell-autonomously converts melanocytes to a metastatic-like phenotype without genetic damage.",
          "quote": "depolarization of even a few cells, a long distance away from the melanocytes is sufficient to radically change their behavior leading to a metastatic-like phenotype",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with muscle-depolarization defects",
          "claim": "Despite aberrant muscle patterning, tadpoles retain (reduced) ability to learn in an associative conditioning assay.",
          "quote": "which impacts but does not abolish the animals' ability to learn in an associative conditioning assay",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76984",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Inferring regulatory networks from experimental morphological phenotypes: a computational method reverse-engineers planarian regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planaria regenerate their correct anatomical pattern after drastic perturbations, which the paper's inferred model aims to explain.",
          "quote": "its remarkable ability to regenerate its correct anatomical pattern after drastic perturbations",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Model-guided discovery of novel phenotypes",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "machine-learning inference of planarian regulatory networks",
          "claim": "An automated method inferred a regulatory network that correctly predicted outcomes of experiments withheld from the search.",
          "quote": "Simulations of the three novel experiments not included during the search with the found network result in the exact correct phenotypes obtained in vivo.",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 16
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76988",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Knowing one's place: a free-energy approach to pattern regulation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Self-assembly by free-energy minimization",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated cell ensemble with shared generative model (active inference)",
          "claim": "Cells sharing a generative model of target form self-assemble into it by minimizing variational free energy, inferring their place.",
          "quote": "self-assembly is an emergent property of cells that share a common (genetic and epigenetic) model of organismal form",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "simulated active-inference cell ensemble",
          "claim": "After the partially formed embryo is bisected, each half dedifferentiates slightly then reconfigures to produce the full target morphology.",
          "quote": "Both of these (split embryo) clones dynamically reconfigure themselves to produce the target morphology",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Active inference in cellular collectives",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "morphogenesis as active inference",
          "claim": "Cells can be interpreted as inferring the causes of their inputs and acting to resolve uncertainty, with genomes parametrizing a generative model of the target morphology.",
          "quote": "allows one to interpret (the dynamics of) a system as inferring the causes of its inputs-and acting to resolve uncertainty about those causes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76989",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Endogenous Gradients of Resting Potential Instructively Pattern Embryonic Neural Tissue via Notch Signaling and Regulation of Proliferation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric prepattern instructing anatomy",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryonic brain",
          "claim": "An endogenous hyperpolarization pattern lining the neural tube instructs brain patterning; disrupting it mispatterns the brain.",
          "quote": "disruption of this spatial gradient of the transmembrane potential (Vmem) diminishes or eliminates the expression of early brain markers, and causes anatomical mispatterning of the brain",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Overriding genetic defaults via bioelectric state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos with activated Notch",
          "claim": "Forced hyperpolarization rescues brain defects caused by constitutively active Notch.",
          "quote": "forced hyperpolarization by misexpression of specific ion channels rescues brain defects induced by activated Notch signaling",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric coordination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos",
          "claim": "Hyperpolarizing ventral cells outside the brain upregulates neural proliferation at long range and can induce ectopic neural tissue.",
          "quote": "hyperpolarization of transmembrane potential (Vmem) in ventral cells outside the brain induces upregulation of neural cell proliferation at long range",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76990",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "Membrane potential depolarization causes alterations in neuron arrangement and connectivity in cocultures",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Depolarization alters neuron aggregation/connectivity in culture; cell/tissue mechanism, not framed as a capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76991",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "On a model of pattern regeneration based on cell memory",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "mathematical cell-signal model of regeneration",
          "claim": "Cells remembering their pre-amputation signal regrow missing structure driven by the difference between old and new signals.",
          "quote": "being the first quantitative model of cellular memory that implements regeneration of complex patterns to a specific target morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "mathematical cell-signal model of regeneration",
          "claim": "Growth stops when the new signal equals the remembered signal, implementing a means-ends analysis.",
          "quote": "Regeneration of the cell structure is stimulated by the difference between the old and the new signals. It is stopped when the two signals coincide.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Proportional error correction",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "mathematical cell-signal model of regeneration",
          "claim": "Cells produce a growth-stimulating substance at a rate proportional to the difference between remembered and current signals.",
          "quote": "the cell produces some substance with the rate proportional to",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "mathematical cell-signal model of regeneration",
          "claim": "Correct regeneration depends on structure size and signal decay, limiting regeneration of large structures.",
          "quote": "Correct regeneration depends on the form and the size of the cell structure, as well as on some parameters of regeneration.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76992",
      "year": 2015,
      "title": "A novel method for inducing nerve growth via modulation of host resting potential: gap junction-mediated and serotonergic signaling mechanisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with ectopic eye grafts",
          "claim": "Grafted eye neurons read host bioelectric topography; only ectopically placed eyes hyperinnervate in response to host depolarization, not eyes in their normal head location.",
          "quote": "tissue becomes more sensitive to bioelectric signals when it is located in an anatomically incorrect location",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Non-neural tissue instructing nerve growth",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with ectopic eye grafts",
          "claim": "Depolarizing host tissue induces striking hyperinnervation by ectopic eyes, as neurons read the electrical topography of surrounding cells.",
          "quote": "neurons read the electric topography of surrounding cells, and demonstrate these cues can be leveraged to initiate sensory organ transplant innervation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76993",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Long-range gap junctional signaling controls oncogene-mediated tumorigenesis in Xenopus laevis embryos",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric coordination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryos with KRAS-induced tumours",
          "claim": "Gap-junctional communication modulates long-range bioelectric suppression of tumorigenesis across ~300 cell diameters.",
          "quote": "our data suggest a complex cross-talk between distant regions of the body that impinge on the stochastic nature of tumorigenesis",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76994",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Molecular bioelectricity: how endogenous voltage potentials control cell behavior and instruct pattern regulation in vivo",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric prepattern instructing anatomy",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "frog face, planarian, left-right axis, zebrafish fins",
          "claim": "Bioelectric prepatterns, like Hox codes, encode organ identity, position, size and axial polarity.",
          "quote": "Spatiotemporal gradients of Vmem among cells in vivo are now known to regulate organ identity, positional information, size control, and polarity of anatomical axes.",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Spontaneous bioelectric pattern formation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled non-neural cells",
          "claim": "Regionalized Vmem patterns can self-organize de novo in identical cells via positive feedback in an electrically excitable medium.",
          "quote": "Such regionalized patterns of Vmem can also form de novo in transcriptionally and proteomically identical cells because cells coupled by gap junctions (electrical synapses) form a (slow) electrically excitable medium",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus and other regenerating models",
          "claim": "Spatiotemporal Vmem changes act as triggers for limb regeneration, eye formation and axial polarity.",
          "quote": "serve as signals that trigger limb regeneration, induce eye formation, set polarity of whole-body anatomical axes, and orchestrate craniofacial patterning",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76995",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Optogenetic Control of Apoptosis in Targeted Tissues of Xenopus laevis Embryos",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Methods paper on optogenetic (KillerRed) targeted apoptosis; tool only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76996",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Optogenetics in Developmental Biology: using light to control ion flux-dependent signals in Xenopus embryos",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Methods/troubleshooting guide for optogenetics in Xenopus; tool only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76997",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Left-right patterning in Xenopus conjoined twin embryos requires serotonin signaling and gap junctions",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Instructive transfer of axial information between organizers",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus conjoined twin embryos",
          "claim": "Late-induced secondary organizers correctly orient their LR axis only when instructed by the primary organizer, a transfer requiring serotonergic and gap-junctional signalling.",
          "quote": "serotonergic and gap-junctional signaling, but not proton or potassium flows, are required for the secondary organizer to appropriately pattern its LR axis in a multicellular context",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76998",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Fishing on chips: up-and-coming technological advances in analysis of zebrafish and Xenopus embryos",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Review of lab-on-chip technologies for embryos; technology review."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "76999",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Limbform: a functional ontology-based database of limb regeneration experiments",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Database (Limbform) of limb regeneration experiments; database only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77000",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Depolarization of Cellular Resting Membrane Potential Promotes Neonatal Cardiomyocyte Proliferation In Vitro",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Depolarization maintains neonatal cardiomyocyte proliferation in vitro; cell-level, no organism capability demonstrated."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77002",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "A bioinformatics expert system linking functional data to anatomical outcomes in limb regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "amphibians and molting arthropods (limb regeneration)",
          "claim": "Amphibians and molting arthropods regenerate amputated limbs; the paper formalizes such experiments into a database and expert system.",
          "quote": "Amphibians and molting arthropods have the remarkable capacity to regenerate amputated limbs",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Primarily a bioinformatics ontology/database paper."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77004",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Transmembrane voltage potential of somatic cells controls oncogene-mediated tumorigenesis at long-range",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric coordination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with KRAS-induced tumour-like structures",
          "claim": "Hyperpolarizing ion channels expressed at distant sites suppress oncogene-driven tumorigenesis, showing remote cells' resting potentials control tumour formation.",
          "quote": "misexpression of hyperpolarizing ion channels at distant sites within the tadpole significantly reduced the incidence of these tumors",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Overriding genetic defaults via bioelectric state",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles expressing human oncogenes",
          "claim": "Bioelectric state of host cells determines whether cells expressing oncogenes go on to form tumours.",
          "quote": "resting potentials in remote cells have a profound influence on whether or not a cell expressing human oncogenes will go on to form a tumor in vivo",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77005",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Alteration of bioelectrically-controlled processes in the embryo: a teratogenic mechanism for anticonvulsants",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Hypothesis that anticonvulsant teratogenicity acts via bioelectric disruption; malformation mechanism not framed as a capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77007",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "Endogenous bioelectrical networks store non-genetic patterning information during development and regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "A transient gap-junction block yields two-headed planaria whose altered target morphology persists through later rounds of amputation in plain water, without genomic change.",
          "quote": "A transient perturbation of physiological cell:cell communication via gap junctions has stably changed the pattern to which the animal regenerates upon damage!",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric storage of patterning information",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled bioelectric networks of non-neural cells",
          "claim": "Target morphology information is proposed to be stored as a distributed memory in the bioelectrical dynamics of somatic cell networks, akin to neural networks.",
          "quote": "We propose that this information is a kind of memory, encoded in electrical networks of somatic cells coupled by gap junctions",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planarian fragments communicate with remaining tissue to decide which structures to build, continuously remodelling toward a specific target morphology.",
          "quote": "Their capacity for self-repair serves as a paradigm case of dynamic morphostasis and continuous remodelling towards a specific target morphology.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "bioelectric patterning (Xenopus, planaria)",
          "claim": "The trigger for morphogenetic outcomes is a bioelectric state rather than a specific gene product; many different channels can produce the same outcome if the right voltage state is reached.",
          "quote": "many sodium, potassium, chloride, or proton conductances can be used as long as the appropriate bioelectrical state is reached",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cancer / melanocytes",
          "claim": "Carcinogenesis is framed as cells defecting from the organism's target morphology, and depolarization can impose or prevent metastatic-like phenotypes.",
          "quote": "carcinogenesis can be seen as cellular defections from the correct target morphology",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77008",
      "year": 2014,
      "title": "A linear-encoding model explains the variability of the target morphology in regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target morphology via injury",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "deer antler, planarian, fiddler crab",
          "claim": "Deer antlers, planaria and fiddler crabs can alter their target morphology specifically and stably in response to injuries at particular locations.",
          "quote": "their target morphology can be altered specifically and stably by injuries in particular locations",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Rewritable target memory",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Octanol-induced two-headed planaria keep regenerating the altered morphology in subsequent amputations after the drug is washed out.",
          "quote": "These changes in the target morphology are persistent: subsequent amputations regenerate the same altered morphology",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Solving the morphological inverse problem",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regenerating organisms (models)",
          "claim": "Organisms that change target morphology at precise locations must solve an inverse problem, which the authors argue requires a linear (explicit) encoding of target shape.",
          "quote": "they must know the local actions that will produce the new morphology",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Explicit encoding of target morphology",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "regeneration models",
          "claim": "Regenerating organisms are proposed to store a linear encoding (blueprint or instruction list) of target shape produced by a nonlinear genetic encoding.",
          "quote": "We propose, therefore, the existence of a linear encoding of the target morphology in these regenerative organisms",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Regenerating planaria rescale all parts to the new proportions of their smaller size.",
          "quote": "producing a new worm with all the parts adjusted to the new proportions for its now smaller size",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77011",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "It's never too early to get it Right: A conserved role for the cytoskeleton in left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenopus, C. elegans, Arabidopsis, HL-60 cells",
          "claim": "A conserved cytoskeletal chirality inside early cells is proposed to be amplified by physiological signalling into consistent organism-level left-right asymmetry.",
          "quote": "The data from frog embryos suggest a scheme in which physiological signaling amplifies single-cell chirality into gene expression on a large scale.",
          "page": 10,
          "page_end": 10
        },
        {
          "name": "Conserved symmetry-breaking mechanisms",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "plants, nematodes, human cells, frogs",
          "claim": "The same tubulin mutations randomize asymmetry across kingdoms, implying a conserved intracellular symmetry-breaking mechanism.",
          "quote": "revealing a remarkable conservation of symmetrybreaking mechanisms among kingdoms",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77013",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Light-Activated Serotonin for Exploring Its Action in Biological Systems",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos injected with caged serotonin (BHQ-O-5HT)",
          "claim": "Light-triggered release of serotonin during early cleavage disrupted consistent organ laterality, showing LR patterning is sensitive to timed serotonin signalling.",
          "quote": "LR defects including situs inversus and heterotaxia were observed in BHQ-O-5HT injected embryos following uncaging",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ],
      "note": "Chemical tool paper whose in vivo validation shows uncaged 5-HT perturbs LR patterning; coded under the LR group for consistency with other LR-mechanism papers."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77014",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Bioelectric modulation of wound healing in a 3D in vitro model of tissue-engineered bone",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "3D tissue-engineered bone wound model (hMSC-derived osteoblasts)",
          "claim": "The same bioelectric-modulating drugs had different effects on cells in the wound area versus the surrounding tissue, suggesting the local environment alters cell responses to bioelectric signals.",
          "quote": "these compounds displayed differential effects in the wound area compared to the surrounding tissue",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77015",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Depolarization alters phenotype, maintains plasticity of predifferentiated mesenchymal stem cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric override of chemical signals",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "hMSC-derived osteoblasts and adipocytes",
          "claim": "Depolarization downregulated bone and fat markers even in the presence of differentiation-inducing factors, indicating voltage state can dominate biochemical signals in maintaining cell state.",
          "quote": "suggesting that bioelectric signaling overrides biochemical signaling in the maintenance of cell state",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric maintenance of cell plasticity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "hMSC-derived osteoblasts",
          "claim": "Depolarized osteoblasts retained lineage plasticity and achieved better adipocyte morphology on transdifferentiation than controls.",
          "quote": "depolarized osteoblasts demonstrated improved ability to achieve correct adipocyte morphology compared with nondepolarized osteoblasts",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77016",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Endogenous Voltage Potentials and the Microenvironment: Bioelectric Signals that Reveal, Induce and Normalize Cancer",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "cancer (Xenopus, planaria, mammals)",
          "claim": "Cancer is framed as cells ceasing to work toward the host's anatomical goals and shrinking their goal-seeking to the single-cell level.",
          "quote": "cells cease to work towards the anatomical needs of a host organism and narrow their dynamic goal-seeking behavior to the level of single cells",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 18
        },
        {
          "name": "Tumor suppression and normalization by patterning signals",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus larvae with oncogene expression",
          "claim": "Artificial hyperpolarization prevents oncogene-induced tumor-like structures despite strong oncogene expression.",
          "quote": "hyperpolarization could prevent the formation of tumor-like structures despite very robust expression of oncogene in cells",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric induction",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus (instructor cells, melanocytes)",
          "claim": "Depolarization of specific cells can trigger metastatic behaviours in other cells at considerable distance via serotonin and butyrate flows.",
          "quote": "Vmem triggers metastatic behaviors at considerable distance, mediated by transcriptional and epigenetic effects of electrically-modulated flows of serotonin and butyrate",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled cell networks",
          "claim": "Gap-junction coupled tissues form physiological networks with multiple stable attractors in bioelectric state space, so cancer may be a tissue-level state rather than a single-cell one.",
          "quote": "gap junctional coupling results in multi-cellular physiological networks with multiple stable attractors in bioelectrical state space",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Tumors as coherent goal-seeking subsystems",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "tumors",
          "claim": "Tumors are described as coherent, goal-seeking subsystems whose diverse cell types cooperate to acquire nutrients and survive.",
          "quote": "cancer is not only a loss of patterning, but also a coherent, goal-seeking subsystem",
          "page": 18,
          "page_end": 19
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77017",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Reprogramming cells and tissue patterning via bioelectrical pathways: molecular mechanisms and biomedical opportunities",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of organ identity and prepatterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus, planaria, regenerating appendages",
          "claim": "Spatio-temporal Vmem gradients act as instructive cues specifying organ identity, positional information and prepatterns, and their manipulation can trigger organogenesis and appendage regeneration.",
          "quote": "spatio-temporal gradients of these endogenous transmembrane voltage potentials (Vmem) serve as instructive patterning cues for large-scale anatomy",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Persuadability by minimal intervention",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Modulating wound Vmem and gap-junction communication produces 0-, 2- or 4-headed worms, showing large-scale shape control through simple bioelectric cues.",
          "quote": "0-, 2-, or even 4headed (rhombus-shaped) worms can be created - a remarkable control over large-scale shape",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Morphogenetic memory and decision-making in non-neural tissue",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "non-neural bioelectric networks",
          "claim": "Bioelectric spatial information processing in tissues is proposed to blur the line between neural memory/decision-making and morphogenesis.",
          "quote": "this blurs the line between memory and decision-making in neural networks and morphogenesis in non-neural tissues",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Offloading complexity to self-assembly",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "bioengineered tissues",
          "claim": "Master-regulator bioelectric cues would let engineers offload computational complexity onto the organism's own assembly and repair capacities.",
          "quote": "allow bioengineers to offload some of the incredible computational complexity onto the organism itself, which is already ideally suited to carry out the assembly and repair process",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77020",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Inversion of left–right asymmetry alters performance of Xenopus tadpoles in nonlateralized cognitive tasks",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles (automated colour-shock training)",
          "claim": "Tadpoles learned to avoid red light paired with shock and kept avoiding it when red no longer elicited punishment.",
          "quote": "animals received a shock punishment when occupying red portions of the arena, and subsequently spent the majority of their time in blue areas",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 7
        },
        {
          "name": "Body laterality affecting learning rate",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles with randomized or inverted LR axis",
          "claim": "Tadpoles with randomized or reversed body laterality learned colour cues more slowly but reached the same performance optimum given enough training.",
          "quote": "animals with either randomization or reversal of somatic left-right patterning learned more slowly than wild-type siblings",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77026",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Planform: an application and database of graph-encoded planarian regenerative experiments",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Database/application (Planform) of planarian regeneration experiments; tool only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77029",
      "year": 2013,
      "title": "Cracking the bioelectric code: Probing endogenous ionic controls of pattern formation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole (tail regeneration, ectopic hearts)",
          "claim": "A simple, low-information bioelectric signal such as a 1 h sodium flux kickstarts a complex morphogenetic cascade, e.g. full tail regeneration at a non-regenerative stage.",
          "quote": "the information content of the bioelectric event is very low-a simple signal can kickstart a complex, downstream morphogenetic cascade appropriate to the location within the host",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric induction of ectopic organs",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo (eye induction)",
          "claim": "Setting non-eye cells to the eye-specific voltage range induces complete eyes far outside the normal eye field, including in the gut and tail.",
          "quote": "a specific range of resting potential was able to drive cells well outside of the anterior neurectoderm into an eye fate and form complete organs",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Context-dependent interpretation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus",
          "claim": "The same bioelectric trigger produces organs appropriate to the location within the host, implying the host tissue interprets the signal contextually.",
          "quote": "Bioelectric signals produce appropriate organs at appropriate locations.",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77033",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Low frequency vibrations induce malformations in two aquatic species in a frequency-, waveform-, and direction-specific manner",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Frequency-selective response",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus and zebrafish embryos",
          "claim": "Embryonic patterning (LR asymmetry, neural tube, tail) is disrupted by low-frequency vibrations in a manner dependent on frequency, waveform and direction.",
          "quote": "the incidence of the three phenotypes we scored was significantly affected by vibration parameters (waveform, frequency, and wave direction)",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        }
      ],
      "note": "Primarily a developmental toxicology study; competency content is minimal."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77034",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Neurally derived tissues in Xenopus laevis embryos exhibit a consistent bioelectrical left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos (eye fields, melanocytes)",
          "claim": "Even anatomically paired structures show a consistent, laterality-linked bioelectric asymmetry: eye-field hyperpolarization usually appears first on the right.",
          "quote": "We found that the striking hyperpolarization of transmembrane potential (Vmem) demarcating eye induction usually occurs in the right eye field first.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Consistent bioelectric LR asymmetry in paired neural structures, linked to primary laterality."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77036",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Early, nonciliary role for microtubule proteins in left-right patterning is conserved across kingdoms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Conserved symmetry-breaking mechanisms",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus, C. elegans, human HL-60 cells, Arabidopsis",
          "claim": "The same tubulin mutations that alter plant chirality also alter early left-right patterning in nematodes and frogs and chirality of human cells, showing an ancient cytoplasmic origin of laterality.",
          "quote": "The origin of laterality is cytoplasmic, ancient, and highly conserved across kingdoms",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "Tubulin proteins are required for differential distribution of maternal proteins to left vs right blastomeres at first cleavage, linking cytoskeletal chirality to body laterality.",
          "quote": "tubulin α and tubulin γ-associated proteins are required for the differential distribution of maternal proteins to the left or right blastomere at the first cell division",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77037",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Transducing bioelectric signals into epigenetic pathways during tadpole tail regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Induced regeneration in non-regenerative states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail",
          "claim": "Tail regeneration requires, and can be initiated at non-regenerative stages by, specific bioelectric changes; modulating Vmem via GlyCl/ivermectin augments regeneration.",
          "quote": "the regeneration of the tail in Xenopus laevis tadpoles both requires, and can be initiated at non-regenerative stages by, specific regulation of bioelectrical signaling",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77039",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Normalized shape and location of perturbed craniofacial structures in the Xenopus tadpole reveal an innate ability to achieve correct morphology",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Navigation from scrambled starts",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole craniofacial structures",
          "claim": "Experimentally malformed jaws and branchial arches are remodelled and repositioned over months to near-normal shape and location.",
          "quote": "tadpoles with malformed jaws and branchial arches that had obvious deformities 9 days after fertilization are largely indistinguishable from controls approximately 40-80 days later",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole jaw",
          "claim": "Misplaced jaws move farther and in different directions than normal jaws, showing that movement is not a fixed program but adjusted to reach the same target position.",
          "quote": "this is not a set 'program' of movements with predefined magnitude and direction",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole craniofacial structures",
          "claim": "Organs reach the target position and stop changing despite abnormal starts; a ping/stop signalling model with an organizing center is proposed.",
          "quote": "The ability of tissues and organ primordia to achieve the appropriate target position and/or morphology and stop changing once this is achieved, despite abnormal starting states",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Means-ends analysis in tissue",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole craniofacial structures",
          "claim": "Correction of misplaced structures is interpreted as tissues measuring their position relative to reference landmarks and performing a kind of means-ends analysis.",
          "quote": "could be interpreted as an ability to perform a kind of means-ends analysis",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Overshoot and course correction",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole jaw",
          "claim": "Structures approach their correct position non-monotonically, e.g. the jaw overshoots the correct angle before readjusting.",
          "quote": "the jaw can 'over-shoot' the correct angle at d30 before readjusting to an angle that more closely resembles the normal angle by d51",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Tissue-dependent repair capacity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole craniofacial tissues",
          "claim": "Neural-crest-derived jaws and arches are fully normalized, while placode-derived eyes and nostrils are only partially corrected.",
          "quote": "some tissues may be more easily adaptable and repaired with time, whereas others can be somewhat repaired but never restored to a completely normal appearance",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77041",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Inhibition of planar cell polarity extends neural growth during regeneration, homeostasis, and development",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian and Xenopus (neural regeneration)",
          "claim": "The PCP pathway is needed to terminate neural growth once patterning is complete; its loss causes continued hyperplasia, extra eyes and excess neurons.",
          "quote": "This failure to terminate growth suggests that neural tissues use PCP as a readout of patterning",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77046",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Transmembrane voltage potential controls embryonic eye patterning in Xenopus laevis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric induction of ectopic organs",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo (eye)",
          "claim": "Setting Vmem of non-eye cells induces well-formed ectopic eyes, even far outside the anterior neural field.",
          "quote": "Manipulating Vmem of non-eye cells induces well-formed ectopic eyes that are morphologically and histologically similar to endogenous eyes.",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo (eye)",
          "claim": "Eye development is disrupted by distinct channels carrying different ions that share only their effect on Vmem, showing voltage state rather than specific gene is the signal.",
          "quote": "distinct constructs that mediate the flux of different ions (sodium, potassium or chloride) and have in common only their effect on Vmem",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77047",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Molecular bioelectricity in developmental biology: new tools and recent discoveries: control of cell behavior and pattern formation by transmembrane potential gradients",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of organ identity and prepatterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus, planaria, regenerating appendages",
          "claim": "Vmem gradients determine anatomical polarity, act as master regulators in appendage regeneration and LR patterning, and prepattern craniofacial gene expression.",
          "quote": "Transmembrane voltage gradients (Vmem) determine anatomical polarity and function as master regulators during appendage regeneration and embryonic left-right patterning.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Bistability and hysteresis",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "electrically coupled non-neural cell networks",
          "claim": "Bioelectric networks show hysteresis (memory), suggesting all cells could support neural-network-like information processing used for decisions in regulative morphogenesis.",
          "quote": "such networks exhibit properties of hysteresis (memory) [64], suggesting that all cells (not just neurons) could support the information-processing capabilities of neural networks",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77048",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Polarity proteins are required for left-right axis orientation and twin-twin instruction",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Laterality instruction between conjoined twins",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus conjoined twins",
          "claim": "An early primary organizer orients the left-right axis of a later-induced secondary organizer (big brother effect), requiring apical-basal and planar polarity proteins.",
          "quote": "the instruction of the secondary twin by the primary organizer requires ABP and PCP",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo, cultured human cells",
          "claim": "Intrinsic single-cell LR biases could be converted into embryonic laterality via polarity mechanisms in cell fields, independent of cilia.",
          "quote": "The ability of single cells to set up asymmetry suggests that cellular chirality could be converted to embryonic laterality by cilia-independent polarity mechanisms in cell fields.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77049",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Regulation of cell behavior and tissue patterning by bioelectrical signals: challenges and opportunities for biomedical engineering",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Minimal signals triggering rich action",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail",
          "claim": "Bioelectric master-regulator signals of very low information content trigger coherent, self-limiting morphogenetic cascades such as tail regeneration.",
          "quote": "signals of extremely low information content can induce responses in the host that are far too complex for us to bioengineer directly",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 12
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of organ identity and prepatterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "regeneration blastemas, embryos",
          "claim": "Altering Vmem can respecify organ identity in regeneration blastemas and induce complete appendage regeneration.",
          "quote": "respecification of organ identity in regeneration blastemas and induction of complete appendage regeneration",
          "page": 27,
          "page_end": 28
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "bioelectric patterning",
          "claim": "The instructive signal is often Vmem rather than a specific channel, since different channel complements can reach the same voltage range.",
          "quote": "cells expressing different complements of ion channel and pump proteins can achieve the same membrane potential range",
          "page": 27,
          "page_end": 28
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77050",
      "year": 2012,
      "title": "Modeling planarian regeneration: a primer for reverse-engineering the worm",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planarian fragments as small as 1/279th of the worm regenerate a complete worm with the original head-tail orientation.",
          "quote": "As little as 1/279th of a planarian [5], or a fragment with as few as 10,000 cells [6], can regenerate into a new worm within 1-2 weeks.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Detection of missing tissue",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Regeneration restores only the exact missing regions, implying a mechanism for detecting what is absent.",
          "quote": "What is the signaling mechanism that triggers the regeneration of only the exact missing regions, structures, and organs?",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Growth and remodelling cease once regeneration is complete, posed as a key question for models.",
          "quote": "What signals trigger growth and cause remodeling to cease when regeneration is completed?",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Scaling with body or group size",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planaria remodel existing tissues to keep correct organ proportions as body size changes.",
          "quote": "How are planarians able to remodel existing tissues to maintain the correct internal organ proportions as size changes due to available cell number?",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Aging as loss of maintenance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planaria are practically immortal because they continuously regenerate aged or damaged tissues.",
          "quote": "Individual planarians are practically immortal-able to regenerate aging, as well as severely damaged or lost, tissues",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77051",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "Transmembrane potential of GlyCl-expressing instructor cells induces a neoplastic-like conversion of melanocytes via a serotonergic pathway",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric induction",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus neural crest / melanocytes (GlyCl instructor cells)",
          "claim": "Depolarizing a sparse, widely distributed population of GlyCl-expressing instructor cells non-cell-autonomously drives melanocytes into a neoplastic-like, invasive phenotype via serotonin.",
          "quote": "Molecular-genetic depolarization of a sparse, widely distributed set of GlyCl-expressing cells non-cell-autonomously induces a neoplastic-like phenotype in melanocytes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus melanocytes",
          "claim": "Host bioelectric state can trigger a transition of stem cell progeny into a metastatic-melanoma-like state without genetic damage.",
          "quote": "the bioelectrical state of specific cells in the host can trigger the stem cell to neoplastic cell transition in pigment cells",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        },
        {
          "name": "Same endpoint through different paths",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus melanocytes",
          "claim": "The effect is carried by voltage itself, not by GlyCl or chloride specifically.",
          "quote": "the relevant signal is not tied to GlyCl per se, or even chloride, but is truly carried by a physiological parameter - voltage",
          "page": 14,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77052",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "A chemical genetics approach reveals H,K-ATPase-mediated membrane voltage is required for planarian head regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric control of axial polarity",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "regenerating planarian",
          "claim": "H,K-ATPase-mediated depolarization of the blastema determines head-versus-tail identity; depolarization by ivermectin drives head formation even at posterior-facing wounds.",
          "quote": "depolarization drives head formation, even at posterior-facing wounds",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77053",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "The H(+) vacuolar ATPase maintains neural stem cells in the developing mouse cortex",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "v-ATPase/Notch maintains neural stem cells in mouse cortex; cell-level stem-cell maintenance, not an organism-level capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77054",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "Histone deacetylase activity is necessary for left-right patterning during vertebrate development",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stabilizing transient signals into lasting patterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo (LR patterning)",
          "claim": "Epigenetic machinery (HDAC, 5HT-binding Mad3) transduces an early, transient serotonin gradient into a much later, stable asymmetric Nodal expression pattern.",
          "quote": "epigenetic machinery transduces early physiological gradients into much later transcriptional effectors during establishment of consistent organ situs",
          "page": 17,
          "page_end": 18,
          "map_to": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77055",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "Low frequency vibrations disrupt left-right patterning in the Xenopus embryo",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos exposed to low-frequency vibration",
          "claim": "Timed low-frequency vibration randomized internal organ situs, identifying two early steps the embryo needs to establish consistent LR asymmetry.",
          "quote": "Exposure to several low frequencies induced specific randomization of three internal organs (heterotaxia).",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Uses vibration to dissect steps required for consistent LR orientation."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77057",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "Long-distance signals are required for morphogenesis of the regenerating Xenopus tadpole tail, as shown by femtosecond-laser ablation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range information flow in regeneration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail regeneration (fs-laser ablation)",
          "claim": "Regenerate shape depends on position-specific, non-graded information conveyed from distant undamaged tissue along an intact dorsal midline/spinal cord, not only from the regeneration bud.",
          "quote": "there is a conduit of morphology-influencing information that requires a continuous dorsal midline, particularly an undamaged spinal cord",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Whole-group context sensitivity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail",
          "claim": "Damaging two positions changed regenerate morphology in a qualitatively different way than damaging either alone, indicating non-additive integration of whole-body information.",
          "quote": "damaging two positions affected regenerate morphology in a qualitatively different way than did damaging either position alone",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77058",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "HDAC activity is required during Xenopus tail regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration machinery, polarity and repair capacity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis tadpole tail regeneration",
          "claim": "HDAC activity is required for the early stages of tadpole tail regeneration; HDAC inhibitors specifically blocked regeneration.",
          "quote": "Here we show that histone deacetylase (HDAC) activity is required for the early stages of tail regeneration.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Molecular requirement framed as part of how the tadpole regenerates its tail."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77060",
      "year": 2011,
      "title": "The wisdom of the body: future techniques and approaches to morphogenetic fields in regenerative medicine, developmental biology and cancer",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamander, planarian, deer antler",
          "claim": "Some organisms perfectly restore limbs, eyes and other organs, and deer rebuild the same antler pattern year after year.",
          "quote": "deer - a large, adult mammal - regenerate meters of bone and associated tissues when the same antler pattern is rebuilt year after year",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Tumor suppression and normalization by patterning signals",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "salamander limb, developmental environments",
          "claim": "Strong morphogenetic fields keep cells within the patterning plan: tumor tissue in an amputated salamander limb is incorporated into the regenerate, and highly regenerative animals have low cancer incidence.",
          "quote": "If a tumor is induced on the limb of a salamander and the limb is amputated through the tumor, the remaining cancer tissue becomes part of the newly regenerating limb.",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Detection of missing tissue",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Wound cells use long-range signals to know their position, wound orientation and which structures remain and need not be replaced.",
          "quote": "long-range signals allow the wound cells to know where they are located, which direction the wound is facing and what other structures are still present in the fragment",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Aging as loss of maintenance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Planaria show no organism-level aging because senescent cells are continuously replaced.",
          "quote": "they show no evidence of aging at the organism level - while individual cells senesce and die, they are regenerated and the animal lives indefinitely",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 3
        },
        {
          "name": "Explicit encoding of target morphology",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "morphogenetic fields",
          "claim": "If the morphogenetic plan is directly encoded rather than purely emergent, it could be targeted by external signals, avoiding the hard inverse problem.",
          "quote": "if a morpho­genetic plan is more or less directly encoded, we will ultimately be able to provide external signals to activate or modify this plan",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77061",
      "year": 2010,
      "title": "A second-generation device for automated training and quantitative behavior analyses of molecularly-tractable model organisms",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Operant and instrumental learning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpoles (automated training device)",
          "claim": "Tadpoles trained with shock in the red half of the arena shifted to spending more time in the blue half, and kept the preference in an unpunished test phase.",
          "quote": "following four training sessions in which the red quadrants were punished, tadpoles showed a significant change in behavior, spending more time in the high intensity blue half of the dish",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Associative conditioning",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "measured_metric",
          "system": "automated machine-vision training platform for tadpoles, planaria, zebrafish",
          "claim": "A parallel automated device provides real-time individual feedback for quantitative, standardized conditioning assays.",
          "quote": "the available systems do not allow automated training (feedback to individual subjects in real time, which is necessary for operant conditioning assays)",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Kin / self-type discrimination",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "tadpoles",
          "claim": "Tadpoles show kin recognition and modulate growth based on conspecific density.",
          "quote": "exhibit rich social behaviors (schooling), kin recognition",
          "page": 3,
          "source": "independent catalogue audit (results/integrity/catalogue-audit.json)",
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77064",
      "year": 2010,
      "title": "The ATP-sensitive K(+)-channel (K(ATP)) controls early left-right patterning in Xenopus and chick embryos",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis and chick embryos",
          "claim": "KATP channel function is required for consistent LR patterning; dominant-negative Kir6.1 randomized organ positions.",
          "quote": "Expression of specific dominant-negative mutants of the Xenopus Kir6.1 pore subunit of the KATP channel induced randomization of asymmetric organ positioning.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Ion-channel requirement framed as part of establishing consistent LR asymmetry."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77066",
      "year": 2010,
      "title": "BioDome regenerative sleeve for biochemical and biophysical stimulation of tissue regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Induced regeneration in non-regenerative states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "mouse digit tip (BioDome sleeve)",
          "claim": "A wearable sleeve delivering a hydrated environment, extracellular matrix digest and electrical stimulation enhanced early regeneration of amputated murine digits.",
          "quote": "the BioDome was effective in supporting early stages of murine digit tip regeneration when combined with a porcine urinary bladder matrix (UBM) pepsin digest and electrical stimulation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77067",
      "year": 2010,
      "title": "Far from solved: a perspective on what we know about early mechanisms of left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "vertebrate embryos (LR patterning models)",
          "claim": "All major LR models trace asymmetry to chirality of cytoskeletal organizing centers, with controversy about how intracellular chirality is amplified onto cell fields.",
          "quote": "All three models trace the origin of asymmetry back to the chirality of cytoskeletal organizing centers, but significant controversy exists about how this intracellular chirality is amplified onto cell fields.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stabilizing transient signals into lasting patterns",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus, C. elegans AWC neurons",
          "claim": "Rapid, transient physiological redistribution of serotonin or gap-junction signals is converted into stable, permanent asymmetric gene expression and neuronal identity.",
          "quote": "establishes transient connections for physiological signals that specify the permanent asymmetry in the structure and function of the AWC olfactory neurons",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77071",
      "year": 2009,
      "title": "Perspectives and open problems in the early phases of left-right patterning",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "embryos across phyla",
          "claim": "Intracellular LR information must be amplified and coherently imposed across large cell fields, likely via a planar-cell-polarity-like pathway.",
          "quote": "intracellular information must be amplified and coherently imposed across large cell fields",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77072",
      "year": 2009,
      "title": "Particle tracking model of electrophoretic morphogen movement reveals stochastic dynamics of embryonic gradient",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Noise and asynchronous update tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "stochastic particle-tracking model of serotonin electrophoresis in Xenopus embryo",
          "claim": "Stochastic particle and cell-level fluctuations do not propagate to the tissue level, yielding a robust, consistent embryonic LR gradient.",
          "quote": "the stochastic variation at the molecular and cellular level does not transfer to the tissue level",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77073",
      "year": 2009,
      "title": "Left-right asymmetry in the chick embryo requires core planar cell polarity protein Vangl2",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Cells inferring their position in the body",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "chick embryo blastoderm (Vangl2)",
          "claim": "Polarized Vangl2 gives each cell a vector toward the streak which, combined with chiral subcellular structure, could let cells determine whether they are left or right of the midline.",
          "quote": "a planar polarity protein serves as a readout of large-scale embryonic pattern within cells",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        },
        {
          "name": "Synchronization and entrainment",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "chick embryo (Hensen's node)",
          "claim": "Vangl2 loss de-synchronizes asymmetric gene expression within left and right node domains, implying PCP coordinates LR information across cells.",
          "quote": "Vangl2 morpholinos also induce a de-synchronization of asymmetric gene expression within the left and right domains of Hensen's node",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77074",
      "year": 2009,
      "title": "Bioelectric mechanisms in regeneration: Unique aspects and future perspectives",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "amphibian limbs, planaria, tadpole tail",
          "claim": "Bioelectric signalling contributes to how morphogenetic processes robustly restore pattern after perturbation.",
          "quote": "the means by which they can robustly restore pattern after perturbation",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Induced regeneration in non-regenerative states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "amphibian limbs, Xenopus tail, planaria",
          "claim": "Applied or induced electrical signals are sufficient to induce or augment regeneration, e.g. H+ flux induces appendage regeneration.",
          "quote": "Another set of crucial experiments demonstrated sufficiency of the electrical signals in inducing or augmenting regeneration",
          "page": 6,
          "page_end": 6
        },
        {
          "name": "Bioelectric guidance of wound repair",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "epithelia, cornea, spinal cord",
          "claim": "Electric fields generated by disrupted epithelial layers guide migratory cells to repair wounds.",
          "quote": "the fields resulting from disruption of the integrity of the polarized layer provide guidance cues for growth of migratory cells that repair the wound",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77075",
      "year": 2009,
      "title": "Role of membrane potential in the regulation of cell proliferation and differentiation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Inducing regeneration where it normally fails",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail (V-ATPase / heterologous H+ pump)",
          "claim": "The review reports that repolarizing the regeneration bud with a heterologous H+ pump induced tail regeneration under normally non-regenerative conditions.",
          "quote": "expression of a heterologous H + pump repolarized the bud and induced a significant degree of regeneration in normally non-regenerative conditions",
          "page": 7,
          "page_end": 8
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planarian neoblasts during regeneration",
          "claim": "The authors argue that planarian regeneration requires stem cells to be informed what to rebuild and when the target morphology is complete so activity can cease.",
          "quote": "what morphogenetic structures must be recreated by a combination of coordinated proliferation and differentiation, and when the target morphology is complete (regenerative stem cell activity can cease)",
          "page": 12,
          "page_end": 12
        }
      ],
      "note": "Review mostly on cell-level Vmem control of proliferation/differentiation; coded only its organism-level regeneration statements."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77076",
      "year": 2009,
      "title": "Bioelectric controls of cell proliferation: ion channels, membrane voltage and the cell cycle",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Induced regeneration in non-regenerative states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail",
          "claim": "Inducing proton efflux from wound tissue induces complete tail regeneration.",
          "quote": "induction of proton efflux from wound tissue has been shown to induce complete regeneration of the tail in Xenopus tadpoles",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ],
      "note": "Mostly a review of Vmem control of cell cycle and proliferation."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77077",
      "year": 2008,
      "title": "KCNQ1 and KCNE1 K+ channel components are involved in early left-right patterning in Xenopus laevis embryos",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos",
          "claim": "Maternal KCNQ1/KCNE1 potassium channels are asymmetrically localized and required for normal LR asymmetry.",
          "quote": "Molecular loss-offunction using dominant negative constructs demonstrates that both gene products are required for normal LR asymmetry.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Ion-channel requirement framed as part of the bioelectric LR circuit."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77078",
      "year": 2008,
      "title": "Planarian PTEN homologs regulate stem cells and regeneration through TOR signaling",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration machinery, polarity and repair capacity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian Schmidtea mediterranea",
          "claim": "PTEN homologs are required for planarian regeneration; their knockdown disrupts regeneration and causes abnormal outgrowths.",
          "quote": "Inactivation of Smed-PTEN-1 and -2 by RNA interference (RNAi) in planarians disrupts regeneration, and leads to abnormal outgrowths in both cut and uncut animals",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Stem-cell regulator framed as required for regeneration of complex structures."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77079",
      "year": 2008,
      "title": "Modulation of potassium channel confers a hyperproliferative invasive phenotype on embryonic stem cells",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range bioelectric induction",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo neural crest / melanocytes",
          "claim": "Depolarizing embryonic cells via KCNE1 misexpression non-cell-autonomously drives melanocytes to overproliferate and invade tissues, a bioelectric switch for neoplastic-like behaviour.",
          "quote": "Depolarization of embryonic cells by misexpression of KCNE1 non-cell-autonomously induced melanocytes to overproliferate, spread out, and become highly invasive",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77086",
      "year": 2008,
      "title": "What's left in asymmetry?",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "individual cells (mammalian cells, ciliates)",
          "claim": "The authors suggest that cells may be able to orient their own intracellular LR directionality rather than receive it from outside.",
          "quote": "suggest that perhaps cells can independently orient their intracellular directionality along the LR axis",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ],
      "note": "Perspective on open questions in LR asymmetry."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77088",
      "year": 2008,
      "title": "Tail regeneration in Xenopus laevis as a model for understanding tissue repair",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail",
          "claim": "The tadpole tail, containing spinal cord, muscle and vasculature, senses injury and fully regenerates its morphology.",
          "quote": "how a complex appendage senses injury and rapidly repairs the necessary morphology",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail",
          "claim": "Tail regeneration grows faster than normal growth yet stops once the target morphology is rebuilt, by an unknown mechanism.",
          "quote": "this process also knows when to stop; it is unknown how the regenerating system knows when it is done, and the required target morphology has been rebuilt",
          "page": 15,
          "page_end": 15
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77092",
      "year": 2008,
      "title": "H,K-ATPase protein localization and Kir4.1 function reveal concordance of three axes during early determination of left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus and chick embryos",
          "claim": "The early cytoskeleton provides directional information to asymmetrically localize H+/K+-ATPase, setting up LR ion flux as a planar polarity system.",
          "quote": "the cytoskeleton of the early frog embryo can provide asymmetric, directional information for subcellular transport along all three axes",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77095",
      "year": 2007,
      "title": "Gap junctional communication in morphogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Cells inferring their position in the body",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "gap-junction-coupled cell fields (Xenopus LR model)",
          "claim": "Electrophoretic morphogen gradients across gap-junction-coupled fields, including subcellular gradients, could let cells derive directional information.",
          "quote": "providing a potential mechanism by which cells in large GJ-coupled fields can derive directional information",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        },
        {
          "name": "Long-range information flow in regeneration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "vertebrate embryos, planarian regeneration",
          "claim": "Gap junctional communication establishes local and long-range instructive cues in development, regeneration and tumor progression.",
          "quote": "The molecular mechanisms by which GJC establishes local and long-range instructive morphogenetic cues are just beginning to be understood.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77097",
      "year": 2007,
      "title": "What lies at the interface of regenerative medicine and developmental biology?",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "planarians",
          "claim": "Planaria are reported to regenerate nearly any excised part and to stop once the pre-existing structures are rebuilt.",
          "quote": "Planaria, which perfectly regenerate after the excision of nearly every part of their body, and stop as soon as the pre-existing structures are rebuilt",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Inducing regeneration where it normally fails",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus tadpole tail",
          "claim": "Misexpression of a yeast H+ pump is reported to induce the full regeneration cascade at normally non-regenerative stages.",
          "quote": "misexpression of a heterologous (yeast) H + pump is sufficient to induce the whole regeneration cascade in the Xenopus tail at non-regenerative stages",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 3
        }
      ],
      "note": "Meeting perspective; coded the organism-level regeneration findings it reports."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77098",
      "year": 2007,
      "title": "Gap junctions provide new links in left-right patterning",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Coordinated binary fate decision",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "C. elegans AWC olfactory neurons",
          "claim": "A gap-junction-coupled neuron network ensures that one of two symmetric AWC neurons stochastically adopts the ON fate and the other OFF, via feedback between them.",
          "quote": "nsy5 can act autonomously to induce the future AWC ON neuron based on a feedback mechanism between both AWC neurons",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Whole-group context sensitivity",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick and frog embryos",
          "claim": "Left and right sides of the embryo communicate to assign LR identity before asymmetric gene expression.",
          "quote": "the left and right sides of the embryos communicate with each other to correctly assign left-right identity before the onset of asymmetric gene expression",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77099",
      "year": 2006,
      "title": "Ion flow regulates left-right asymmetry in sea urchin development",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "sea urchin (Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus) larvae",
          "claim": "H+/K+-ATPase-dependent ion flux is needed for the consistently left-sided formation of the adult rudiment in sea urchin larvae.",
          "quote": "Exposure to omeprazole disrupted the consistent asymmetry of adult rudiment formation in larvae.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Ion-flux requirement for consistent LR asymmetry in an invertebrate deuterostome."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77103",
      "year": 2006,
      "title": "Mathematical model of morphogen electrophoresis through gap junctions",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Persistence under repeated disturbance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "Xenopus embryo LR patterning",
          "claim": "The LR system has under 1% defects and regulates and restores LR signals after short pulses of perturbing reagents.",
          "quote": "revealing the ability of the system to regulate and restore LR signals when perturbed",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9,
          "map_to": "Robustness to pathogens, toxins and stress"
        },
        {
          "name": "Parameter-insensitive robust gradient formation",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "mathematical model of serotonin electrophoresis through gap junctions",
          "claim": "The final LR morphogen gradient depends only on the voltage difference, not on gap-junction number or geometry, giving robustness without feedback loops.",
          "quote": "This independence of a large number of parameters and molecular details reveals a novel method of generating a gradient that does not rely on feedback loops",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77104",
      "year": 2006,
      "title": "Inverse drug screens: a rapid and inexpensive method for implicating molecular targets",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Methods paper on hierarchical inverse drug screens; tool only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77111",
      "year": 2005,
      "title": "Localization and loss-of-function implicates ciliary proteins in early, cytoplasmic roles in left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis and chick embryos",
          "claim": "Early microtubule-dependent motor protein function is required for oriented LR asymmetry in frog embryos, consistent with cytoplasmic rather than ciliary roles.",
          "quote": "loss-of-function experiments implicated very early intracellular microtubule-dependent motor protein function as an obligate aspect of oriented LR asymmetry in Xenopus embryos",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Cytoskeletal/motor requirement framed as part of orienting LR asymmetry."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77112",
      "year": 2005,
      "title": "Xenopus TRPN1 (NOMPC) localizes to microtubule-based cilia in epithelial cells, including inner-ear hair cells",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Localization of TRPN1 channel to kinocilia of hair cells; sensory-cell biology, no capability claim."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77113",
      "year": 2005,
      "title": "BMP-3 is a novel inhibitor of both activin and BMP-4 signaling in Xenopus embryos",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "BMP-3 antagonism of activin/BMP via ActRIIB; molecular signalling not framed as a capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77114",
      "year": 2005,
      "title": "Left-right asymmetry in embryonic development: a comprehensive review",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Laterality instruction between conjoined twins",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick, frog, fish, human conjoined twins",
          "claim": "Laterality defects in one conjoined twin may be induced by LR morphogens crossing over from the adjacent twin.",
          "quote": "laterality defects in one twin may be induced by cross-over of LR morphogen molecules from the adjacent twin",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 13
        },
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "vertebrate and invertebrate embryos",
          "claim": "Invariant LR asymmetry of heart, viscera and brain links biomolecular chirality to organism-level anatomy and cognition.",
          "quote": "The mechanisms which ensure invariant LR asymmetry of the heart, viscera, and brain represent a thread connecting biomolecular chirality to human cognition",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77115",
      "year": 2005,
      "title": "Serotonin transporter function is an early step in left-right patterning in chick and frog embryos",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis and chick embryos",
          "claim": "Serotonin transporter (SERT/VMAT) function during cleavage stages is required for normal laterality of heart and viscera.",
          "quote": "Pharmacological or genetic inhibitors of either SERT or VMAT specifi cally randomized the laterality of the heart and viscera in Xenopus embryos.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Serotonin-transport requirement framed as an early step in LR patterning."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77117",
      "year": 2004,
      "title": "A novel immunohistochemical method for evaluation of antibody specificity and detection of labile targets in biological tissue",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Immunohistochemistry method for antibody specificity; methods only."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77118",
      "year": 2004,
      "title": "The embryonic origins of left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "vertebrate embryos",
          "claim": "The review proposes that consistent LR asymmetry originates very early from differences in ion flux across the embryonic midline, as an alternative to the cilia model.",
          "quote": "it is proposed that asymmetry is driven, at very early stages, by differences in ion flux across the embryonic midline",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ],
      "note": "Controversy review proposing an ion-flux/cytoplasmic-transport origin of LR asymmetry."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77119",
      "year": 2004,
      "title": "Early Patterning of the Left/Right Axis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Laterality instruction between conjoined twins",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick conjoined twins",
          "claim": "Signals from one primitive streak (e.g. right-sided Activin) can alter LR gene expression in an adjacent twin, predicting which twin shows laterality defects.",
          "quote": "parallel streaks during early gastrulation could result in the right-sided Activin of the left embryo inhibiting the expression of Shh in the left side of the right embryo",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 9
        }
      ],
      "note": "Mostly a review of molecular LR patterning mechanisms across vertebrates."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77120",
      "year": 2003,
      "title": "Fusicoccin signaling reveals 14-3-3 protein function as a novel step in left-right patterning during amphibian embryogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos",
          "claim": "14-3-3 protein function, revealed via fusicoccin, is an extremely early required step in LR patterning; perturbing it causes heterotaxia.",
          "quote": "we show that 14-3-3E protein is likely to be an endogenous and extremely early aspect of LR patterning",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Molecular requirement framed as part of LR asymmetry determination."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77121",
      "year": 2003,
      "title": "Bioelectromagnetics in morphogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Stopping when the target is reached",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "segmented earthworm regeneration",
          "claim": "Regenerating earthworms add segments until about 90, apparently stopping when total body voltage reaches the full-length value.",
          "quote": "segments are added until the overall voltage totals the correct endogenous value for a full length worm",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Induced regeneration in non-regenerative states",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "adult frog limbs, mammals",
          "claim": "Applied steady electric fields can initiate limb regeneration in normally non-regenerating species.",
          "quote": "minute, steady electrical fields imposed within forelimb stumps of adult frogs initiated limb regeneration",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "amphibians, planaria, human children's fingertips",
          "claim": "Regeneration recreates existing structures in mature tissue, even in humans for severed fingertips under the right conditions.",
          "quote": "human children will regenerate severed fingertips if the stump is not pulled over with skin after a clean amputation",
          "page": 3,
          "page_end": 4
        },
        {
          "name": "Defection and repair of group boundaries",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "tumors, teratomas",
          "claim": "Cancer is framed as an error of geometry in which cells grow without regard for the orderly structure of the whole.",
          "quote": "Tumor cells grow, migrate, and function without regard for the orderly structure within which they occur.",
          "page": 8,
          "page_end": 8
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77122",
      "year": 2003,
      "title": "Motor protein control of ion flux is an early step in embryonic left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "vertebrate embryos",
          "claim": "Laterality is proposed to originate from asymmetric localization of electrogenic proteins by cytoplasmic motors, producing pH/voltage gradients across the midline.",
          "quote": "asymmetric localization of electrogenic proteins by cytoplasmicmotors",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77123",
      "year": 2002,
      "title": "Asymmetries in H+/K+-ATPase and cell membrane potentials comprise a very early step in left-right patterning",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis and chick embryos",
          "claim": "Consistent LR orientation depends on a very early H+/K+-ATPase-driven differential ion flux and voltage asymmetry.",
          "quote": "Thus, LR asymmetry determination depends on a very early differential ion flux created by H÷/K÷-ATPase activity.",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Ion-pump requirement framed as an early step in LR patterning (text uses ÷ for +)."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77124",
      "year": 2002,
      "title": "Early embryonic expression of ion channels and pumps in chick and Xenopus development",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Expression survey of ion channel/pump genes in early embryos; descriptive resource, no capability claim."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77125",
      "year": 2002,
      "title": "Katp channel activity is required for hatching in Xenopus embryos",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "KATP activity required for hatching-gland function; embryonic physiology (hatching) is not one of the competency capabilities."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77127",
      "year": 2001,
      "title": "Left-Right asymmetry determination in vertebrates",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "vertebrates",
          "claim": "The review reports that the direction of LR asymmetry is consistent among normal individuals and conserved across species, and examines how it is achieved.",
          "quote": "Remarkably, the direction of left-right asymmetry is consistent among all normal individuals in a species and, for many organs, is also conserved across species",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Review of the steps of vertebrate LR determination."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77128",
      "year": 2001,
      "title": "Asymmetry of Body and Brain: Embryological and Twin Studies",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Laterality instruction between conjoined twins",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick and human conjoined twins",
          "claim": "LR pathway molecules cross the blastoderm and affect the conjoined embryo, with geometry and timing determining which twin shows situs anomalies.",
          "quote": "These are both based on molecules in the LR pathway crossing some distance in the blastoderm and affecting the conjoined embryo.",
          "page": 4,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ],
      "note": "Encyclopedia entry on body/brain asymmetry and twinning."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77129",
      "year": 2000,
      "title": "Expression of connexin 30 in Xenopus embryos and its involvement in hatching gland function",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Connexin 30/gap junctions in hatching-gland secretion; embryonic physiology (hatching), not a competency capability."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77131",
      "year": 1999,
      "title": "Twinning and embryonic left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Laterality instruction between conjoined twins",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick and human conjoined twins",
          "claim": "Laterality defects in side-by-side conjoined twins are explained by LR pathway molecules crossing the blastoderm and affecting the adjacent embryo.",
          "quote": "These are both based on molecules in the LR pathway crossing some distance in the blastoderm and affecting the conjoined embryo.",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ],
      "note": "Review of twinning and LR asymmetry."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77132",
      "year": 1999,
      "title": "Cerberus regulates left-right asymmetry of the embryonic head and heart",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "chick embryos",
          "claim": "Left-sided Cerberus helps set head and heart laterality; misexpressing it on the right reversed heart and head turning.",
          "quote": "misexpression of cCer on this side of the embryo led to upregulation of the transcription factor Pitx2 and reversal of the direction of heart and head turning",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Signalling requirement framed as part of laterality decisions in head and trunk."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77134",
      "year": 1999,
      "title": "Left-right asymmetry in animal embryogenesis",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Laterality instruction between conjoined twins",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick, amphibian and human conjoined twins",
          "claim": "Asymmetrically expressed signals on one side of a twin may affect the opposite side of the adjacent twin, explaining situs defects in side-by-side twins.",
          "quote": "the asymmetrically-expressed genes on one side of one twin might affect the development of the opposite side of the adjacent twin",
          "page": 5,
          "page_end": 5
        }
      ],
      "note": "General review of LR asymmetry."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77137",
      "year": 1998,
      "title": "Gap junctions are involved in the early generation of left right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Symmetry breaking and laterality from cell chirality",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Xenopus laevis embryos",
          "claim": "Dorsoventral differences in gap-junctional communication are needed to orient LR asymmetry consistently; altering them induced heterotaxia.",
          "quote": "Heterotaxia was induced by either blocking gap junction communication (GJC) dorsally or by introducing communication ventrally (but not the reverse).",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Gap-junction requirement framed as part of consistently orienting the LR axis."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77138",
      "year": 1998,
      "title": "Evolutionary conservation of mechanisms upstream of asymmetric nodal expression: Reconciling chick and Xenopus",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Regeneration of a target pattern",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "chick and Xenopus lateral mesoderm explants",
          "claim": "Lateral tissue explanted away from the midline regenerates node/notochord structures that express Shh, restoring midline signalling.",
          "quote": "explanted lateral tissue regenerates node/notochord structures exhibiting Shh expression",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77140",
      "year": 1998,
      "title": "The compulsion of chirality: toward an understanding of left-right asymmetry",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "vertebrate embryos",
          "claim": "The review addresses how molecular chirality (e.g. dynein) is transmitted across cell fields to produce morphological and behavioural asymmetry.",
          "quote": "we discuss the nature of the information flow from molecular chirality to morphological and behavioral asymmetry",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77141",
      "year": 1997,
      "title": "Applied DC magnetic fields cause alterations in the time of cell divisions and developmental abnormalities in early sea urchin embryos",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Habituation",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "sea urchin eggs exposed to static magnetic fields",
          "claim": "Longer field exposures did not produce larger cell-division delays, a bell-curve response the authors suggest may reflect a habituation process in the egg.",
          "quote": "a bell-curve relationship around a maximal value is observed which may represent some sort of habituation process within egg",
          "page": 13,
          "page_end": 14
        }
      ],
      "note": "Mainly a bioelectromagnetics study of static field effects on sea urchin development; the habituation interpretation is speculative."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77143",
      "year": 1997,
      "title": "Two molecular models of initial left-right asymmetry generation",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Amplifying cell chirality to body-scale asymmetry",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "vertebrate embryos (dynein and Cx43 models)",
          "claim": "Dynein is proposed to set cell-autonomous LR bias, and asymmetric Cx43 gap junction activity to convert this into large-scale LR asymmetry across multicellular fields.",
          "quote": "asymmetric activity of Cx43 gap junctions within key cells sets up electric potentials in multi-cellular fields, thus establishing large-scale LR asymmetry",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        },
        {
          "name": "Independent organ-level decisions",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "chick embryo, human isomerism",
          "claim": "With bilateral Nodal, each organ independently decides its situs at random rather than forming two identical left sides.",
          "quote": "causes a heterotaxic phenotype where each organ decides its situs randomly",
          "page": 9,
          "page_end": 10
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77149",
      "year": 1995,
      "title": "Locating putative protein signal sequences",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Genetic algorithm for locating protein signal sequences; bioinformatics, unrelated."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77150",
      "year": 1994,
      "title": "A Julia set model of field-directed morphogenesis: developmental biology and artificial life",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Complex form from minimal positional-information rules",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Julia-set computer model of field-directed morphogenesis",
          "claim": "A model of two mutually regulating genes interpreting a positional field produces rich organism-like morphologies, chaotic differentiation and sharp edges.",
          "quote": "only two interacting genes are sufficient for (i) complex pattern formation, (ii) chaotic differentiation behavior, and (Hi) production of sharp edges from a continuous positional information field",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Noise and asynchronous update tolerance",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "Julia-set computer model of field-directed morphogenesis",
          "claim": "Adding random error to positional readout did not simply blur the form: parts stayed untouched while others were duplicated, a model of how embryos respond to perturbation.",
          "quote": "Note that part of the image is completely untouched, while another part is duplicated, and spatially shifted.",
          "page": 11,
          "page_end": 11
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77152",
      "year": 1993,
      "title": "Current and potential applications of bioelectromagnetics in medicine",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Inducing regeneration where it normally fails",
          "existing": true,
          "kind": "reported",
          "system": "adult mammals and other vertebrates exposed to applied electric fields",
          "claim": "The perspective reports that applied fields of in vivo type can accelerate regeneration and produce regeneration in normally non-regenerating adult mammals.",
          "quote": "applied fields of the type found in vivo can accelerate regeneration in such species, and more interestingly, effect regeneration in normally non-regenerating animals such as adult mammals",
          "page": 2,
          "page_end": 2
        }
      ],
      "note": "Speculative medical perspective; coded only its reported regeneration statement."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77153",
      "year": 1985,
      "title": "Creating graphics with mathematical functions",
      "competencies": [],
      "note": "Hobbyist article on drawing graphics with mathematical functions; unrelated."
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77157",
      "year": 1997,
      "title": "Left/right patterning signals and the independent regulation of different aspects of situs in the chick embryo",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Independent organ-level decisions",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "chick embryo",
          "claim": "Bilateral Shh/nodal expression produces heterotaxia in which heart, gut and embryonic rotation determine their laterality independently.",
          "quote": "produces a heterotaxia-like condition, where different aspects of laterality are determined independently",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "paper_id": "77159",
      "year": 2005,
      "title": "Characterization of innexin gene expression and functional roles of gap-junctional communication in planarian regeneration",
      "competencies": [
        {
          "name": "Long-range information flow in regeneration",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "demonstrated",
          "system": "planarian regeneration (innexins)",
          "claim": "Innexin-based gap junctional communication mediates long-range instructive signals that specify blastema identity; blocking it produces two-headed worms.",
          "quote": "the respecification of the posterior blastema to an anteriorized fate by GJC loss-of-function suggest that innexin-based GJC mediates instructive signaling during regeneration",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        },
        {
          "name": "Cells inferring their position in the body",
          "existing": false,
          "kind": "proposed",
          "system": "planarian",
          "claim": "Previously adjacent cells adopting head vs tail fates after bisection implies long-range signalling about position relative to, and identity of, remaining tissue.",
          "quote": "long-range signaling allowing determination of position relative to, and the identity of, remaining tissue",
          "page": 1,
          "page_end": 1
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "missing": [],
  "total_expected": 338
}
